What QB('s) in the NFL would you trade the #1 overall pick this draft for?

i would happily give that pick of ours to cleveland for brady quinn.

it would give us a chance to correct a horrible blunder made in last year's draft, and if you think about it, we still have the player chosen instead of quinn - ginn.

it would simply be as if quinn had re-entered the draft this year and we picked him.

and since quinn seems to have a somewhat-diminished value to cleveland because of the emergence of derek anderson, then despite the prevalent inherent value of a top qb prospect, we might get a little something extra from the browns for our trouble.

and no, i'm not down on beck nor am i giving up on him. it's simply that the value of the position vs. the players projected to be available in this draft make quinn look pretty good.

plus, what a terrible thing it would be to have two good young qb's on the roster, right?

NaboCane, your logic is terrible since Quinn is unproven.

I'd fire off the picks for Peyton or Carson Palmer

"Adam First wrote:

NaboCane, your logic is terrible since Quinn is unproven.

I'd fire off the picks for Peyton or Carson Palmer

forgive me, i was positing a real-world scenario, since neither the colts nor bengals are likely to trade their franchise qb's for a #1.

that, and the fact that every player that we might choose with that first overall pick would be unproven...and without the benefit of having spent a year learning in an nfl environment.

"NaboCane wrote:

i would happily give that pick of ours to cleveland for brady quinn.

it would give us a chance to correct a horrible blunder made in last year's draft, and if you think about it, we still have the player chosen instead of quinn - ginn.

it would simply be as if quinn had re-entered the draft this year and we picked him.

and since quinn seems to have a somewhat-diminished value to cleveland because of the emergence of derek anderson, then despite the prevalent inherent value of a top qb prospect, we might get a little something extra from the browns for our trouble.

and no, i'm not down on beck nor am i giving up on him. it's simply that the value of the position vs. the players projected to be available in this draft make quinn look pretty good.

plus, what a terrible thing it would be to have two good young qb's on the roster, right?

IMO, there was a good reason why around 22 teams passed on Quinn to begin with and likely more is Cleveland didn't trade for him. We could have gotten him for the 9th pick last year but did not and now he's worth the 1st overall pick? Sorry, not me!

Definitely Manning and maybe Romo. Yes, he is overhyped but he is young and I really like him, especially under pressure.

"NaboCane wrote:

i would happily give that pick of ours to cleveland for brady quinn.

it would give us a chance to correct a horrible blunder made in last year's draft, and if you think about it, we still have the player chosen instead of quinn - ginn.

it would simply be as if quinn had re-entered the draft this year and we picked him.

and since quinn seems to have a somewhat-diminished value to cleveland because of the emergence of derek anderson, then despite the prevalent inherent value of a top qb prospect, we might get a little something extra from the browns for our trouble.

and no, i'm not down on beck nor am i giving up on him. it's simply that the value of the position vs. the players projected to be available in this draft make quinn look pretty good.

plus, what a terrible thing it would be to have two good young qb's on the roster, right?

Thanks. I needed a good laugh this morning.:up:

My other was to bring Vinny Testaverde down here.

what do u guys think the Browns are gonna do with Brady Quinn???? u have a 3rd year guy in Derek Anderson who is lighting up the field, and a rookie in Quinn....do u trade away a 3rd year proven guy in Derek Anderson and RISK Brady Quinn not playing well (like Matt Leinart), or do keep Anderson and try to trade away Quinn like they did with Frye.

Oh NO! Another Brady Quinn thread...

Why in the hell did you have to list him?

I'd take Dan and thats because with the the 1984 Marino we get a Rookie where as with Manning hes not getting any younger. I would have gone for Manning in his rookie season over Marino perhaps but not 2007 Manning versus 1984 Marino.

Whoever wouldnt trade it for Manning, Brady, Palmer, Romo have rocks in their head.

I don't know that I would trade it away for any QB with the current state of this team. We need to get a QB some talent to work with first...

"Carabinieri44 wrote:

what do u guys think the Browns are gonna do with Brady Quinn???? u have a 3rd year guy in Derek Anderson who is lighting up the field, and a rookie in Quinn....do u trade away a 3rd year proven guy in Derek Anderson and RISK Brady Quinn not playing well (like Matt Leinart), or do keep Anderson and try to trade away Quinn like they did with Frye.

The Browns are already talking about giving Anderson a long-term deal. That might grease the skids for a Quinn trade. Honestly, a high second round pick might do the job. They picked him at #23, and got nothing for it. I don't necessarily endorse this idea, but I think the Browns would listen if we offered them the #31 for Quinn.

hey phil :wave:

I only said P.Manning and Brady. I didn't say the 84 Marino because I thought the poll should have been limited to current players.

On further review, though, I'd probably give it up for Palmer, too. Maybe Romo.

"NaboCane wrote:

hey phil :wave:

Hey Joe! :wave:

Peyton, Brady and Romo are the only ones worth a #1... why the hell is Dan Marino on this list... you want to get him killed on this team?

Manning, Palmer, and 1984 Marino. I left out Brady because I believe he's the beneficiary of an offensive line that gives him an eternity to make decisions.

"phunwin wrote:

I only said P.Manning and Brady. I didn't say the 84 Marino because I thought the poll should have been limited to current players.

On further review, though, I'd probably give it up for Palmer, too. Maybe Romo.

:lol:

I put '84 Marino on there "tounge-in-cheek". After all, it is a multiple choice poll. No harm, no foul, right?

:up:

"Aqua4Ever04 wrote:

Your list is pretty incomplete. You left off Ben Roethlisberger, Jason Campbell, Drew Brees, Matt Hasselbeck and maaaaaybe even Marc Bulger (prior to this year for sure.) These are all guys I would trade the first overall pick for and I would'nt give the #32 pick for Young, Manning, Leinart or Quinn.

Wow. That's a pretty huge list to trade the #1 overall pick in a draft for, IMHO. I wouldn't trade our first overall for any of those QB's (Big Ben coming the closest).

I was only allotted 10 slots for my poll or I would have included more. Hindsight 20/20, I would have dropped '84 Marino and added Big Ben. :thumbup:

Ben Roethislinberger should be on on that list. I'd give up the number 1 pick for him.

Having Marino on it is a waste, it was 1984

I would trade for Palmer, Peyton Manning or Brady with my #1

No way I trade my # 1 for Quinn, Matt L, Eli, I wouldn't trade a 3 for Young.

Manning, Brady, Palmer and Dan vintage '84.

I think Romo is good but he's got a long way to go to be considered in the top tier (IMO, Quinn has not done anything, Leinart (a personal fave of mine) is hurt but I think he could make it to the top, Eli is too inconsistent for me and Vince Young is simply the most over rated athlete in professional sports (IMO).