He just is. I don't care about the championships. I don't care about the divisional success. Those aren't QB stats. Aaron Rodgers is a better QB on a worse team. If you don't see that you're either not looking or not thinking. Aaron Rodgers has done, and is still doing, that thing everyone says a great QB needs to do - carrying his team. Tom Brady doesn't do that anywhere near as often because his teams are better. Maybe he could do it, but he hasn't had to. Aaron Rodgers though? He's picked up a lame team and hiked it up a mountain several times. If Brady is the GOAT, Rodgers is the Mountain GOAT. One walks around a petting stall where everyone fawns over him. The other one regularly assails precipitous cliffs and those who look ask, "How on earth has he done that?!"