I don't have DirecTV and I am nowhere near the expert when it comes to judging QB play like many of you here. I may have good instinct for what defines a good QB, but that's about it
With the first overall pick in the 2012 draft (taking in to account the first 4 games of the season) the Miami Dolphins select:
Tell me why.
-
-
-
I this like overall player we would select? Fantasy draft? If it is give me Rodgers first.
Or is it out of these five rookie QB's? Starting to fall for Tannehill but you can still give me Andrew Luck. -
I think the OP is asking us to choose between Luck, RG3, Weeden, or Tannehill.
I'd still go with Luck. -
I misread you're saying what player should've we taken over Tannehill? Frankly no one. I wanted Ingram, DeCastro, Kuechly and I don't think either player warrants being drafted ahead of Tannehill.
-
4 games in with hindsight with the 1st you trade down for either RGIII or Tannehill and load up the offensive with picks. At the end of teh year is when you really need to ask this question.
Pandarilla likes this. -
Either you guys think my post is worthless, which is OK or you don't understand the jist of it. Looking at Tannehill right now, where does he rank from this rookie class through 4 games? Does he have the potential to be the best one out of the bunch ?
-
As far as next year, I would love to pull a St. Louis Rams and trade back a few picks for someone who wants Geno Smith (who is playing lights out) grab a 1st next year and take one of the top WRs.
Pandarilla likes this. -
Tannehill is better than anyone we could have gotten. Tannehill showed he is a franchise guy he is making Hartline look like a beast.
-
Here is how I rank them now in terms of their play right now:
1.) RG3 (He is more of a system fit, the Shanahan's are making sure he is fine in his own element)
2.) Luck (Harder offense to run out of the gate)
3.) Tannehill
4.) Weeden
5.) Wilson
Most Potential:
1.) Tannehill (This could be controversial, but he has a cannon and has only played 23 games as a QB. It's scary how good he is already.)
2.) Luck
3.) RG3
4.) Wilson (If Weeden and Wilson were the same age I would have Weeden here)
5.) Weeden (His age gets him the last spot on the list)Bumrush likes this. -
-
Weeden has been flat out bad on and off the field.
-
-
I'm kind of hoping for history to repeat itself in the form of the 83 QB class... The order in which they were taken means nothing but it would be cool to see this
Andrew Luck- Jim Kelly
RG3- John Elway
Ryan Tannehill- Dan Marino
Brandon Weeden- Ken Obrien
Russell Wilson- Gary Kubiak
Blackledge and Eason left off the list....Pandarilla likes this. -
Play action 80 yard TD. No denying that.
-
Luck...
-
Rg3
-
Tannehill