How about:
Sherman
Revis
Haden
Grimes
Vonate

Harris is a little too high. I love Peterson but hes a bit overrated being on a top 5 list. Maybe top 10. Talib and Vontae is a coin flip depending on scheme and whether you want the slightly younger player (Vontae). I always was a fan of Vontae's ability to play press as hes got a unique, highly athletic skillset and his technique has improved. .

 

He certainly is special...that pick against Detroit, and his pick in the Pro Bowl, were absolutely ridic! His game tailed off through the end of the season last year though...I'm hoping it was just a domino effect of what the defense was going through, and that he'll be back to his uber form this year. Still...Grimes at 80% is far better than the rest of the CB group, so I'm still loving that they gave him a longer contract after his first year.

 

My bad, I've never understood that one.

 

I'd take Grimes' 2014 over any of the others for what it's worth.

C'mon...the guy had a career year and was probably the most exciting CB in the NFL.

Give the guy some love for God's sake...he was far and away the best Dolphin on defense last year...yeah, I said it.

 

I wouldn't put Grimes top 5, he certainly isn't better then Vontae...hell last year he wasn't even as good as Sean Smith lol.

that public poll top 5 is much closer to being accurate than Davis and Wilcotts list.

 

Vontae has no business being anywhere near a top 5.

One year doesn't make a player. Especially when that players career is marked by inconsistency.

 

Idk about one year, Vontae was pretty good a couple
years ago too, but last year he took his game to another level, he was downright dominant, adding to the ever growing list of trades Ireland lost.

 

2013 was very good. 2014 was off the charts.

 

Gil Brandt ‏@Gil_Brandt

NFL CBs w/ highest Red Zone burn %

1. Amerson 70% (10 targets)
2. Ron Parker 64% (11)
3. Grimes 62% (13)
4. Roby 60% (10)

 

Hello........... ???