Easy. The answer to all 5 - TED GINN. :knucks:

 

Good questions tho...

 

1) He's a going to be a good starter, but I honestly can't see him being a franchise guy. However I think with Ronnie Brown (healthy) and a top tier WR you'd be hard pressed to find a QB with talent who wouldn't succeed. Especially with our line.

2) I don't think you draft based on injuries. Or rather, you make sure you have depth just like you would at any other position, but you don't reach for a guy because you believe your star might go down. Not sure Incognito and Hilliard are really an issue, as I dont see us relying on them too hard. Especially Hilliard. Things could change if Smiley goes however.

3) Smiley? Until proven otherwise.

4) I honestly can't blame him for one of the two fumbles (maybe both) in that game. Those were some perfectly placed hits, and big ones at that. However I do agree he had a down year and hopefully picks it up.

5) If we add another receiver? Most likely either Camarillo or Turner. Obviously Cam is a much better player at this point that Turner, however I'd say that Hartline will develop into a better player than Cam, and a similar enough one that makes Camarillo expendable. It depends how the staff feels about the progress Turner has made and his long term potential.

 

First of all..... regardless of what the FO actually does, to continue trying to develop White as a pro set QB is a waste of time and roster spot.....the only place that kid is dangerous is when he has the ball in space. So we either figure out ways to do that, or this is his last season as a Dolphin. They can't keep making excuses for keeping him at QB.....

Secondly, you're panicking on our RB situation.... we can only afford to address so many areas and when you have a unit that talented, leave it alone. Injuries happen, hopefully they won't this year...

 

i still fully believe Henne will be our QB for the next decade ...

each question has a backup plan on Offense ... so not really worried.

again, for the OL -- outside of C depth ... not worried one bit. we will have our best line in years.

Fasano is capable, certainly not spectacular .... we don't need spectacular - so as long as he improves a bit, we will be ok at TE ... plus there is Sperry and Nalbone in the hopper that we don't know where they are at until the mini camps and OTCs ...

i do think we'll add another WR .... and i'm still all in on trading down - then trading for Marshall with either the low 1st or 2nd .... we need to find some way to push Ginn at both WR and KR .... CAM is certainly trade bait, conversely - he is a reliable known until others can prove their worth during TC. We really need Turner (or some new tall WR to make it onto the field this year) to create some mismatches .... folks think Bess is a lock, whereas - i disagree .... maybe Mullins can push him, since he is faster (i think) ... then there is also Johnson and Pruitt --not holding my breath ... but you never know what can happen.

 

imo ricky was asked to carry the load way too much when ronnie went down
they should have given lex more touches so to say lex played a lot during that time is false. in the bills game for instance RW was supposed to be limited to 25 carries and he had 20 or so at halftime. lex was mainly used on third down or spelled williams on passing plays

as for cobbs being an everydown back i dont see
dont think he is built to carry the load
have to agree that the running back position is a bit of a problem with ronnie being injury prone it would be nice to find a bruising back sometime during the draft. tall order i know.

 

I agree and that would make sense if he actually was a good QB....however that little midget under center looks worse than the actual pick. This was a cluster**** of an idea from the moment they drafted him and to continue trying to develop him as a QB is just plain ignorance of the facts.

Who knows? Do you know for a fact everybody will get hurt again?

What position of need would you like to neglect in order to try and revamp a unit that is arguably one of the best in the NFL?

Oh and buy low, sell high

 

1. We still haven't seen the full extent of what he is capable of. We saw some good things in his first year as a starter and we also saw some bad things. I don't know if he is talented enough to carry an offense without more help but I think he is more than capable to get the job done.

2. I think RB is something we need to address this year or next year in the draft. Ronnie can't stay healthy and while Williams missed some years of taking a pounding 2-3 years down the road we could be in trouble there.

3. That's another position based on your mock draft in another thread wouldn't surprise me to see them address. They strongly believe in winning the game in the trenches and that is a weak spot. Maybe Smiley can stay healthy or maybe Incognito can get his head out of his a@#. I think we look mid to late rounds for somebody.

4. Another position we need to address. If we can't find a true #1 WR we need to find a playmaker and dependable TE that Henne can rely on. I'm not sure Fasano is that man.

5. We have way too many #2-4 type of WR's. I think if Ginn doesn't make some strides this year they may move on with him. This staff likes old school guys that don't mind getting down and dirty. He obviously is afraid of contact. If he made our offense explosive you could deal with that but that isn't the case. We get great value out of Bess and Hartline showed some promise. Ginn has a lot to prove this year.

 

Sorry, but Pat White is a quarterback in title only. He clearly is not an NFL quarterback based on his ability. To continue him at this position is foolish and a waste of time. His strength is his ability to run with the ball when he is in space. You move him to an athletic position and try to salvage the pick. If he stays at QB, then there is no chance that this pick pans out.

Also, I agree that Miami is in trouble if Ronnie goes down and Ricky cannot carry the load, but I'm not concerned about it. Why should I be making moves worrying what my top two backs will do when I'm sitting here with zero starting outside linebackers, a very questionable starter at nose tackle for the first eight games, no starter at free safety, and continued questions about the interior offensive line. Not only that, but ILB has to be addressed at some point to get someone that can eventually push Channing Crowder out of his job.

Basically, I might consider a running back with one of the 6th round picks that Miami has, but I'm loading up on linebackers in the first four rounds and possibly another offensive lineman.

 

I'd have no problem using a late round pick on a RB .........but more than likely that player would do no better than end up on the practice squad. It's not like we don't have any depth right now...

 

I think you underestimate this unit...... Ronnie and Ricky will be creating havoc once again, mark it down.

And Blount is probably gone before the 4th round..

Get a true number one WR and TE and we won't have to worry about wearing those guys out.

 

I can think of 7 positions that are more of a need than running back right now.

 

Ted Ginn will have his Best Year next year i will put my money on that
Ryan Grice Mullen :D
Lets Go Taurus Johnson!

 

Hopefully having Penny there for another year plus the competition can help him overcome the sophmore jinx. We do have a traffic jam at #2 and #3 QB. I guess having depth at the most important position is a nice luxury but too many guys with limited reps to go around. There's been talk of White moving to slot but Bess is there. Orginally I thought that pick would mean we would use him as a slot WR but drafting him last year as a QB is very puzzling.

I don't know anything about the guy from the CFL but we certainly need more consistency out of that position.

To your last point, I think the key is we need someone who creates some pressure on the defense and opens up our offense. Whether it's drafting a WR in the 1st or 2nd round or going after a TE we need someone. I'm not hell bent on spending our 1st pick on a WR or the popular opinion of trading for Marshall or drafting Bryant as I think it's important to get a high character player. IF they feel Bryant is that guy then I will be happy with that. It would be nice to see Benn, Thomas, LaFell or Tate there with our 2nd pick.

While many in Fin nation seem to think this draft will make us contenders this year I'm of the opinion we are still 2 years away. We need to address WR, FS, NT, OLB, TE, RB, LG and possibly another LB spot and we won't cover that all in this year. While RB has been a bright spot and strength,
we are 1-2 injuries away from losing the playmaking on our offense. I know most teams are but when you look at Browns history and Williams age it becomes more pressing. I would like to see them use a mid round pick at RB.

Many seem to think the first 4 rounds will go with some cobination of TE, OLB, WR, FS, and NT in no particular order. I wouldn't be surprised to see RB in one of those slots.

 

Good summation Padre :up:

1)Henne is the answer but he's never going to be Peyton Manning. Not accurate enough. Still he can be our Eli Manning or Ben Roethslisberger potentially which is good enough

2) I think RB is the wildcard in this draft. I like our RB corps but I could also see us drafting some new blood. I think everyone is in play depending if they pull the trigger on a RB in the draft and then it depends what type of RB they draft. Spiller or Best and Cobbs is gone. Lagarrette Blount and Lex is gone

3) I think it will be Incognito at LG but the battle will be fierce and whoever becomes a backup could probably start on a lot of other teams

4) I think Fasano will return to 2008 form and I think we'll finally see if Nalbone has a chance. Still I cant see us skipping drafting a TE this draft but so far that position is rumor free as far as the draft is concerned

5) Camarillo will be cut. Ginn might be a draft day trade. My wildcard is Bess will be cut or traded if we draft a slot receiver type with better speed

 

That was a nice summation, Padre of specific questions. This thread might be better served after the draft, however there is one question that can sum up all the questions about our O. (well, at least to me....)

Who is going to be our offensive play-maker ??

Brown - Questions about health continue to surround him. He's still best suited as a complementary back mainly due to the injury history. He can break big plays, but he's not a player the other team 'worries' about since he's about the ONLY player that fits the bill and can be controlled since they don't really have to worry about anyone else.

Ginn - not exactly yet. I personally still hold out hope that this kid develops into a bona fide NFL WR, but inconsistency has been his forte so far. He's an exciting return guy, but our overall return teams have been very poor for three years...that's still not enough to be that missing 'play-maker' though.

Cammy - Nice receiver...not a difference maker.
Bess - Ditto.
Hartline - maybe, there's room for potential with this kid, but more likely "see Cammy..."
Fasano - up and down years don't bode well for this kid either. He's another 'Cammy' type player. Nice player but not a difference maker.

Williams, Cobb, Lexy, Turner ?? Anyone really hold out hopes any of these guys will develop into that guy ?? Sorry, not me.

We need a Dez or Benn or a Tate or perhaps even an import via a draft day trade...in fact, in my fantasies, I still see that swap #1's and #3's with Dallas for Miles....if that occurs, I wouldn't even watch the rest of the draft....


Ok, that's a lie, but you get my drift....bottom line is we just don't have anyone that is feared by the rest of the NFL...

 

I don't see Camarillo being cut. He did not drop a single pass last year. Not one. He is money. All of those players have some trade value.

 

Ignore it all you want, but you know it is true. Pat White will never be an NFL caliber quarterback.

As far as Wake, Moses, or Anderson, Wake is the only one that has shown anything in limited time. Moses has been in the league for 3 years and has done nothing. Anderson has been in the league for 6 or 7 years and has done nothing. Culver has been in the league 4 years and has done nothing. It is foolish to think everyone on your team is just a late bloomer and to ignore these positions in the draft because you are concerned about the deepest position on this team.

 

Believe it or not Charlie Anderson was our best cover LB.....that being said, I agree with KB.....ignoring this positions can't be done....pick early quality and often for that LB corp....I dont wanna see a offensive pick until Mike Williams in the 4th...hahaha...if he even makes it that far, but thats where I slot him out as....I wouldnt spend a 3rd on him....

 

They're going to keep doing what they are doing with White. There will almost certainly be more "cute" stuff where he isn't the guy under center when they're more comfortable with him being able to fill that role, though.

Joe Berger, I'm claiming. There was very little if any dropoff from the fantastic year that Jake Grove was having.

They are the same guy, basically. If Fasano ends up as the #2, he's more '08 than '09.

Ginn, probably.

 

Why would they get rid of the low cost/high production players?

 

Sure, that kind of stuff I'd love to see, but they said that the focus would be on developing him as a Quarterback with the idea that he would have to come in like in the Steelers game even if he were primarily doing other stuff.

Well, at Center. That's what I thought Incognito would be initially, Center/Guard depth to let Berger move to Guard and not worry about it.

I'm completely with you here.

 

There's a whole lot that Grice-Mulllens would have to do before he's close to a replacement for Bess.

 

Too early to tell. Henne did some good things and some bad things last season. He's the incumbent now, so we'll see what he can do with a full offseason of starter prep under his belt, but he's not nearly the lock at QB that the dogma would suggest.

As for the backups... tough call. I can't see us going into the season with four QBs active, which means Thigpen or Pennington gets traded, White is listed as a non-QB for roster purposes (KR/PR, maybe?), or we cut a running back to make room. Don't see White making the practice squad: someone would claim him off waivers if he were cut.

If Turner doesn't have a productive training camp, he's gone. If he has a productive training camp, adios Camarillo.