According to reports they made an offer to Franklin.

 

Yes, but I'm not sure Franklin is much of an upgrade at this point. He hasn't exactly been good the last couple seasons has he? What are your thoughts on what he has left?

 

Franklin has been playing terrible the last couple of years. He wouldn't be much if at all better than what we have with bushrod and larsen.

Revis could be an intriguing option if he moves to free safety.

At this point all free agents available are castoffs with injury or performance concerns. For cheap I would take a chance on some of them.

Sent from my F3111 using Tapatalk

 

Revis is not Revis anymore. Guys get old, sometimes faster then you would think.
Pass.

Only one of those I'd have interest in is Mangold. I think he's got a good year or two left in him.
I just don't see Pouncey making an entire season and I wasn't too impressed with our subs last year.

 

Some guys fade quickly and some guys get traded to teams in which the scheme is not a good fit. When Franklin played for Denver he had 3 really good years. Gase was the OC for 2 of those years. I think if Gase wanted him he would push for him. I heard the offer the Dolphins gave was really low. So, I'd think that Gase isn't overly impressed with him.

 

Sign Revis and have him at safety or as backup safety. Would he be FS or SS? Never really understood the difference to be honest.

 

Thats helpful bud! Thanks. Now I know everything about it. :crapstrom:

 

SS should be thumpers, and FS should be ball hawks. :loser:
In an ideal world, both are both, and one would just line up on the "Strong" (TE)side of the offense.

 

The difference between the two positions is fading. In years last you'd have a distinct difference, now not so much. In many ways it mirrors how the difference between right and left tackle has also been mitigated.

Really in today's NFL you're looking for guys who can cover moreso than being huge hitters. You don't want wimps back there but given the emphasis on the passing game you'd lean more towards that than looking for in the box bangers. Those types of safeties are more often than being given time as nickel backers and such as defenses want more versatility rather than isolated skill sets that don't cross over.

That's why a guy like Jabril Peppers was highly sought after by a good number of teams: versatility.

 

Would you say the two most important traits to look for in a safety are physical and mental quickness?

 

I didn't ask you and your answer doesn't even make sense with what I asked.

 

lol?

Seriously, you're not making any sense. "Patrolling" and "security" aren't traits which, mean they have literally nothing to do with my question. And again, the question wasn't asked of you. Had I asked a question of you, it wouldn't be football related as your opinion of football related matters has proven to be as useful English lit degree.

 

Yes, but I always put mental ability over physical traits. Again I quite Dick Vermeil who said that he prefers guys who have instinct over guys who have just speed.

No instincts means you'll run yourself out of plays as opposed to guys who have instincts who are already a step ahead to begin with.

 

I assume you're messin around.

 

I'm not that old yet.

 

I don't think it's a "what's he got left" thing. He's not really that old so he shouldn't be deteriorating at least not beyond what experience should be able to compensate for. The question is whether he just played above his level for a couple of seasons and is now returning to his baseline or did he play better b/c he was in the right scheme and had the proper motivation. I don't know that answer, but either way he's probably not more than competent anyways. Competent is better than what we've had here during Tanny's career so that would be an upgrade over last season. But I don't see getting competence out of the group we currently have as an unreasonable expectation either. You're probably right that he may not be much of an upgrade. My understanding is that the contract we offered was pretty close to the minimum so the Dolphins seem to agree.