Tell me this is justice
32 replies
http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202426427894
A Long Island judge has dismissed charges of driving under the influence and illegally possessing a weapon against a 9/11 rescue worker, citing the man's status as an "American hero."
...........
"he Court finds that the Defendant has demonstrated the existence of compelling factors, considerations or circumstances which show that his prosecution or conviction upon the accusatory instruments herein would constitute an injustice."
Alright I'm no lawyer but basically what this article is saying to me is that because this guy DID HIS JOB on Sept. 11th he gets to walk off a DUI and illegal weapons charge? And everyone is saying that an athlete shouldn't be able to walk? Why this guy?
I usually don't pay attention to things like this and if it wasn't for digg I wouldn't have ever come across it but WTF :tantrum:
"A man's suffering is similar to the behavior of gas. If a certain quantity of gas is pumped into an empty chamber, it will fill the chamber completely and evenly, no matter how big the chamber. Thus, suffering completely fills the human soul and conscious mind, no matter whether the suffering great or little. Therefore, the "size" of human suffering is absolutely relative." - Viktor Frankl
Maybe I'm in the wrong but I don't think it's fair to compare a Professional Athlete making millions to a Firefighter in a much more noble profession making much less. Sure it's favoritism in both cases, but this is favoritism we can live with. If you or your family are ever in that situation, this is the guy who's going to save you, not the athlete.
It took balls of steel to do what those firefighters and police officers did on 9/11. If anyone deserves a 2nd chance, it's this guy. Kudos to the Judge on this one
For me it's the principle of the matter not who it is.
People wonder why the legal system is ****. This is why.
"A man's suffering is similar to the behavior of gas. If a certain quantity of gas is pumped into an empty chamber, it will fill the chamber completely and evenly, no matter how big the chamber. Thus, suffering completely fills the human soul and conscious mind, no matter whether the suffering great or little. Therefore, the "size" of human suffering is absolutely relative." - Viktor Frankl
"anlgp wrote:
For me it's the principle of the matter not who it is.
People wonder why the legal system is ****. This is why.
Whatever judge used that as an excuse, should be disbarred.
This topic is posted only to elicit discussion. Viewer discretion is advised.
http://images.thephins.com/forums/signaturepics/sigpic1360_3.gif
"n9necount wrote:
Maybe I'm in the wrong but I don't think it's fair to compare a Professional Athlete making millions to a Firefighter in a much more noble profession making much less. Sure it's favoritism in both cases, but this is favoritism we can live with. If you or your family are ever in that situation, this is the guy who's going to save you, not the athlete.
It took balls of steel to do what those firefighters and police officers did on 9/11. If anyone deserves a 2nd chance, it's this guy. Kudos to the Judge on this one
but think about this, lets say the crime was a little more serious, lets say he sexually molested a child, would u still think he deserves a 2nd chance?
Presidents give out pardons all the time, too. Should we take that away? There is nothing wrong with showing compassion for individuals who have earned it
"Jt0323 wrote:
but think about this, lets say the crime was a little more serious, lets say he sexually molested a child, would u still think he deserves a 2nd chance?
That is not a fair comparison though. His crimes were victimless
"n9necount wrote:
That is not a fair comparison though. His crimes were victimless
Doesn't matter, you do the crime you do the time.
This topic is posted only to elicit discussion. Viewer discretion is advised.
http://images.thephins.com/forums/signaturepics/sigpic1360_3.gif
"n9necount wrote:
That is not a fair comparison though. His crimes were victimless
Driving under the influence may be victimless until he actually kills someone for driving under the influence. This guy is going to think hes invincible because he's an "American Hero."
NO ONE is above the law, not even the President. Jimmy, correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't this violate the Fifth Amendment?
In this case, there may be extenuating circumstances due to his psychological and physical conditions following 9-11. He suffered significant trauma. That being the case, he should be remanded to mandatory care. Being just let off the hook sounds like a miscarriage of justice.
ירושלים, בירת עמי
while i do give the judge props for recognizing what this man has done, i tend to agree with the majority here in that he should probably be punished. there are many, many brave men and women who risk their lives every single day to save Americans, and not to downplay what happened to the rescue workers on 9/11 because what they did certainly was heroic, but they also weren't the only firefighters to ever lose their lives you know? and what about our brave soldiers? they've all risked their lives, so do they all get second chances too? i think it just sets a bad precedent.
while i appreciate what this man and many others have done, i have very little tolerance for DUIs. it is irresponsible, dangerous and downright stupid. and besides, if it is a first offense his punishment wouldn't be so horrid that he couldn't just take it and live with it.
now, if this is a 2nd, 3rd, etc. offense to the point where the judge letting him go is actually getting rid of significant jailtime, then i think it is rediculous, because this would have then been his 3rd, 4th, etc. 'chance'. and a repeat DUI offender is someone who i have less than zero tolerance for, regardless of his/her honors

Also to comment on this..
It's his job. There are paid firefighters as much as there are volunteer firefighters. I'm not saying it's an easy one but this guy gets a second chance because of the heroic nature of his job? As other people have pointed out there are other jobs that are just as heroic and as someone else pointed out nobody is -- or should be -- above the law.
"A man's suffering is similar to the behavior of gas. If a certain quantity of gas is pumped into an empty chamber, it will fill the chamber completely and evenly, no matter how big the chamber. Thus, suffering completely fills the human soul and conscious mind, no matter whether the suffering great or little. Therefore, the "size" of human suffering is absolutely relative." - Viktor Frankl
My son is a fire fighter.
IF he got caught dui, it would be all on him. It would have nothing to do with his job.
If they go to their job drunk, how long would they have a job?
To me, if they abuse the laws, their the same as the rest of us.
I admire our firefighters, police and armed forces for what they do for us, but no one should be above the law.

"dolphindebby wrote:
My son is a fire fighter.
IF he got caught dui, it would be all on him. It would have nothing to do with his job.
If they go to their job drunk, how long would they have a job?
To me, if they abuse the laws, their the same as the rest of us.
I admire our firefighters, police and armed forces for what they do for us, but no one should be above the law.
:up: What she said !
"Jt0323 wrote:
Driving under the influence may be victimless until he actually kills someone for driving under the influence. This guy is going to think hes invincible because he's an "American Hero."
But you cannot compare a child molester who actually did the act to an individual who didn't. We can play the what if game all day, fact of the matter is if you are going to compare a child molester to a 9/11 hero who is ONLY guilty of the crimes he is charged for it's quite silly, imo.
"n9necount wrote:
But you cannot compare a child molester who actually did the act to an individual who didn't. We can play the what if game all day, fact of the matter is if you are going to compare a child molester to a 9/11 hero who is ONLY guilty of the crimes he is charged for it's quite silly, imo.
Okay so he's guilty of the crimes he is charged for. But wait. He wasn't charged for anything yet he did the crimes. :huh:
I hope he feel guilty in his heart.
"A man's suffering is similar to the behavior of gas. If a certain quantity of gas is pumped into an empty chamber, it will fill the chamber completely and evenly, no matter how big the chamber. Thus, suffering completely fills the human soul and conscious mind, no matter whether the suffering great or little. Therefore, the "size" of human suffering is absolutely relative." - Viktor Frankl
"n9necount wrote:
But you cannot compare a child molester who actually did the act to an individual who didn't. We can play the what if game all day, fact of the matter is if you are going to compare a child molester to a 9/11 hero who is ONLY guilty of the crimes he is charged for it's quite silly, imo.
In no why did i compare a 9/11 hero to a child molester. This guy committed a crime. If any one committed the same crime they would be punished, and so should he. This judge is basicly telling any firefighter or policeman who helped during 9/11 that it is ok for them to drive under the influence because they are an American Hero. This guy could of killed someone. He is being negligent and should be held accountable for it. I don't care who he is. Hero or no Hero. Also what about American Soldiers serving in Iraq. I consider them American Hero's. Does it give them the right to drive under the influence? No.
Also lets say that person killed someone close to you because he was negligent, would you care if that person was an American Hero or not?
"anlgp wrote:
Okay so he's guilty of the crimes he is charged for. But wait. He wasn't charged for anything yet he did the crimes. :huh:
I hope he feel guilty in his heart.
He got a pardon due to his previous noble actions. And I'm sure people of such character appreciate the 2nd chance they have been given and feel guilty about their crimes and will NOT repeat them. If they do, then they will pay for it. I'm a betting man, and I'd wager to say that this particular individual will not be like your typical athlete hooligan
"Jt0323 wrote:
In no why did i compare a 9/11 hero to a child molester. This guy committed a crime. If any one committed the same crime they would be punished, and so should he. This judge is basicly telling any firefighter or policeman who helped during 9/11 that it is ok for them to drive under the influence because they are an American Hero. This guy could of killed someone. He is being negligent and should be held accountable for it. I don't care who he is. Hero or no Hero. Also what about American Soldiers serving in Iraq. I consider them American Hero's. Does it give them the right to drive under the influence? No.
Also lets say that person killed someone close to you because he was negligent, would you care if that person was an American Hero or not?
Didn't happen. But if we're playing the what if game, what if this Fireman saved you or your loved one from certain death on that day. Wouldn't you feel a little more inclined to show compassion to the individual more than someone who plays sports?
I don't believe that because a man is a firefighter or because a man is a professional athlete changes his personality enough to make him a repeat offender.
"A man's suffering is similar to the behavior of gas. If a certain quantity of gas is pumped into an empty chamber, it will fill the chamber completely and evenly, no matter how big the chamber. Thus, suffering completely fills the human soul and conscious mind, no matter whether the suffering great or little. Therefore, the "size" of human suffering is absolutely relative." - Viktor Frankl
"n9necount wrote:
Didn't happen. But if we're playing the what if game, what if this Fireman saved you or your loved one from certain death on that day. Wouldn't you feel a little more inclined to show compassion to the individual more than someone who plays sports?
what if he killed them by driving drunk wouldn't you feel enough anger to want him in jail regardless of his previous noble actions or profession?
"A man's suffering is similar to the behavior of gas. If a certain quantity of gas is pumped into an empty chamber, it will fill the chamber completely and evenly, no matter how big the chamber. Thus, suffering completely fills the human soul and conscious mind, no matter whether the suffering great or little. Therefore, the "size" of human suffering is absolutely relative." - Viktor Frankl
"anlgp wrote:
Also to comment on this..
It's his job. There are paid firefighters as much as there are volunteer firefighters. I'm not saying it's an easy one but this guy gets a second chance because of the heroic nature of his job? As other people have pointed out there are other jobs that are just as heroic and as someone else pointed out nobody is -- or should be -- above the law.
It's his job doesn't mean he couldn't have walked away from it on that day, as some did say in hurricane katrina. I think the guy should have been punished, but the its what he gets paid for doesn't apply here IMO. You are basically trying to trivialize something half this planet would not have done job or not.
thanks to VO for the sick ass sigs. 

Charlie: If you're not as educated or as informed what you do is you start your own party and you yell the loudest.
"Jt0323 wrote:
Driving under the influence may be victimless until he actually kills someone for driving under the influence. This guy is going to think hes invincible because he's an "American Hero."
if you want to play the what if game you can just as easily say, he will never do it again, despite getting off this time can't you?
thanks to VO for the sick ass sigs. 

Charlie: If you're not as educated or as informed what you do is you start your own party and you yell the loudest.
"anlgp wrote:
what if he killed them by driving drunk wouldn't you feel enough anger to want him in jail regardless of his previous noble actions or profession?
I cannot answer this question because the fact is he didn't kill anyone. That scenario did not happen. I only work with concrete evidence and in this case it involves a human being who put his LIFE on the line to save other human beings, who went on to make a serious mistake. Certainly at least to me, way more noble and more deserving of a break than someone who catches touchdowns for living
"unluckyluciano wrote:
It's his job doesn't mean he couldn't have walked away from it on that day, as some did say in hurricane katrina. I think the guy should have been punished, but the its what he gets paid for doesn't apply here IMO. You are basically trying to trivialize something half this planet would not have done job or not.
The reason why I put
I'm not saying it's an easy one
in there is because I wasn't trying to trivialize his job. The judge trivialized the fact that he was drunk driving and carrying an illegal weapon by not giving him a punishment so what's your point?
"A man's suffering is similar to the behavior of gas. If a certain quantity of gas is pumped into an empty chamber, it will fill the chamber completely and evenly, no matter how big the chamber. Thus, suffering completely fills the human soul and conscious mind, no matter whether the suffering great or little. Therefore, the "size" of human suffering is absolutely relative." - Viktor Frankl
