There have been a few threads recently which people have been comparing Tannehill to Wilson. To my mind that's completely stupid because Wilson has inarguably a better QB than Tannehill. A much better comparison figure is Tannehill to Andrew Luck. As Teams both Indy and Miami have been pass heavy, and don't consistently run the ball as well as having inconsistent/poor defenses. They are both AFC teams and play many common opponents. So there is solid basis to compare Luck and Tannehill. Starting point Tannehill's career passer rating in 85.2. Luck's is 85.0. So as passers there is very little to distinguish between the two QBs over their careers. But since RT17 and Lucky to play against the AFC South are in different divisions a better point of comparison is to compare their performances against common opponents. 1: Rest of the AFC East(BUF, NYJ, NE) Tannehill 510 of 888 attempts for 5523 yards. 30 TDs and 25 Ints. Passer Rating 75.39 Luck 169 of 306 attempts for 1962 yards. 11 TDs and 12 Ints. Passer rating 70.47 2: Rest of the AFC South (HOU, JAC, TENN) Tannehill 151 of 224 attempts for 1759 yards. 11TDs and 9 Ints. Passer Rating 90.61 Luck 384 of 647 attempts for 4825 yards. 34 TDs and 13 Ints. Passer rating 91.89 3 AFC West Tannehill 154 of 253 attempts for 1683 yards. 11 TDs and 3 Ints. Passer Rating 93.7 Luck 156 of 252 attempts for 1676 yards. 11 TDs and 3 Ints. Passer rating 91.1 4: AFC North Tannehill 134 of 217 attempts for 1523 yards. 7 TDs and 2 Ints. Passer Rating 89.7 Luck 154 of 264 attempts for 1865 yards. 12 TDs and 6 Ints. Passer rating 85.8 5: NFC Tannehill 377 of 566 attempts for 4034 yards. 26TDs and 14 Ints. Passer Rating 91.4 Luck 305 of 546 attempts for 3579 yards. 30 TDs and 20 Ints. Passer rating 80.4 6: All non Divisional opponents Tannehill 665 of 1026 attempts for 7240 yards. 44TDs and 19 Ints. Passer Rating 92.08 Luck 615 of 1062 attempts for 7117 yards. 53 TDs and 29 Ints. Passer rating 83.52 Against the AFC East, AFC North and NFC Tannehill is significantly better than Luck. Against the AFC South and AFC West Tannehill and Luck are about the same. There is no group of opponents where Luck has performed significantly better than Tannehill. I am in now way trying to pump up RT17, who has been a flawed QB so far. While I believe RT17 has been badly served by his coaches that is not the point of what I'm looking at here. What I can't understand is why so many people are high on Lucky to play in the AFC South.