he forgot to mention that Bell is really fast

 

I was a little confused at seeing a C+ at quarterback and then read nothing but gushing love for Chad. I'm confused :confused:

 

I think you have underrated the offense across the board

 

Yeah, that's a bit strange. I think C+ is way too low. I know we may not have the best QB situation in the league, but Chad P had an awful lot to do with our success last year, and probably will again this year. We have a good young QB prospect in Henne, and a versatile guy sitting at 3rd string in Pat White. Id say B-, or B at least.

 

I can see how someone could give Miami a C+. Henne and White are not known. It still remains to be seen that they can start for more than one game and play well.

Pennington is also a quarterback that dispite having what is arguably the 2nd best season in Dolphin history, has yet to have two good seasons in a row for his career.

 

He said he wasn't impressed with Donald Thomas because he only played in one game. Someone should tell him he got injured. But the guy knows a lot for not being an AFC Fan

 

How we got a C+ at QB and an A at DL?

 

a bit out of wack on a few things, but not bad for being a fan of another team

 

Pennington desrves at least a B.

 

Our QB grade should be an A, IMO. Pennington isn't the best QB in the league, but he is perfect for our offense. And he does a great job as a leader.

I think our WR/TE grade should be a B, but I don't blame him for giving us a C-. We have question marks there.

The funniest grade is ST. B? Really?

 

I don't disagree with this. However, maybe this should have been the piece in the article, C+ would have made more sense then. :yes:

 

I don't know if he was rating the entire QB stable. I took it as being a grade just for Pennington as the starter. But who knows. Still, Pennington deservers better than a C+ based on his body of work. Even if you think Pennington is a C+, do you think Trent Edwards is as good a QB? Because he got a C+ too.

Interesting read nonetheless.

 

I would subtract from the DL one letter grade and I'd give that to our QBs. Otherwise, it's about as good as any other.