1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Billy Joel or Elton John

Discussion in 'TV, Music and Movies' started by TrueDolFan, Jun 22, 2009.

Billy Joel or Elton John?

  1. Billy Joel

    13 vote(s)
    50.0%
  2. Elton John

    13 vote(s)
    50.0%
  1. TrueDolFan

    TrueDolFan Minion of Satan

    1,330
    585
    0
    Jun 17, 2008
    Twin Cities, MN
    I had the pleasure of seeing their Face 2 Face tour here in Saint Paul back on May 5. One of the best shows I've ever seen, both of these guys are musically on a whole 'nother level.

    Two bona fide living legends. Who do you like better?

    My vote is for Elton.
     
  2. GARDENHEAD

    GARDENHEAD Season Ticket Holder Club Member

    11,681
    10,413
    113
    May 7, 2008
    New Orleans
    I can't stand Billy Joel. Schmaltzy bastard.
     
    azfinfanmang likes this.
  3. Pagan

    Pagan Metal & a Mustang

    20,329
    39,767
    113
    Mar 22, 2008
    Newburgh, NY
    You need to listen to something besides what the radio plays then, and besides....Elton isn't schmaltzy???

    Jesus W. Christ on a backhoe..."Someone Saved My Life Tonight", "Sorry Seems to Be The Hardest Word", and "Harmony"???

    Dude....:lol:

    I've seen the Face 2 Face tour twice. They're both amazing. My vote goes to Billy for two reasons.

    One, he's a fellow NYer. :D

    Two...he writes ALL the parts of his songs. Elton doesn't write his own lyrics. Bernie Taupin does.

    In that aspect, Joel is the better songwriter.
     
  4. slickj101

    slickj101 Is Water

    15,886
    8,901
    113
    Dec 21, 2007
    NY
    Right. If Elton wrote his own songs he might get my vote.

    Billy Joel has "piano man" though so maybe not.
     
  5. slickj101

    slickj101 Is Water

    15,886
    8,901
    113
    Dec 21, 2007
    NY
    Wtf is schmaltzy?

    Is that like a Jewish slur or something?
     
  6. SICK

    SICK Lounge Moderator

    72,658
    35,312
    113
    Nov 29, 2007
    Charlotte NC
    i went with elton.....rocket man is like top 5 of my all time favorite songs
     
  7. Pagan

    Pagan Metal & a Mustang

    20,329
    39,767
    113
    Mar 22, 2008
    Newburgh, NY
    Yea, but for every "Piano Man" Billy has a "Goodnight Saigon" to counter it. :wink2:

    NOTHING Elton write ever matched that song, IMO.
     
    DrAstroZoom likes this.
  8. slickj101

    slickj101 Is Water

    15,886
    8,901
    113
    Dec 21, 2007
    NY
    "Piano Man" tops everything else from these 2, IMO.
     
  9. GARDENHEAD

    GARDENHEAD Season Ticket Holder Club Member

    11,681
    10,413
    113
    May 7, 2008
    New Orleans
    They are both schmaltzy, but Joel is way worse.

    Good definition from wikipedia: In American English, schmaltz (adj. schmaltzy) has also an informal meaning of excessively sentimental or florid music or art or maudlin sentimentality. Its earliest usage in this sense dates to the mid 1930's.

    Elton redeems himself cause he's flamboyantly gay. Gotta respect that. He don't care. Joel has no excuses.
     
  10. slickj101

    slickj101 Is Water

    15,886
    8,901
    113
    Dec 21, 2007
    NY
    So sentimentality makes for bad music? That doesn't make any sense.
     
    Pagan likes this.
  11. GARDENHEAD

    GARDENHEAD Season Ticket Holder Club Member

    11,681
    10,413
    113
    May 7, 2008
    New Orleans
    Excessively sentimental music is bad. Its in the eye of the beholder.
     
  12. muscle979

    muscle979 Season Ticket Holder

    15,863
    6,275
    113
    Dec 12, 2007
    Evans, GA
    This was tough. I gave Billy Joel the nod mostly because of how much I like the song "Piano man". It was close.
     
  13. #1 fan

    #1 fan Well-Known Member

    2,161
    558
    113
    Dec 20, 2007
    miami
    big "goodbye yellow brick road" fan. had to go with elton.
     
  14. bkbuffet

    bkbuffet Season Ticket Holder

    1,148
    442
    0
    Nov 28, 2007
    Omaha, NE
    Billy gets my vote. One of my favorite artists and he puts on an excellent live show.
    Elton is too much a Diva... and I'm not saying that because of his sexual preference.

    Billy may have a few Schmaltzy songs, but he has plenty that are not. He also is a big supporter of his community and has a genuine interest in teaching music to others.
    I think Elton is more about the attention and the money.
     
  15. PrepDogg

    PrepDogg Rock hard....Ride Free

    1,131
    338
    0
    Apr 19, 2008
    It's close But I'll take Elton John cuz he has a better voice and 'Don't let the sun go down on me' is one of my favorite songs ever. I've always wanted to them live.
     
  16. slickj101

    slickj101 Is Water

    15,886
    8,901
    113
    Dec 21, 2007
    NY
    That statement is ridiculous.









    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]




    Like I said, completely ridiculous.
     
  17. Pagan

    Pagan Metal & a Mustang

    20,329
    39,767
    113
    Mar 22, 2008
    Newburgh, NY
    ~ "Philadelphia Freedom"
    ~ "Don't Go Breaking My Heart"

    'Nuff said. :tongue2:
     
    GARDENHEAD likes this.
  18. azfinfanmang

    azfinfanmang Premium Member Luxury Box

    29,745
    11,512
    0
    Nov 23, 2007
    Elton John hands down.

    Even with all the CRAP *cough*Candle in the wind *cough* he did, his early stuff easily outweighs both his crap and ALL of Billy Joel's.

    Sorry, I dont think its just coincedence his Initials are BJ.
     
    gunn34 likes this.
  19. cnc66

    cnc66 wiley veteran, bad spelur Luxury Box

    31,582
    17,137
    0
    Nov 23, 2007
    Bernie Taupin wrote his early stuff
     
  20. azfinfanmang

    azfinfanmang Premium Member Luxury Box

    29,745
    11,512
    0
    Nov 23, 2007
    What surprises me is that you didn't pick up on the incredible IRONY in my post.
     
  21. FinSane

    FinSane Cynical Dolphins Fan

    19,862
    5,792
    113
    Dec 1, 2007
    Melbourne, Fl
    Goodbye yellow brick roooooaaaaddddddd

    Elton. I only like two Billy Joel songs and thats "We Didnt Start the Fire" and "Piano Man".
     
  22. GARDENHEAD

    GARDENHEAD Season Ticket Holder Club Member

    11,681
    10,413
    113
    May 7, 2008
    New Orleans
    We Didn't Start The Fire is an abortion. I forgot about that one.

    Elton should win cause he didn't write that song!

    Oh, and Billy supports his community so that when he gets pulled over for drunk driving, the cops let him off...until he drives his car into someone's house!!!
     
  23. HolliFinFan

    HolliFinFan Not a Face Painter Luxury Box

    2,220
    1,480
    113
    Nov 24, 2007
    South Florida
    I truly enjoy and appreciate both performers. I voted for Elton John because my iPod more frequently choses him. Btw, I love the song "Harmony" to the haters :lol: Tough poll for sure. Both are brilliant musicians with storied lives who continue to contribute to both the industry and communities. Great idea for this poll, btw.
    For what it's worth, "Grey Seal" is a tune that has not been mentioned and I really like.
     
  24. HolliFinFan

    HolliFinFan Not a Face Painter Luxury Box

    2,220
    1,480
    113
    Nov 24, 2007
    South Florida
    I guess CNC and I are dumm :lol:
     
  25. TrueDolFan

    TrueDolFan Minion of Satan

    1,330
    585
    0
    Jun 17, 2008
    Twin Cities, MN
    You still gotta give it up to Elton for his ability to take Taupin's lyrics and put them to music. A lot of people don't realize that they don't actually sit down together and write songs. Taupin writes the lyrics, then John sets them to music.

    Being a musician (and I assume writing songs with your band), you know that is just not the "normal" way songs get written, and how incredibly crazy it would be for somebody to hand you lyrics and say, "write the music for this".

    Elton John is phenomenal.
     
    gunn34 likes this.
  26. DrAstroZoom

    DrAstroZoom Canary in a Coal Mine Luxury Box

    9,033
    9,005
    113
    Jan 8, 2008
    Springfield, Ill.
    They're both quite talented, but Billy Joel gets my vote for his songwriting and superior piano skills.
     
    NaboCane likes this.
  27. gunn34

    gunn34 I miss Don & Dan

    21,755
    3,475
    113
    Jan 5, 2008
    Oviedo FL
    I went with Elton.

    Both have some cheezy material. I think Elton has the bigger catalog. Someone Saved My Life Tonight, Empty Gardens, Levon, Bennie and the Jets far outweigh his bad stuff... I Guess That's Why They Call It the Blues, This Train Don't Stop There Anymore

    Joels songs like Honesty, Piano Man, and Only The Good Die Young are great songs. But when he's bad, IMO he's worse then Elton's bad stuff. His horrible An Innocent Man album alone swayed me to select Elton.
     
  28. Pagan

    Pagan Metal & a Mustang

    20,329
    39,767
    113
    Mar 22, 2008
    Newburgh, NY
    I never said Elton wasn't phenominal, but anyone who writes music can write to written lyrics. In fact, alot of times it's better to have the lyrics first. That way you know what the song is about, and the music can fit the overall mood and tone of the lyrics. Believe it or not, in most cases it's EASIER, because the composer reads the lyrics and melody lines come out.

    I'm the lyricist in my band, and we do it both ways. I'll either write to what my guitarist or keyboardist gives me musically, or I'll get a brainstorm and come up with some lyrics that they'll compose some music for.

    It's more "normal" than you think.

    Don't get me wrong, I love Elton and have most of his CDs on my iPod, but for sheer songwriting he doesn't compare to Billy's ability to put himself into the shoes of someone he's never met and tell their life story in a lyric, as well as write the music to match. Or his ability to paint a vivid picture of what he's singing about. Elton just doesn't do that with his music.

    "Downeaster Alexa" and "Allentown" are prime examples, as is the song I mentioned before, "Goodnight Saigon".

    Listen to "New York State of Mind", and if you're a New Yorker, he nails it. And "Miami 2017" is just amazing.

    The only song by Elton that comes near matching the power and intensity of that is "Funeral For a Friend/Love Lies Bleeding".

    They're both amazing, and seeing them both together is not to be missed. But all in all, Billy's music is deeper than Elton's. Elton is more pop oriented.
     
    Rocky Raccoon likes this.
  29. DrAstroZoom

    DrAstroZoom Canary in a Coal Mine Luxury Box

    9,033
    9,005
    113
    Jan 8, 2008
    Springfield, Ill.
    I'd rather write lyrics from music than the other way around, personally.
     
    Pagan likes this.
  30. TrueDolFan

    TrueDolFan Minion of Satan

    1,330
    585
    0
    Jun 17, 2008
    Twin Cities, MN
    I guess I thought that most lyrics were written with the melody already in mind, then the rest of the music written around that.
     
    Pagan likes this.
  31. Pagan

    Pagan Metal & a Mustang

    20,329
    39,767
    113
    Mar 22, 2008
    Newburgh, NY
    So would I Doc...just pointing out that it can go both ways. :wink2:
    Most are, but not always. :)
     
  32. Rocky Raccoon

    Rocky Raccoon Greasepaint Ghost Staff Member

    30,224
    36,965
    113
    Dec 2, 2007
    Jersey
    Love Billy Joel. Just listened to "Goodnight Saigon" again, he is a freaking genius and though Elton is good too, Billy wins hands down. I know I'm late on this thread but listening to "Goodnight Saigon" really put it over the top for me. Honestly, I know most of Billy's stuff, both hits and unknowns and I only really listened to this song for the first time recently and it blew my mind. Just incredible.
     
    NaboCane likes this.
  33. NaboCane

    NaboCane Banned

    31,949
    11,899
    0
    Nov 24, 2007
    Billy Joel writes both his own music and lyrics.

    Elton John without Bernie Taupin was mediocre at best.
     
  34. NaboCane

    NaboCane Banned

    31,949
    11,899
    0
    Nov 24, 2007
    Ah; his infamous "Kiki Dee" period. :barf:
     
  35. phunwin

    phunwin Happy kids are Dolfans. Luxury Box

    Up until the early 80s, this would have been close (Elton's Kiki Dee/Billy Jean King era notwithstanding). Both had phenomenal range through the 70s. We forget now, but Elton also had some awesome dark and soulful music then; Madman Across the Water is every bit a match for Goodnight Saigon. But Elton faded badly and was essentially writing elevator music by the 90s. Billy still had some good work left in him; the "River of Dreams" album was quality.

    What clinches it is the Princess Di Candle in the Wind remake. That song was, while a touching attempt to pay tribute (oh, and to make a ****pile of money, too), an absolute catastrophe. He took his best song, a song with a powerful, poignant message (Hollywood's corruption of a beautiful young woman) and turned it into a song so full of sap that listeners had to blow their nose with a pancake. Billy Joel would never, ever pull something like that with Piano Man.
     
    NaboCane likes this.
  36. gunn34

    gunn34 I miss Don & Dan

    21,755
    3,475
    113
    Jan 5, 2008
    Oviedo FL
    You can't believe that.

    Money talks.
     

Share This Page