Commentary: Feely cut...what the hell?!?

I think alot of people saw this coming.

Yeah, it was somewhat seen coming but still caught me a little by surprise. How often does a team cut a 91% field goal kicker from the previous season? I have my doubts about Carpenter. He has a strong leg but can he make the big time kicks?

We had salary cap room so we could have kept him without any problems. I don't understand this move to be honest.

It is a head scratcher.

I think this had more to do with kickoffs than anything

He was an outspoken players union rep, therefore he had to go. Parcells and Co. won't stand for him trying to speak out against them breaking the status quo they establish. Nothing personal, just business.

why not trade him?

"Mari0k wrote:

why not trade him?

Yeah, at least that. I still don't agree with the move but if Lawrence Tynes can get you a sixth rounder, Feely can get you the same.

"Mari0k wrote:

why not trade him?

I don't think too many teams are going to give up a whole lot for a kicker. And its not like he is the best kicker in the league or anything. Hes a good kicker, maybe he'll catch on somewhere else.

Lets hope that Carpenter gets the job done. If not, we'll be bringing others in for tryouts.

I know the Saints have Grammatica in a battle with the rookie they drafted in the seventh round. There is never a shortage of kickers.

No biggie

"Mari0k wrote:

why not trade him?

For what, a half eaten bag of Doritos and a flat Diet Coke? No one will give up squat for a kicker they know will walk. That way, they can negotiate his contract without having to eat the crap deal he's already got.

Had to make room for that 4th QB. LOL

So we get rid of a good FG kicker who sucks at kickoffs, and replace him with a kicker who also sucks at kickoffs and may be good at FGs.

"Mike13 wrote:

So we get rid of a good FG kicker who sucks at kickoffs, and replace him with a kicker who also sucks at PAT's and may be good at FGs.

Fixed.:sad:

PATs? your worried about the points after touchdowns. haa haa. If this team can find the endzone, i am pretty sure the young guy can make a chip shot.

i worry about a pressure 45 yarder that means the game. hmm

"Timmy54 wrote:

PATs? your worried about the points after touchdowns. haa haa. If this team can find the endzone, i am pretty sure the young guy can make a chip shot.

i worry about a pressure 45 yarder that means the game. hmm

Why wouldn't I be worried about PAT's? The guy missed six in college. How can I expect him to make me a big kick for us in the NFL if he's missing PAT's in college?

"alen1 wrote:

Why wouldn't I be worried about PAT's? The guy missed six in college. How can I expect him to make me a big kick for us in the NFL if he's missing PAT's in college?

Did you see these misses. There is also the snap, the hold, and kick to consider when a feild goal is missed. alot of times expecially in college there is a horrible snap or the holder does something and oops--kicker gets the miss. Kind of like when a QB throws to a wideout and the receiver drops it only to be caught by the defense. you will see alot of that this year too!!!

from what i have seen of this guy, he has a big leg and has been pretty accurate. The front office went to save some cash instead of hoping Feely would be healthy. I just hope it wont cost us a game is all.

"Georgia Fin wrote:

He was an outspoken players union rep, therefore he had to go. Parcells and Co. won't stand for him trying to speak out against them breaking the status quo they establish. Nothing personal, just business.

Thats kind of how I take this as well. Plus we all know how Parcells feels about kickers. For him to be a vocal kicker at that, well we all know about the Vanderjact situation.

Didn't Carpenter drill that first field goal off of the dirt at like 40+ yards Saturday night, that was pretty impressive. :yes:

That being said this is still a dumb move, actually its a Cameron like move, because when you have a good kicker you keep him. Plus if he was cut because he was outspoken for the player's union then I lose some respect for Parcells and Co. (well I never liked Parcells' personality or mindset in the first place, sometimes he puts together a good team sometimes he doesn't until someone else takes over the reigns...ie the Cowboys).

Not a huge move but its dumb overall.

I did not reaslly take me by suprise I saw this coming. But I just dont understand a 91% field goal kicker and we get rid of him. But Carpenter should be good. I hope he can hit the big kicks.

I don't like it. It's not a smart move, IMHO. Still, it's not as if our making the playoffs this season hinges on having Feeley as kicker.

I like this move. Bring in a fresh leg and let's see what the kid can do. He hit those two 40+ yard FG's last week let's see how he does this week.

i'm kind of confused why a lot of people are unhappy with this or questioning the move.

you have two kickers on your roster.

One is a veteran, $1M+ salary, currently is injured, and is vocal and a players rep. The other is an undrafted rookie free agent, getting next to squat in pay, is practicing very well, has outperformed the vet in practice, is healthy, and is confidently booting LONG fieldgoals off dirt in the preseason game.

what is to debate? i think it's pretty straight-forward to me. :)

also, to those asking about trading.... other teams know what is going on, no one is going to give us anything. you better bet that parcells & co were trying the trade angle first. for all we know Feely could have been on the block the last two weeks. :up:

They did try to trade Feely, no takers.

I don't know why so many see this as such a negative. Yes, Feely was great last year for the Dolphins. But I'm much more optimistic in that I see this as a sign of faith in Carpenter.

With him and Fields, wouldn't it be nice to have two young kickers we don't have to worry about for the next 5-10 years?

I see this as a good sign. Like when Jimmy Johnson cut Jack Del Rio because of how impressive Zach Thomas was.

Jack Del Rio played for the Dolphins??:tongue2: