Great thread...mostly because its something besides a Madden thread which has been the Gaming Forum for the last month. Also with the PS3 Slim on the way for $299 (supposedly) and a drop of the 360 Elite to $299 the next couple of months will be fun.
The even bigger surprise is that Mario Kart DS was 6th place. That game is nearly 4 years old!! Don't get me wrong, it's a great game. But damn, after 4 years it sells like that? It's the freaking Dark Side of the Moon of video games!