Why trade for him when he'll be released ? C'mon Pads.

Besides he is a head case, so personally I don't want him anywhere near our team. Just think of Belicheat getting into his head twice a year, and Rex Ryan too. No I think we should pass.

 

I think Young is worth a 2nd round pick. As in, the Titans would have to give us a 2nd round pick in exchange for taking on their garbage. Then I'd release him before the bonus kicked in.

 

I don't want him for any price. He's a cancer and a quitter, total head case. Not to mention that he won't ever win anything in the NFL. I'd much rather play Henne than Young.

 

Not only that, but you bring in another head case to go along with Brandon Marshall and you're really asking for trouble...IMHO.

What this team desperately needs is a strong leader. Vince Young deserted his football team. That is not leadership. That is a quitter.

JMHO...

 

I'm not a fan of VY, but we do NEED a QB to play professional football.

 

I gotta agree here fin72....the guy hasn't proven he can take any criticism without a meltdown. The first time he faced Sexy Rexy, that windbag would have him shuddering in his cleats and that would be the week before we play them... To me, he's a guy that should and will get another chance, but he has to grow up and mature before that....do we bring him in and play Henne to allow him time to mature ?? Doubtful, Ireland and Sparano are desperate to keep their jobs at this time. If we bring him in and start him right away and he goes into a meltdown....we the fans and this staff are screwed...

 

It was either/or with the Titans situation .Either Vince Young or Fisher had to go .Now it seems both are on the outs.

Perhaps the Titans owner decides to keep Young.

 

He would be worth a look but he is too expensive to trade for, he will be a free agent 100% guaranteed.

 

When I think of a more colorful way to say **** NO, I'll come back.

 

I'd rather bring Jeff George out of retirement.

 

All ur cheerleaders are belong to us! Nevar!

 

we're missing a poll option: "Hell No, I'd rather be kicked in the balls by a mule"

 

Vince Young sucks as a QB, we don't need him.........

Mike Vick is just a POS of a person, don't need him

 

You'd be silly not to trade a 5th for VY, that's a very low risk - high reward type of deal. I think the price might be a 4th and change, which doesn't change my opinion.

That said, I think VY is due a big roster bonus soon, and will likely be cut. The only way you make that trade is if you think he might not otherwise choose to come to Miami. And since we will offer him practically every opportunity to start and don't collect income tax, I don't see why we wouldn't be a naturally attractive option.

Greg McElroy, for what it is worth, has got to be high on Ireland's radar. He fits the criteria: lots of starts in a big program, excellent accuracy, low turnovers, good size. Doesn't have the big arm, but neither did Penny. So I'd expect he comes through the draft as well.

 

If the Titan's will give us a 3rd and Vince for a bag of footballs with a few extra endzone pylons, sure. Lets do it. Otherwise, no thanks.

 

see your point, but to me there's a big difference between "our starting QB" and a "QB that has started a bunch of games".
you can make the case that we traded a 5th for Thigpen, and even though he's nothing more than a backup, it wasn't a bad deal. At least Thigpen had potential to take it to the next level. Young has a big enough body of work, we know what we're getting. An extremely mediocre QB that hasn't very thin skin and has already piled up some injuries from being a run-first QB.

I don't like the idea of drafting Cam Newton, but if we're going to go with a running QB, I'd rather draft a young Cam Newton, with fresh legs, and at least some potential, than waste a 4th round pick on Vince Young. If you're going to waste a roster spot on VY, wait until after CBA is put in place, bring him in as a free agent and let him compete. He's a vet, and if he's worth a damn, he'd win a roster spot.

 

We've got one guy who mocks his own fans, alienates his coach, fights in strip clubs, goes on suicide watch, and quits on his team b/c he was benched, who is due 11 million. We've got another guy who took his benching on his extremely charge chin w/o any public opposition, then went out and played well that same week, came back from injury and finished the season under less than optimal conditions, who makes 550K. Both are relatively young, middle of the pack type QBs who may or may not become good QBs in the future. And you prefer the 1st guy? I dunno, sounds like another thinly veiled Henne basher thread to me.

 

You got that right. If Ireland makes that deal he has no brains whatsoever :lol:.

 

I'll take him for a ham sandwich and a clipboard. Low ball em and try to keep the lettuce.

 

No, I won't pretend he's as bad as Dennis Dixon. I'm also not going to pretend that his 2 pro-bowl berths and record had anything to do with his passing ability either. He is, at best, a mediocre QB that played for one of the best 2 or 3 coaches in the NFL. Fisher was able to make the most out of his talents and his running abilities, the latter was IMO the biggest reason for his record and pro-bowl berths. He has a career completion percentage lower than Henne. VY averages 0.8 passing TD's per game. Do we really want that guy throwing the ball for us?

 

With some serious questions regarding his mental state that may only be rivaled by Charlie Sheen.

 

You haven't been objective on Henne in this thread or any other that I've seen. You make excuse after excuse for why Young, Palmer etc aren't having success, but Henne's struggles are b/c he sucks. It's an open secret that Young was placed on IR for his thumb aka insubordination and conduct detrimental to the team. The hoops you jump thru to try and make this guy sound good, it sounds like youre a defense attorney at a parole hearing.

Young and Palmer both have 11 million dollar cap numbers for next season, any "objective" analysis needs to take that into account. Would you rather have Young, or would you use that $ for Marcedes Lewis and Braylon Edwards? Or use it for Brad Smith and Deangelo Williams? Or use it to resign Soliai and extend Wake? Or use it for Johnathan Joseph and Michael Bush. I can think of a million wiser ways to use that cap space than on Vince friggin Young. The Titans selected him #2, built the franchise around him, got him an all world RB that could force teams into man coverage, got him WRs and a decent TE, and the Titans are now willing to give him up to anyone willing to take him. Objectively, why is that?

Keep in mind, Young has a very unique skill (lackthereof) skill set. You'd have to design a scheme especially for his strengths, AND a scheme for Henne. You'd need weekly game plans for both. Who would you devote the lion share of the reps and development time too? They both need it. Its hard enough trying to groom one QB, no we're trying to groom two?

 

I see what you did there Greyson, and I love it

 

I agree completely, though we might be the only two guys on the board to think this way.

Randy Moss and Mike Vick were bigger nutcases, and worked out very well for their teams. The beauty of a low risk type investment is that you're not forced to keep him if he becomes trouble. You just shrug your shoulders and move on.

Gimme a Vince Young opening up what should be an admittedly simple and watered-down offense over a million Henne checkdowns. I think you'd want to pair Young with a pretty good receiving tight end though, he seems to look that way a bit.

 

Does he have the skilz to be a deep threat Wr? Because he sure the heck does not know how to be a consistant NFL Qb.

 

No to Vince Young. Pass. Let the Vikings get him. Eliminates need at quarterback on a team drafting ahead of us.

 

Which games did Henne "lose"?

And I'm not worried about Young beating Henne out. As I said before, its about opportunity cost. Young costs 11 million, and he'd require an intense amount of training and development, something he's been loathe to subject himself to throughout his career. But it's not really about Young, it's about Henne, how bad he "sucks" and how bad you want him replaced. You're certainly entitled to your opinion. We'll see what happens.

 

If Miami doesn't draft a QB in the first round, that is who I want Miami to draft later on. Take a Mark Ingram in the first, Lance Kendricks in the 3rd, McElroy in the 4th and your setting yourself up for a very nice offensive draft. Or go Pouncey/Wis/Julio in the first, Delone Carter in the third, and McElroy in the 4th -5th round area. I'd be absolutely thrilled with ither of these scenerio's.

 

Pads, where are you getting your information that Vince Young will be traded? Everything I read said it would be either Fisher or Young, now with Fisher gone I assumed Bud Adams would be keeping Young. Unless you've read something I haven't I'm considering the whole Young scenario null and void.

 

Yeah, we need a QB who contemplated suicide.

STOP SETTLING FOR MEDIOCRE, PEOPLE!

Get me a legit quarterback, dammit.