Hey guys, I need some opinions on this one... For my dynasty league (12 keepers)... PPR, 6 pts TDs, 4 pt TD passes, 10 yds/pt, etc Would you take this trade? LeSean McCoy for Michael Crabtree Which side of the trade would you want to be on?
What's the rest of your team like? I'm not as high on McCoy as a lot of people. I just don't see anything special when I watched him last year. They also have a lot of other RBs to steal GL work. Crabtree def has more upside in ppr, imo.
It's the same team that I had posted my keepers question to. At RB: CJ2k Sjax RBrown Barber At WR: Boldin Crabtree MSW Hines Ward Bowe Garcon Evans at TE: Celek Gonzo ------------------------- On a side note, would you consider Crabtree for any of the following: -J.Stewart -Moreno -D.Brown -Grant Don't know if he would but might be worth a shot.
You're stacked at RB so I wouldn't trade what could end up being your best 1-2 WR for an RB that I can't see outproducing CJ or SJ. Crabtree for Stewart would def be the best for me. But seeing as how you need a stud WR, I'd prob keep him.
I'm really not a Ryan Grant fan. He puts up too many single digit and low double digit games for my liking. Stewart has more talent and should be the better keeper if Deangelo Williams leaves.
I like McCoy a lot especially in a PPR league given Andy Reids unwillingness to commit to the running game regularly. I just dealt Shonn Greene in a keeper league to get Crabtree and didnt think twice about it. Crabtree is a keeper imo, even though his QB situation is eh. he could become a true #1 for fantasy. He had 600 in an abbreviated season last year.
well you have four good backs and only two good wr options so I'd hold crabtree. If you want mccoy that badly trade sims walker and barber or brown for mccoy and a lesser back with some upside. Hardesty or ahmad bradshaw might be good guys to look at if the team you are dealing with has one. Or you could deal boldin before his value drops like I think it will in the Baltimore passing attack