Ian Kinsler or Felix Hernandez? Which one should I keep? League categories are standard 5x5, except that we sub OBP for batting average, and OBP against for WHIP.
-
phunwin Happy kids are Dolfans. Luxury Box
-
I will try to help you but I need you to answer a few questions for me: How many teams are in your league? How many players per team? Who else is currently on your team already? Is this a normal draft or is it an auction league? -
-
What is your re-draft slot?
Do you have a feel for other 2B that would be available in draft?
or other SP?
Who else do you have on your team? Who else you keeping?
What about trading either prior to draft for package deal, etc?
I too would lean Kinsler without knowing the above details, but if you have top slot, keep King Felix and redraft Kinsler....for me, I need additional detials to not vacuum this and simply say Bat over Arm. -
-
My only point was besides from Utley, who's a top 5 pick for sure, the rest of the pack is pretty similar and 2B isn't weak overall like 3B is this year. Sure some guys hit more HRs and drive in more (Uggla, Phillips) but others might steal more bases and score more runs (Roberts). I don't think anyone can for sure say Kinlser or Felix without more information. -
A) plays in a bambox for a team that always plays a lot of 10-8 games
B) Whats harder to find: 2B or SP?
Id continue further but Im not giving away all my secrets for free. Keep Kinsler. Its not really a discussion imo. -
phunwin Happy kids are Dolfans. Luxury Box
Wow, great discussion, thanks all!
To answer the other questions that came up, it's 5x5, 10 teams, and my other keeper is David Wright (we can only keep two; I doubt that I could turn F-Her or Kinsler around into a pick and keep the other). I'm new to the league, so I've no sense of who's going where. I'm picking last in every round, since my team is the defending champ. No snake drafting here, unfortunately.
Roster is: C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF, OF, OF, Util, SP, SP, RP, RP, P, P, P, BN, BN, BN, BN, BN, DL, DL. -
BigDogsHunt likes this.