I agree with the James assessment. I would definitely love to have him at #11 and I do think I'd choose him over Minkah at this point. I did have Minkah higher at one point, but the more I see of James the more I like him. Timmons isn't much bigger than Smith and I would hesitate to say that he's a bigger thumper. Smith hits hard and as you can see he can take on O-Linemen. That's not to say that I didn't see him get washed out in college, but for the most part he was able to make the play and get the tackle regardless if he was going through the block or avoiding the block all together. And the "he was protected" at Georgia is true, to an extent. I mean, everybody had their job and Smith did his with an A+ grade. I think he could come into Miami and start from day one and play a 3 down 'backer. I don't see Edmunds being able to come right in and do that. I guess my biggest gripe is all this "Player A doesn't fit your scheme" talk and then the attempts to smear that player because a person likes someone else better. Great players play great. I think Smith has the most ability to play great. And for all the physical traits that Edmunds has, Smith isn't really lacking in anything, PLUS he's smarter.