Hartline wants 5-6 million per season

1163 repliesLocked

ToddPhinToddPhinLuxury Box
Jan 27, 2013, 03:27 AM

"MrClean wrote:

Child please. :no: So, WRs cannot go over the middle in the red zone? Well, they can if they have that ability. If that were true of every team, then every team would have an equally low pct of their TD passes to their WRs, like Miami's. We see Welker get open in the red zone inside the hashes a lot. In the AFC Championship, Bolden caught 2 TD passes in the middle of the end zone. We do not have a WR who can work well in that compressed area.

Nope, nor can they run the fade , nor go over a DB, nor catch a quick pass and do the rest on his own... nope, none of that; it's all on the QB making a deadly accurate throw toward the sideline while the receiver is absolved of all responsibility. :unsure:

ToddPhinToddPhinLuxury Box
Jan 27, 2013, 03:28 AM

"shouright wrote:

A wide receiver's going over the middle is a longer-developing play, which necessarily makes it harder to pull off than a shorter-developing one. Also, if going over the middle is inherently more beneficial to wide receivers for the reasons I've stated (and with which you've implicitly agreed), then cover men can cheat toward defending those plays. In all, the wide receiver's ability to function within a compressed field is significantly compromised.

Great point when you have Bess as the receiver. Thanks.

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 03:33 AM

"phinsational wrote:

Nope, nor can they run the fade , nor go over a DB, nor catch a quick pass and do the rest on his own... nope, none of that; it's all on the QB making a deadly accurate throw toward the sideline while the receiver is absolved of all responsibility. :unsure:

They can sure do all that, but there's also a lot they can't do, like run a go route, a post, a long comeback, etc., and so defenders can forget all about covering those routes, and focus instead on covering only the ones you mentioned.

In addition to that, when the QB throws in a direction in which his pass takes longer to arrive (more horizontally than vertically), the DB, who's covering only the select few routes you mentioned, is given more time to get a jump on the ball than if the pass is thrown in a direction in which there is a shorter distance between point A and point B (vertically, to the tight end, mostly).

This is why tight ends are teams' favorite targets in the red zone, and this is why it's so important to be able to run in the red zone. Your wide receivers are largely taken out of the equation by the compression of the field.

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 03:35 AM

"phinsational wrote:

when you have Bess as the receiver

An over-the-middle route in the red zone is a longer-developing play than something toward the sideline regardless of who's running the route.

ToddPhinToddPhinLuxury Box
Jan 27, 2013, 03:39 AM

"shouright wrote:

Yet his yards per target is among the league's best.

:lol: Come on. The blind refusal to look at objective data is getting a little ridiculous.

That tends to happen when a receiver catches an 80 yard pass vs busted coverage, doesn't face bracketed coverage like many teams primary receivers do, and isn't a dynamic receiver; IE: isn't a component in the quick passing game b/c of his lack of playmaking ability; therefore he doesn't receive many short passes to effectively bring his YPA down even though those short passes would benefit the offense despite hurting the receiver's average.

ToddPhinToddPhinLuxury Box
Jan 27, 2013, 03:40 AM

"shouright wrote:

As if that's possible. :lol: ;)

Find me a supporting argument of what I asked for and I'll shut up through the entire draft, not one post. But if you can't, I get to pick your avatar for a month.

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 03:41 AM

"phinsational wrote:

That tends to happen when a receiver catches an 80 yard pass vs busted coverage, doesn't face bracketed coverage like many teams primary receivers do, and isn't a dynamic receiver; IE: isn't a component in the quick passing game b/c of his lack of playmaking ability; therefore he doesn't receive many short passes to effectively bring his YPA down even though those short passes would benefit the offense despite hurting the receiver's average.

I'd sure be convinced if any of that was based on any kind of systematic, objective study.

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 03:42 AM

"phinsational wrote:

Find me a supporting argument of what I asked for and I'll shut up through the entire draft, not one post. But if you can't, I get to pick your avatar for a month.

Tempting, but the place just wouldn't be the same without you. ;)

shula_guyshula_guyNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 03:43 AM

Moving the ball foward gets more difficult as you get closer to the goal line. The less area a defense needs to protect, the more effecient that defense becomes. I have often argued that with all the rule changes they been making to favor passing that they should also consider making the field more narrow to compensate the defense. Same principle as the red zone.

"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it."

Frederic Bastiat

ToddPhinToddPhinLuxury Box
Jan 27, 2013, 03:56 AM

"shouright wrote:

They can sure do all that, but there's also a lot they can't do, like run a go route, a post, a long comeback, etc., and so defenders can forget all about covering those routes, and focus instead on covering only the ones.

In addition to that, when the QB throws in a direction in which his pass takes longer to arrive (more horizontally than vertically), the DB, who's covering only the select few routes you mentioned, is given more time to get a jump on the ball than if the pass is thrown in a direction in which there is a shorter distance between point A and point B (vertically, to the tight end, mostly).

This is why tight ends are teams' favorite targets in the red zone, and this is why it's so important to be able to run in the red zone. Your wide receivers are largely taken out of the equation by the compression of the field.

Which is why guys with good natural ability separate themselves from guys like Hartline who lack it.

I just want to be clear, you're saying the back of the endzone serves as an extra defender taking away the deeper routes and makes life more difficult on the receiver b/c the corner can squat on routes and attempt to take away the underneath?

VanDolPhanVanDolPhanSupporter
Jan 27, 2013, 03:59 AM

Davone Bess received a 4 year $9.3 million contract with a $3 million signing bonus.

This was in the middle of a year that he was 79 balls for 820 yards and 5 TD's and was his second season in a row with numbers like that (well not quite td's but the rest was close).

Yet cause Hartline makes it to FA were supposed to pay him nearly $6 million? Nah. I'll pass thank you. Combine that money into a real talent at Wr or go double dipping in the draft.

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 04:04 AM

"phinsational wrote:

Which is why guys with good natural ability separate themselves from guys like Hartline who lack it.

I just want to be clear, you're saying the back of the endzone serves as an extra defender taking away the deeper routes and makes life more difficult on the receiver b/c the corner can squat on routes and attempt to take away the underneath?

Is this where you post the picture of Calvin Johnson in the red zone with two guys on him again? :lol: ;)

shula_guyshula_guyNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 04:07 AM

"VanDolPhan wrote:

Davone Bess received a 4 year $9.3 million contract with a $3 million signing bonus.

This was in the middle of a year that he was 79 balls for 820 yards and 5 TD's and was his second season in a row with numbers like that (well not quite td's but the rest was close).

Yet cause Hartline makes it to FA were supposed to pay him nearly $6 million? Nah. I'll pass thank you. Combine that money into a real talent at Wr or go double dipping in the draft.

He wont get 6mil in FA and I suspect his agent knows that. This is likely his first asking price and fully expects on settling for less. The question really is how much less. I would be somewhat surprised to find out that they could not get a deal done at 4 million.

"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it."

Frederic Bastiat

shula_guyshula_guyNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 04:09 AM

"shouright wrote:

Is this where you post the picture of Calvin Johnson in the red zone with two guys on him again? :lol: ;)

Why dont you stay on topic instead of constantly baiting people into off topic arguments

"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it."

Frederic Bastiat

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 04:11 AM

"shula_guy wrote:

Why dont you stay on topic instead of constantly baiting people into off topic arguments

With all the complaining you do, I sure hope you're contemplating contacting the moderators about me and putting me on your ignore list. :)

jdang307jdang307Supporter
Jan 27, 2013, 04:19 AM

"shouright wrote:

Actually it's not like saying those things, because those things are predictive of winning, whereas the percentage of teams' TD passes thrown to its wide receivers is not.

Even the sheer number of TDs thrown to teams' wide receivers (let alone the percentage of them), which is something that can be more easily attributed to their QBs, is only relatively weakly predictive of winning.

Forget the numbers man. Use some basic logic. The sheer number of TD's thrown to a teams WR's is weakly predictive of winning. Ok. Fine.

Without running any numbers, I can tell you, the sheer number of TD's scored helps a team win, does it not? If your WRs scores a bunch, it relieves you a bit if another position is lacking. If your WR scores a bunch, and your other positions do too, well you're that much better off.

You still need a good defense and other factors, but to say it is a non-factor is hogwash. A WR who can smell the endzone is better than one who cannot. I don't give a damn about numbers. Chris Chambers who was good for 800 yards and often times 6-10 TDs is better than a WR who does 800/1.

AJ Green is a beast and nobody is telling me it's Dalton that's allowing him to score so many TD's.

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 04:27 AM

"jdang307 wrote:

Without running any numbers, I can tell you, the sheer number of TD's scored helps a team win, does it not?

Sure, but you don't need those TDs to come from your wide receivers to win.

If your WRs scores a bunch, it relieves you a bit if another position is lacking. If your WR scores a bunch, and your other positions do too, well you're that much better off.

The percentage of TDs caught by wide receivers correlates nil with winning.

I think the mistaken belief here is that there is some sort of "special ability" that allows wide receivers to score touchdowns. That data don't bear that out.

Number one, touchdowns typically vary for a given receiver from season to season, and even from half-season to half-season, which argues against ability and argues for other factors. Number two, wide receivers' numbers and percentages of touchdowns have the relatively insignificant relationship with winning that I alluded to above.

What this all means in terms of Brian Hartline is that if you're a smart GM in my opinion, you don't base a whole lot of your salary considerations for him on what he's doing in the end zone.

Killer BeesKiller BeesForum Veteran
Jan 27, 2013, 04:36 AM

How can you sit there with a straight face and a say a wide out's TD number's mean absolutely nothing? How many times did Marshall get in the end zone while he was here? How many games did we win? But hey he put up a lot of receiving yards so...

shourightshourightNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 04:38 AM

"Killer Bees wrote:

How can you sit there with a straight face and a say a wide out's TD number's mean absolutely nothing? How many times did Marshall get in the end zone while he was here? How many games did we win? But hey he put up a lot of receiving yards so...

I guess the only explanation is that I must be a goddamned idiot. ;)

Killer BeesKiller BeesForum Veteran
Jan 27, 2013, 04:41 AM

lol

ToddPhinToddPhinLuxury Box
Jan 27, 2013, 05:07 AM

"shouright wrote:

I'd sure be convinced if any of that was based on any kind of systematic, objective study.

As an example look at Andre Johnson's contribution to the short passing game and see how it brings down his yards per attempt despite actually benefitting the offense.

yards per attempt



ypa


Andre Johnson
8.23


Hartline
8.46

passes thrown behind the LOS and up to 10 yards



yards
ypa
reception%
YAC


Andre Johnson
651
7.31
77%
361


Hartline
362
5.17
61%
128

passes thrown 11+ yards



yards
ypa
reception%


Andre Johnson
947
13.0
59%


Hartline
721
11.8
51%

So how does Brian have a higher YPA despite Andre having more yards in both categories, a greater reception rate in both categories, and a higher yards per attempt in both categories? It's b/c he contributes more in the short passing game which lowers his overall YPA. Unfortunately, Hartline isn't that type of dynamic player, as he's not a reliable target to pick up yards with the ball in his hands, and that does our offense no favors.

Added: That's with Andre Johnson routinely receiving bracketed coverage which Hartline does not...... and it's with Hartline receiving a gratis 80 yard catch boosting his ypa.

ToddPhinToddPhinLuxury Box
Jan 27, 2013, 05:19 AM

"shouright wrote:

Is this where you post the picture of Calvin Johnson in the red zone with two guys on him again? :lol: ;)

Nope, it's where I point out how the situation you're referring to in the redzone <how the back of the endzone serves as an extra defender so that cornerbacks can jump routes and play the underneath which makes things tougher for Hartline> is for all intents and purposes like the bracketed coverage most of the league's better receivers face across the entire field, not just in the redzone/endzone, but they still put up impressive stats rather than having fans making excuses for their disappearance when the coverage gets tighter. Hartline's ineffectiveness in the redzone/endzone gives you an idea of what his production would be like if he were routinely bracket covered like great receivers are; it'd be goodbye 1k yards and hello mediocrity.

PatssuckPatssuckNew Member
Jan 27, 2013, 06:30 AM

"phinsational wrote:

Nope, it's where I point out how the situation you're referring to in the redzone <how the back of the endzone serves as an extra defender so that cornerbacks can jump routes and play the underneath which makes things tougher for Hartline> is for all intents and purposes like the bracketed coverage most of the league's better receivers face across the entire field, not just in the redzone/endzone, but they still put up impressive stats rather than having fans making excuses for their disappearance when the coverage gets tighter. Hartline's ineffectiveness in the redzone/endzone gives you an idea of what his production would be like if he were routinely bracket covered like great receivers are; it'd be goodbye 1k yards and hello mediocrity.

Hartline's numbers are also misleading. If he played to his normal numbers in that game then he wouldn't even have 1000 yards. He is a 700-800 yard and 1-3 td guy. I don't understand why people are argue against this. He has NEVER score a lot of Tds going all the way back to college. To mention he is a pro bowl alternative is hilarious considering what a joke the pro bowl is.

Who will watch the watchmen?

A patriot must always be ready to defend his country from its government.

cdz12250cdz12250Supporter
Jan 27, 2013, 06:31 AM

Where Hartline gets open a lot seems to be the tippy toes tightrope sideline route. He's good at that. Add Bess, who catches it in slot routes, a tight end who can attack the seam, a good veteran and a downfield threat, and I'd love to keep Hartline, because the whole field would be available. There must be a way to get a contract done.

JWjw3102Forum Veteran
Jan 27, 2013, 06:35 AM

"Perfectville_USA wrote:

http://miamiherald.typepad.com/dolphins_in_depth/

Free agent Brian Hartline is expected to seek a contract paying him $5-6 million annually this offseason.

Jordy Nelson, the receiver to whom Hartline was optimistically compared entering the 2012 season, only makes $3.5 million annually. The Dolphins want to re-sign Hartline for 2013, but it doesn't sound like they'll get a hometown discount. Hartline, 26, is coming off career highs in catches (74) and yards (1,083).

Thank GOD he only scored 1TD, if he got in the endzone twice? He might have wanted 10-12 million. I hope Ireland does not over spend on this guy. No way he should get that type of money. He is no Jordy Nelson and Hartline has problems getting seperation. He is not a PLAYMAKER and we need playmakers at the WR position.

According to Ireland, an offensive playmaker is someone who scores TD's. By that very definition, Hartline is no offensive playmaker. I don't see any team in the NFL paying him the type of money he wants. If there is a team foolish enough to pay him $5-6 million dollars a year, I hope he enjoys playing for that team, because it won't be the Dolphins.

Hartline is a decent #2 receiver for the Dolphins and probably a #3 receiver for the better teams in the NFL. He is worth maybe $2-3 million dollars a year at most.

This thread is locked.