Getting Tommy back healthy is crucial. I'd much rather see him in the postseason rotation than say Derek Lowe. Derek has won some huge games in his career but at this point he's too jekyl and hyde out there for October. Tommy has much better stuff than JJ. JJ has to be nearly perfect location wise, when he's not he gives up five or six runs which is what has been happening nearly every start since the ASB. Part of it might be injury but the injuries don't seem to stop. I think the question has been answered about who to keep long term between Hanson and JJ. Beachy has been excellent, he started number five on the team and has earned himself a postseason rotation spot.