If he is healthy and signs here I'll be happy.

 

Who the hell is OscarDaBarber?

 

Oscar Da Grouch's hair stylist!

 

Perhaps a friend of Incarcerated Bob?

 

I think he is Gaffney's barber. He has a photo of himself cutting Gaffney's hair.

 

Fellas, Gaffney is just not that good a player, this is why I'd prefer to go with the youngsters.

Of course 4 gms into the yr we can shake things up, but still.

 

Fella, compared to what we have, other than Bess, he is a frigging All Pro. At least he gets open and has good hands, even if he is limited for YAC. Tanne needs another reliable target. We use a high draft pick on a possible Franchise QB, then hobble him with a WR corps of just Bess and the great pretenders.

 

He's a pretty good player. It would be a good signing.

 

He is also 31, never had 1k yds or more then a handful of Td's in a single season.

Fella, we are rebuilding, let the young guys give it a shot.

 

Eh, still would take Naanee, but not thrilled with either option.

This would smell of the things Sparano did his last two yrs, we need to develop younger players D22, this is the reality of 2012.

I'd prefer Matthews or Fuller or even Marlon "butterfingers" Moore.

Way I see it, Bess/Hartline/Fasano/Bush is pretty much our core offense, the youngsters can see the field when it counts and let's see what they can do when it matters.

Clay/Thomas/AA/Thigpen are our lesser options in the passing game

 

You call Moore butterfingers but would still prefer Naenaethenono? Did you watch him at all during the preseason? He dropped more balls in three games than I care to count! He could be 31, or 19 but if he caint catch, he needs to be removed.

 

Rebuilding a team requires a solid veteran or two and especially at wideout!!!

 

Gaffney would be more welcome than Stallworth or Branch, IMO.

Gaffney-Hartline-Bess isn't suicidally bad, and if the TEs and RBs help out, that's at least a decent passing tree for Tannehill. Still means the position has to be addressed next year, preferably with a high draft pick and a good free agent. Dwayne Bowe and Marquess Wilson, Robert Woods and Malcom Floyd, something like that.

 

do it!

 

I do not want Gaffney at the expense of Matthews. I know that sounds crazy, but I don't. And there is no guarantee that Matthews makes the practice squad like Omar implies. However, I might live with it if he is replacing Moore, and without a doubt if he is replacing Naanee.

 

He had 947 last year which is pretty darn good. In fact it placed him 27th in the entire league. Not wowing numbers, but considering there are 32 teams in the league and the Dolphins have the worst WR corps in the NFL, it would be foolish to overlook him if he's healthy. He would potentially be the best WR on the Dolphins if they added him. I'm all for building for the future, but the likelihood of any of the Dolphins current "young" players ever turning into anything more than a bottom of the roster WR is not very high. More importantly trotting this sad group that we currently have out there when we have a rookie QB at the helm is playing a dangerous game. You need to give him all the help you can and Gaffney would really improve the unit.

And Naannee is a far inferior player. If it's Gaffney for Naannee (which I'd be it would be) that's a no-brainer.

 

Dolfans say this every yr, save for the brief Marshall era, this is a part of the realization of what 2012 "is" Des.

And the Draft is no sure thing either, teams move up, guys fall off, etc.

This is why I'd rather be proactive and just take our medicine.

 

Same here, as bad as we need a veteran WR, we need someone we can count on for more than just a couple years, I don't know if we would get more than one year out of Gaffney and I would hate to lose Matthews for a rental. He's a late round pick yes, but the kid was one of the best players out of camp. We GOT to find out what we have in him before we risk him to waivers.

 

What realization? I wrote off the 2012 season as an empty hole the second Sparano was fired. 2013 won't be much better.

I'm looking ahead to the 2014 season.

 

Don't need Naanee as part of a rebuild, and signing Gaffney would send a message to the veterans that the team is trying to win This season.
If you don't think he'd help Tannehill a lot more than having Naanee out there, well there really isn't much else I can say. I may as well talk to the wall.

 

Well we know he wouldn't replace Bess or Hartline, and I'd hope not Matthews either. Any of the others, I'd have no problem with swapping for Gaffney for a roster spot.

 

We are going after everyone that played for Washington.

I hope they make the right decision and sign Gaffney.

 

If we do sign him, I just hope it's to replace Naanee.

 

Gaffney for Naannee makes the most sense and I'd hope they still keep Matthews, but the fact that people would be willing to risk the development of the most important player this franchise has had in over a decade (Tannehill) throwing a poor unit out there with him over a 7th round pick is a little ridiculous to me.

 

Garbage in, Garbage out.

 

i welcome any wr vet that can help us win this year. we will get our youth and talent at the wr position in the next draft and we will need one or 2 wr vets to help our new wr draftees next april. what we need is wr vet help now!

 

Im not a gaffney fan, but the team has already given all of the youngsters the whole offseason and preseason to prove themselves and earn a shot, and they all fell flat on their faces. The team needs to give Tannehill all of the weapons that they can. A one year deal has no downside.

 

i'm ready to give the guys we have at WR now a shot at playing a real game with no vanilla offense and a complete gameplan, i'm kind of anxious to see what happens

 

Naanee is pretty good in Madden. :couch:

 

To me Gaffney would become our vertical threat which could replace Naanee. In a ideal world Naanee would learn from Gaffney and become what we hoped he would be at the start of camp