I voted for Maclin.

 

No love for James Laurinaitis?

 

HAHA...1 TD, 1 Lose. That's great

 

Is Henne not considered a rookie? He only played in minimal action last year.

How Sanlose even got nominated is beyond me.

 

It was clearly Maclin this week.

 

You've got to be kidding me. 50% completion and a loss.

 

He really is not,he has been on the team ,Sanchez is a rookie and started as a rookie with no learning time to get used to the calling.

 

i thought Sanchez did some great things last night....didn't look like a rookie at all. meh, i don't like the mindless bashing...

 

WTF did he do to be on the list? ..... Oh yeah; he plays for a New York team.

 

3 words.

Hispanic Heritage Month. He is the new poster boy they were pimping him out BIG TIME last night.

 

They just made fun of him on NFLN

 

What a joke

that he is even being considered!! Guess he has to lose a few more before everyone stops bending over for him.

 

Voted for Collie. What can I say...I'm a dog lover. :tongue2:

 

Really?

I guess I was watching a different game.

He had one pass...one single pass that was anything above mediocre, and that wouldnt be anything without Crayon making the nice catch.

He overthrew his recievers numerous times.
He did the Cardinal no-no with intentional grounding.
He went 12/24 for a 174, and shouldve had two INT's to add to that.

Face it, the hype machine is on. Right now, they are making him out to be the poster boy, but just like Hollywood typically does to kids, it is probably gonna hurt him much in the long run.

 

Knowshown Mareno has looked pretty good as well BTW

 

moreno was good I thought. I voted maclin taking everyones word for it, but I like moreno alot :lol:

is moreno not latino??

 

Sure, ever hear of his mom Rita? :shifty: :hump:

I watched him run the Donkees version of the Wildcat...I think they called it the Nightmare or something...but he was pretty solid with it.

 

its called the wild horses :lol:

 

Complete joke that Sanchez is even nominated for this. Maclin wins this award hands down, or should anyways.

 

I'm not that biased. I mean, did he make some superb throws? Yes. And he is deservedly on the list. This is a ROOKIE of the week voting. I have seen much worse make the list. His performance was pretty good for a rook, esp. for one playing QB.

Inasmuch as I would not vote against him, I would vote for the rook most deserving. And it it between Maclin and Collie. IMO, Maclin gets it.

The only problem I have is that Henne played a much more polished game, and in some regards, is being overshadowed by Sanchez. If I were a Jets fan (what a nightmare), I would not be unhappy with Sanchez's performance. But Henne played magnificently and made some very tough throws. I am so happy with how he played.

 

Sanchez had a terrible game. He made two nice plays, one being the deep pass and the other being the pass to Edwards on the broken play.

I've never seen what others do in him, and WANTED to Jets to trade up for him so badly. He will set their franchise back, quote me, mark my words, he is at best an average QB.

 

Yep, I've been saying this since he decided to enter the draft, but here's the thing:
Every year the NFL feels like they have to hang the Rookie darling plaquard on somebody.
Sanchez has that honor this year. A large part of that is the entire NY glamour blitz and the non-stop hype that comes with it.

He was very pedestrian his only year of playing in college with plenty of weapons and a great line in front of him.

In Pre-season he made a few plays, but during the regular season he hasn't been that great.
Gruden mentioned it a few times last night, the kid shouldve stayed in school another year. He has a great line in front of him, a good running game and now has Crayon to throw to.

One thing I do know, the NY media will turn on you as quickly as they immortalize you, and I think its a matter of time for Sanchez.

 

Voted for sanchez thought he had a good game ,not sure why all the negative bashing ,yea he is a jet but the kid is playing well.

 

It has nothing to do with him being a Jet. He IMO isn't a good QB, certainly not a franchise guy you trade up to get.

 

its cause he's a jet

 

To you or to me :confused:

I didn't like him as a player before he was a Jet :lol:

 

my bad, to me hahaha

 

this is RIDICULOUS. we've seen "terrible" games at the QB position. and Sanchez had some GREAT throws and great decisions last night. not even CLOSE to being terrible, and I'd say he actually played VERY well, considering it's his 5th NFL start.

just silly.