And another Parker catch is listed as the best play for the Dolphins from week 2. It's alright, but weren't they watching Jay Ajayi? Dolphins play starts at 4:39...
Yeah I don't agree with that order at all. It's almost in reverse order. I'd put #4 (Parker) and #5 (Rudolph) above the other 3, though #1 isn't that bad. That Rudolph catch was like an Oronde Gadsen clone (but with less wingspan).
It's all subjective. Very few "top 5" catches are truly special anyway, like that helmet catch that prevented NE from winning a SB, or that Odell Beckham one-handed catch while being held/fouled on the play.