1 Steven Hauschka BAL K 2 Garrett Hartley NO K 3 Taylor Mehlhaff NO K 4 Dan Carpenter MIA K 5 Connor Barth KC K Here were the other rookie kickers that did anything this year. A weak class, but Carpenter is certainly the standout in my opinion. Matter of fact, Carpenter led ALL rookies (regardless of position) in scoring with 103 points.