Rules are simple: Pick the Dolphins draft picks based on CBS's NFL Draft Prospects rankings. So, for example, the 38th rated prospect, cannot be available at 42. Rankings available here: http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/prospectrankings/TSX/2012 8: Courtney Upshaw, OLB, Alabama 42: Markelle Martin, FS, Oklahoma St 73: Dwight Jones, WR, North Carolina 104: Brock Osweiler, QB, Arizona State 138: Vick Ballard, HB, Mississippi State 169: Dwight Bentley, CB, Louisiana Lafayette 200: Adrian Robinson, OLB, Temple
Based on their rankings I would draft this way, even though there is no way these people would be available when we pick (minus DeCastro) 8: Riley Reiff, OT, Iowa - Will hold down the RT, and can play LT in a pinch. I think he is better fitted for the RT position and more consistent than Jonathan Martin. 42: Alshon Jeffery, WR, South Carolina - While I like other WRs more than him the value of getting him here is too great. 73: Brandon Weeden, QB, Oklahoma State - Ginger, but don't let the fire crotch fool you, kid can play. 104: Ladarius Green, TE, La.-Lafayette - Great size and speed, finally give us the playmaking TE. 138: Jacquies Smith, OLB, Missouri - Great size and speed. Aldon Smith looked up to Smith while at Missouri. Could be a great pick up here. 169: Ryan Broyles, WR, Oklahoma - He most likely would have to go on IR for the year, but at this pick he is worth it. 200: Donte Paige-Moss, OLB, North Carolina - A player of this much talent at this pick is a no brainer.
8-Riley Reiff, OT, Iowa 42-Bruce Irvin, OLB, West Virgina 73-Cam Johnson, DE, Virgina 104-Ladarius Green, TE, La.-Lafayette 138-Tramain Thomas, FS, Arkansas 169-Jaymes Brooks, OG, Virgina Tech 200-Keshawn Martin, WR, Michigan St I went with a QBless draft as I have a feeling we will get Flynn. Felt like I covered the major areas outside QB.
8. Mark barron- bells replacement great hitting can catch as well 42. Bruce Irvin - explosive olb and can step right in as a pass rusher for us 73. Andrew datko - Colombo should never be in aqua and orange again 104.Kheeston Randall DT (texas)- we don't seem to want to resign our NT and this guy can definitely plug the gap 138. Tramaine Thomas - was a 1-2 pick earlier on but still a solid player 169. Ryan broyles - can come back from his injury and become a fantastic number 2 200. Kellen moore
I think the rankings will change quite a bit, but here are my picks based on the CBS rankings. 8: Ryan Tannehill, QB, Texas A&M- He's raw, but IMO he may have the highest upside of any QB not named Luck. 42: Markelle Martin, FS, Oklahoma State - I think he's the best player at a position of need. 73: Doug Martin, RB, Boise State - This is an insurance pick (Bush/Thomas), but I see near Rice/MJD potential. 104: Ladarius Green, TE, La.-Lafayette - Great size and speed, natural receiving instincts, could be special. 138: Jacquies Smith, OLB, Missouri - Great size and speed. Good first step, could be special. 169: Ryan Broyles, WR, Oklahoma - Another insurance pick (Gates), but before he was injured looked like he could have Desean Jackson-esque potential. 200: Tank Carder, OLB, TCU - You have to love the name. Injury concerns, but he's heady and a better athlete than people think.
I also think the ratings will change a lot over the course of the offseason as well as my picks when unrestricted free agency begins... but here's basing it off team needs/value. 8 - Courtney Upshaw, OLB, Alabama - Need a playmaker opposite of Cameron Wake, Upshaw is just that. 42 - Markelle Martin, FS, Oklahoma State - We need a serious improvement at the FS spot, Reshad Jones isn't cutting it. 73 - Brandon Weeden, QB, Oklahoma State - Value pick mainly, we can see if he is the real deal or not. 104 - Ryan Steed, CB, Furman - Add some depth in the secondary, maybe give some competition to Carroll/Wilson. 138 - Marvin McNutt, WR, Iowa - Great player this low, we need playmakers and he is one of them. 169 - Ryan Broyles, WR, Oklahoma - Another value pick, he was a first round pick before he got hurt. 200 - Jeff Allen, OT, Illinois - We need some help on the OL, he'd be another body. With this draft, I'd hope our free agents are more offensive line oriented and that we re-signed Soliai (if we stayed in the 3-4) and Langford (not as important as Soliai).
8/9. Quinton Coples - DE, North Carolina 42. Alshon Jeffery - WR, South Carolina 73. Andrew Datko - OT, Florida St. 104. Brock Osweiler - QB, Arizona St. 138. Vick Ballard - RB, Mississippi St. 169. Brandon Taylor - S LSU 200. Nick Provo - TE, Syracuse
8. DE/OLB Courtney Upshaw Alabama 42. WR Alshon Jeffery South Carolina 73. ILB Vontaze Burfict Arizona State 104. QB Brandon Weeden Ok State 138. OT Markus Zusevics Iowa 169. QB Russell Wilson Wisconsin 200. TE Deangelo Peterson LSU
8. Quinton Coples DE 42. Alshon Jeffery WR 73. Vontaze Burfict MLB 104. Brandon Weeden QB 138. Levy Adcock OT 169. Jerrell Young FS 200. Cody Johnson FB
8. OLB, Courtney Upshaw. (Another pass rusher is a massive priority. Love this guy's intensity.) 41. WR, Alshon Jeffery. (could put up some big numbers including redzone w/ Marshall drawing double coverage & Moore's downfield ability). 73. RB, LaMichael James. (James as PR/KR would be a nice compliment to a great D; Philibin will figure out ways to get his talent involved). 104. TE, Ladarius Green. (seems to be a unanimous pick) 138. FS, Tramain Thomas. (2nd team SEC'er has shown an ability to make plays in a variety of ways). 169. OLB, Donte Moss. (can't pass on his talent. Hopefully Greg Little's massive dedication and 1st year success has rubbed off on him.) 200. RT, Levy Adcock. (I'd like to give Philibin a year with our current group before throwing a high pick at Oline). 200b. WR, Greg Childs. (picked up an extra 7th specifically for him. He's a big, physical, playmaking SEC WR with 1st round talent prior to his injury who will push fellow SEC WR, Jeffery. Jeffery, Childs, Green, Gates, Clay, and Marshall would present a constant threat over the top which would allow Bush, Thomas, James, and Marshall plenty of playmaking opportunities underneath, which would in turn allow even more opportunities over the top. The ground game would improve with the safeties kept honest, defenses would become more reactionary, and the play-action game would become dangerous.
#8 David Decastro #40 Brandon Weeden #73 Vontaze Burfect #104 Joe Adams #138 Quentin Saulsbury #169 Davin Megget #200 (think it went for Bush) Desmond Wynn #230 something Emmanual Davis Reaches I'll grant, but I'm surprised Burrfect and Adams are ranked so lowly, I wanted a G/C but could not find a good value in the later rds.