Is the debate over Henne finished?

Not quite.

3 games bruh. I'm pro-Henne, but the debate isn't finished until he puts it together for a whole season.

He has seemed to mature in the off season and playing some decent ball, but the jury is still out.

lol. this thread. i guess all the phins will go 11-5 this year needed an outlet

"Bumrush wrote:

Folks, we have ourselves a legitmate QB.. In fact, at top 15 QB at this point.. Anyone that wants to compare Colt McCoy to Henne can eat some crow..

Fix his RZ accuracy and Henne may be a top 10 QB by the end of the year.. Loving what I am seeing out of this kid and his aggression..

Not for the haters. Henne is playing very well. IMO, only one bad throw and that was 3 & goal late in the 1st half. He had Bess, but maybe it was too late he just threw it away?? The one to Marshall a couple series earlier, did Henne miss him or did BM run the wrong route? We dont know?
When Henne has had the time, he's been nothing but money!! 15/19 for 191 and TD!! That's very good! Don't care what anybody else says.

Side note, Randy Cross is a idiot, he should just STFU! He's been wrong so many times today!
Joe Hayden is awesome, Sean Smith is terrible.

He's playing very well this year except for one area: red zone.

Granted, he's had a few drops in the endzone. But this is where the men are separated from the boys. It's a lot more difficult to complete passes down there.

Henne's going to have to prove he can make it happen down there.

Yeah but he's had Red Zone issues for 3 years now....is he suddenly going to fix it? Can't score Touchdowns then you can't win. Dolphins have 250 yards and twice as much time of possession and are only up 3 and will probably let the Browns score now.

Also not doing well on 3rd down.

We'll we're 0-2, so that says we're a bad team too!
Henne is playing very well though even though we can't finish a drive yet.

To be a top QB you need to throw tds in the redzone. It's that simple.

What an ill-timed, thread. Yeah sure. The debate is over. If you think that, you're sadly mistaken. He's the leader of an offense that cannot score points.

"Bumrush wrote:

Folks, we have ourselves a legitmate QB.. In fact, at top 15 QB at this point.. Anyone that wants to compare Colt McCoy to Henne can eat some crow..

Fix his RZ accuracy and Henne may be a top 10 QB by the end of the year.. Loving what I am seeing out of this kid and his aggression..

He threw for 40% last week. Let's get through the season and take a step back and then make a judgment.

Fails again in at the Goal Line! Week after week same thing. I don't even get excited when we get to the goal line. I've never seen a team play so pathetic at the goal line.

Chad Henne is probably the 21st - 24th best QB in the NFL. Please don't get it twisted because he had one good game against the Patriots AWFUL pass defense.

All the pass yards in the world mean nothing if you can't put the ball in the end zone.

"MonstBlitz wrote:

All the pass yards in the world mean nothing if you can't put the ball in the end zone.

People are just excited that for the first time in his career he has more TDs than INTs.

Way to add to the debate. And you're calling me a troll? Grow up

"Bumrush wrote:

Way to add to the debate. And you're calling me a troll? Grow up

What's the debate? You provided nothing to debate over other than he's played better than Colt McCoy. And believe me, Colt McCoy is not the gold standard of NFL quarterbacks that you want to compare your starter to. Henne's not a good QB. He had one good game against the Pat's AWFUL defense and hasn't done anything in the past 2 weeks other than throw for a 40% completion against the Texans and **** up over and over again in the red zone all day today. Henne is not a top 15 QB. He's damn sure not a top 10 QB.

If playing better than Colt McCoy makes you a top 15 QB in the NFL there's about 26 guys who are in the top 15 QBs in the NFL. I'm just saying you should expand your criteria of what constitutes a top 15 QB.

I'm not using Colt Mcoy as a comparison, I am simply bringing up Colt because certain individuals in this forum have tried to argue that Mcoy is actually better.

I'm not responding to anything else from you, it's clear you have no desire to give Henne any credit and prefer failure so you can look like you know what you're taking about.

In his fourth season he still can't throw a fade to save his life...or his job. And this new-found tendency of his to pull the ball down and run is a disturbing step in the wrong direction and it will end badly.

He has improved since last season, but that isn't saying much and a thread like this just invites scrutiny.

"Bumrush wrote:

I'm not using Colt Mcoy as a comparison, I am simply bringing up Colt because certain individuals in this forum have tried to argue that Mcoy is actually better.

I'm not responding to anything else from you, it's clear you have no desire to give Henne any credit and prefer failure so you can look like you know what your taking about.

You're right. I've been a Miami Dolphins fan for 21 years and I'm rooting for the team to fail so that I can "look like (I) know what (I'm) talking about" on a message board to people I don't know and will likely never meet in real life. It couldn't be that...you know...Chad Henne isn't a good QB.

Oh wait, this is thephins.com....I forgot when you disagree with someone about a player it means you actively want the team to do poorly and you're not a real fan even if your position is entirely justified with empirical and statistical evidence.

This team is pathetic. Season over. Hope we get a chance to draft Luck. This team needs an overhaul.

This is why you don't make threads like this before halftime. What a joke this team is.