1. Dec 22, 2011 #1
   

   Fin D Sigh

   72,252

   43,684

   113

   Nov 27, 2007

   Just wanted to help pass the time till we heard about Barkley.
   
   So, based solely on their college career (without the hindsight of their pro careers), what pick do you think these QB's would go if they all came out the same year:
   
   Rivers
   Montana
   Marino
   Kelly
   Elway
   P Manning
   Rodgers
   Luck
   Barkley
   C. Palmer
   A. Smith
   Leinhart
   Newton
   Montana

    
2. Dec 22, 2011 #2
   

   rafael Well-Known Member

   27,364

   31,261

   113

   Apr 6, 2008

   My guess/opinion:
   
   Luck
   Elway
   P. Manning
   Kelly
   C. Palmer
   Marino
   Newton
   Leinhart
   Barkley
   Rivers
   A. Smith
   Rodgers
   Montana

    

   dolfan7171 and Fin D like this.
3. Dec 22, 2011 #3
   

   firedan Well-Known Member

   2,035

   861

   113

   Oct 31, 2008

   palm beach county fl

   1.Elway 2.Manning 3.Luck 4.Rogers 5.Kelly 6.Newton 7Rivers 8.Marino 9.Smith 10.Rogers 11.Palmer 12.Leinhart 13.Montana

    

   Fin D likes this.

• Log in with Facebook

Your name or email address:

Do you already have an account?

• No, create an account now.
• Yes, my password is:
• Forgot your password?

Stay logged in