Wow... what a day. So now we're 5-4 after a good team play, all around, with an absolutely confusing QB situation. Assuming all 3 of the QBs are viable to play Thursday (highly unlikely for Pennington, and probably questionable for Henne), who would you start at QB and why? I think Thigpen made a very strong case today. I honestly did not expect him to play nearly as well as he did, he really surprised me. I'm really torn between the two of them, as I think Pennington is too brittle now. If he can go down with shoulder pains within 2 plays off of a rather innocuous hit, I don't think he's going to survive much longer.