Clabo is very perplexed..
242 replies
"FinNasty wrote:
Has he given up a relatively low number of QB hits in comparison to the number if sacks? If so, he could just be saying that the actual number of sacks is a little fluky and not a reflection of his overall protection.
If true... to that I'd say "well then clearly when you're getting beat... you're getting BEAT. Badly." But that's how I interpreted his statement.
Let me see... If a defensive player comes in unblocked and smears your QB all over the turf, is that a QB hit or a sack? Does it make any difference?
STFU, Clabo. Sit down.
"ckparrothead wrote:
There's really no truth to what Tyson Clabo is saying.
Pro Football Focus keeps data on hits on the quarterback. If you add up sacks and hits, Miami's offensive line (not counting RBs and TEs) is 3rd-worst in the NFL at 31 hits allowed on the quarterback.
So even if every single one of those 19 sacks attributed to the offensive line were converted into just hits on the quarterback, Miami's line is allowing the 3rd-most in the NFL.
So Tyson Clabo really just needs to STFU.
Note: That doesn't account for number of passing plays, either. If you calculate hits per passing play, the Dolphins offensive line (again, not counting tight ends and backs) has allowed THE MOST hits per passing play. So STFU Tyson Clabo. Do your job better.
What Clabo is saying is absolutely true, and the distinction you're making is misleading.
Differentiating between sacks and hits isn't valuable in this context. They both represent offensive line failures, the difference between them has nothing to do with how often those failures occur.
Tannehill is being pressured on 33.8% of snaps. There are 20 quarterbacks in the NFL right now getting pressured at a higher rate per PFF. The amount of pressures(blocking failures) are not particularly noteworthy, it's the amount that are resulting in negative consequences.
"Disgustipate wrote:
What Clabo is saying is absolutely true, and the distinction you're making is misleading.
Differentiating between sacks and hits isn't valuable in this context. They both represent offensive line failures, the difference between them has nothing to do with how often those failures occur.
Tannehill is being pressured on 33.8% of snaps. There are 20 quarterbacks in the NFL right now getting pressured at a higher rate per PFF. The amount of pressures(blocking failures) are not particularly noteworthy, it's the amount that are resulting in negative consequences.
Which is the big mystery that can't seem to be demystified.
"Disgustipate wrote:
What Clabo is saying is absolutely true, and the distinction you're making is misleading.
Differentiating between sacks and hits isn't valuable in this context. They both represent offensive line failures, the difference between them has nothing to do with how often those failures occur.
Tannehill is being pressured on 33.8% of snaps. There are 20 quarterbacks in the NFL right now getting pressured at a higher rate per PFF. The amount of pressures(blocking failures) are not particularly noteworthy, it's the amount that are resulting in negative consequences.
And what people have been trying to make you understand for a while now, is that pressure numbers are not higher because of Tannehill getting rid of the ball quicker. If his amounts of snap holding the ball longer and his average release time, was just merely league average, you can pretty much guarantee those pressure numbers would climb exponentially.
Just the fact that about 95% of the league holds the ball longer than Tannehill means that a lot of the would be pressure is never materializing thanks to him.
Okay - so just to get it out of the way - RT shares a bit of blame here, no doubt. He needs to be a bit more instinctive and aware of the rush. I don't think it's a matter of getting rid of the ball fast enough. He has to do that too often. But, I think it's a matter of when the 2.8-3.0 second clock goes off in his head he needs to start looking for an exit at that point - unless he's standing tall with no one nearby.
But, that does not change the fact that Clabo is getting beat badly at times and to the inside - which is a killer for a QB in the pocket. It may not be pressure but he's often getting shoved back to the QB. The pocket closes in on Tanny like a giant blob (which is what our soft OL is - we have three pretty clear soft guys on the line). They just aren't stout. It is not pressure but it's tighter than some.
It might help to have some more 3 step drops and draws as a variation to keep the defense off balance. But, still, the reality is Clabo has gotten manhandled a few times. Suggs destroyed him a couple of times.
The reality is for an NFL lineman, you can't play great on 25 pass block plays and then play badly on 5. That's 5 potential sacks right there. If the QB escapes a few, it's 2-3. That's just how it is in this league. The margin between good and avg/poor is razor thin. It's that way for QBs and INTs. 2-3 more bad throws in a game may be the difference in a QB who is at the top of the ratings and one who is down around 80.

"Sumlit wrote:
And what people have been trying to make you understand for a while now, is that pressure numbers are not higher because of Tannehill getting rid of the ball quicker. If his amounts of snap holding the ball longer and his average release time, was just merely league average, you can pretty much guarantee those pressure numbers would climb exponentially.
Just the fact that about 95% of the league holds the ball longer than Tannehill means that a lot of the would be pressure is never materializing thanks to him.
That's a collection of ideas people find favorable that I don't think really stands up. Tannehill gets rid of the ball relatively quickly, but there's a huge difference between that(which is fundamentally a part of this offense). He's not forcing the ball out to hot reads, in fact, I'd go so far as to say that's something that rarely in practice happens. The idea that the offense is performing pretty well only by the grace of Tannehill is very much a self-serving idea.
"Disgustipate wrote:
That's a collection of ideas people find favorable that I don't think really stands up. Tannehill gets rid of the ball relatively quickly, but there's a huge difference between that(which is fundamentally a part of this offense). He's not forcing the ball out to hot reads, in fact, I'd go so far as to say that's something that rarely in practice happens. The idea that the offense is performing pretty well only by the grace of Tannehill is very much a self-serving idea.
Your point wasn't about offensive efficiency, but about the total pressure to sacks discrepancy. Fact of the matter is, a lot of would be pressure is not happening because the ball is out quickly. Be it my offensive scheme, or QB skill, or a mixture of both.
What happens or doesn't, after the ball is released is another separate discussion.
Well.We are very perplexed too.We thought we were buying a road grader but we got a turnstile instead.:pity:
"jdang307 wrote:
Its because Tanny gets rid of it so fast. So when he can't, he's sacked.
It could just as plausibly mean he gets rid of the ball too fast.
Either way, its a pretty bad thing to say on Clabo's part. To the degree where I would consider benching him if I were the coach.
“Come on, shake your body baby, do that conga!”
That's a pretty ridiculous thing to say on Clabo's part. He's been bad. I don't care what the percentage of QB hits says. The film does lie. You can see the guy getting destroyed in pass pro over and over again. I'm sure he's frustrated because he's been a good RT his entire career and is now struggling, but he should not be pointing fingers and needs to look in the mirror (or at least at the game film).
Follow me on twitter. Or don't @Adam_Vaccaro
I'm curious how cutting him affects anything... one year contract, $3.5m.. $1.5m guaranteed... vested veteran... I guess if we cut him now he still gets the full amount. :sad:
Twitter @Silver_Hornet (follow me and I'll follow you, just let me know who you are on here!
"Sumlit wrote:
Your point wasn't about offensive efficiency, but about the total pressure to sacks discrepancy. Fact of the matter is, a lot of would be pressure is not happening because the ball is out quickly. Be it my offensive scheme, or QB skill, or a mixture of both.
What happens or doesn't, after the ball is released is another separate discussion.
I think the theory here is that plays aren't being made while under pressure. Its either get the ball out before pressure, or take a sack.
“Come on, shake your body baby, do that conga!”
Clabo is confused? whats so confusing about learning how to block?

MonstBlitz;2232016 wrote:
It wouldn't surprise me if he is retained. Jeff Ireland is the nightmare that won't end. The **** stain you cannot flush. The Herpes for which there is no cure.
There is the link, not sure it works...
But if it doesn't, he had such a sarcastic, shady, underlining tone it was actually quite riveting.

"Stringer Bell wrote:
I think the theory here is that plays aren't being made while under pressure. Its either get the ball out before pressure, or take a sack.
I seem to remember a stat where Tannehill ranked very favorable in passing under pressure.
If you're saying Tannehill needs to improve in reading pre-snap, anticipating the rush, and eluding the rush, I think that is a fair task to ask of him. However, we must also acknowledge that he does not have the time, nor does he have the room to maneuver back there on a consistent basis, and that falls on the protection.
It is fair to ask improvement and growth of Tannehill, but there are others who need to improve more, others who should be more the target of our criticism, and of whom we should be demanding more.
I watched the interview and I think you guys are overreacting a bit. It didn't seem to me like he was pointing any fingers at anyone. He was basically saying that giving up so many sacks with so few QB hits is unusual, and it is. He also went on to say that better protection starts with the 5 guys up front and they need to do their jobs better.
"invid wrote:
Do you know what the sack % is for when he holds the ball past the average 2.5 seconds?
Could it be that our offensive line does a fair job at the initial pass-rush and then kind of gives up on the second effort, and that's why our pressure to sack ratio is so high?
Yes it's inordinately high, about 33%. Highest in the league by a comfortable margin. I think next highest might be around 20%.
It is as you say, the offensive line do not hold their blocks very long. So when Ryan Tannehill holds the ball longer than 2.5 seconds (which QBs in the NFL do statistically about 49% of the time, so it's quite common) he is pressured pretty much every time, and sacked about a third of the time.
Twitter: @ckparrot
3 Yards Per Carry Podcast - Featuring Boomer, Section126, and ckparrothead
threeyardspercarry.podbean.com
"Disgustipate wrote:
What Clabo is saying is absolutely true, and the distinction you're making is misleading.
Differentiating between sacks and hits isn't valuable in this context. They both represent offensive line failures, the difference between them has nothing to do with how often those failures occur.
Tannehill is being pressured on 33.8% of snaps. There are 20 quarterbacks in the NFL right now getting pressured at a higher rate per PFF. The amount of pressures(blocking failures) are not particularly noteworthy, it's the amount that are resulting in negative consequences.
You're asserting something completely different from what Clabo is.
He specifically said hits. He was wrong. Fact. The offensive line has allowed more hits and sacks on Ryan Tannehill per pass play than any other offensive line in football. Fact.
Twitter: @ckparrot
3 Yards Per Carry Podcast - Featuring Boomer, Section126, and ckparrothead
threeyardspercarry.podbean.com
"ckparrothead wrote:
You're asserting something completely different from what Clabo is.
He specifically said hits. He was wrong. Fact. The offensive line has allowed more hits and sacks on Ryan Tannehill per pass play than any other offensive line in football. Fact.
Bears. Beets. Battlestar Galactica.
"Rocky Raccoon wrote:
I watched the interview and I think you guys are overreacting a bit. It didn't seem to me like he was pointing any fingers at anyone. He was basically saying that giving up so many sacks with so few QB hits is unusual, and it is. He also went on to say that better protection starts with the 5 guys up front and they need to do their jobs better.
There's nothing "so few" about the number of hits they've given up on Ryan Tannehill. It's the highest rate in the league.
Twitter: @ckparrot
3 Yards Per Carry Podcast - Featuring Boomer, Section126, and ckparrothead
threeyardspercarry.podbean.com
"Sumlit wrote:
I seem to remember a stat where Tannehill ranked very favorable in passing under pressure.
Which would be all the more reason for it to happen more often.
“Come on, shake your body baby, do that conga!”
Nobody has any complaints about Aaron Rodgers' pocket presence. During the first five games of 2009 when he had poor pass protection from his offensive tackles, he was sacked the same amount per pressure as Tannehill.
Tauscher and Clifton got healthy, the tackles started playing better, wonder of wonders Rodgers stopped taking sacks every third time he was pressured.
When you make it more difficult for a teammate to do his job, he tends not to do it as well. Not rocket science.
Twitter: @ckparrot
3 Yards Per Carry Podcast - Featuring Boomer, Section126, and ckparrothead
threeyardspercarry.podbean.com
If Ryan is outside the pocket and is being chased, and closed in on, he needs to throw the ball away unstead of trying to make the impossible play. Taking a negative play and sack is worse than a loss of down.
"cdz12250 wrote:
Let me see... If a defensive player comes in unblocked and smears your QB all over the turf, is that a QB hit or a sack? Does it make any difference?
STFU, Clabo. Sit down.
How many times has that actually happened?
"GMJohnson wrote:
How many times has that actually happened?
Unblocked hasn't really happened very often. Unblocked would actually be encouraging because it would mean they just have some things to fix schematically.
Much more often the players are blocked, but able to quickly defeat the block, and then come in free from obstruction and able to track Tannehill to where even moving one way or another wouldn't necessarily help.
Twitter: @ckparrot
3 Yards Per Carry Podcast - Featuring Boomer, Section126, and ckparrothead
threeyardspercarry.podbean.com
