I bring this up for the thoughts that him and Jeff Ireland might be in dis-agreement on drafting players, and acquiring free agents. When I say acquiring free agents, I mean ex- Bill Parcells players. Wouldn't it be better for this team to have one player personnel decision maker in Jeff Ireland? I just have to wonder how much better would our 2009 draft been with out Bill making decisions on the draft. If you think he is not having impact and sat in the player decision making process you have to be kidding yourself. I myself maybe in the minority, but I think it is time for bill to give control of the players decision making to Jeff and Tony.
If Jeff and Tony disagree with Bill on player moves how much could they actually disagree with him, without the threat of losing there jobs?
Tags:
- Thread Status:
- Not open for further replies.
Page 1 of 3
-
-
I think the only reason Parcells moves on is if Parcells wants to move on.
If someone offers him another mega buck deal to bring a team back, he may listen.
From what I understand he does like Florida. -
Do they disagree much? And how many ole Parcell players are still floating around in the league? I was thinking of starting a Parcell's thread regarding the fact that, in his mind, with the state of the franchise, and the flux the league will be in with the CBA...he couldn't possibly think his job is done, or justify jumping ship just yet. I think, Parcell's thinks, he HAS to come back. If as nothing but a pure admin.
-
I believe he has a hand in the process but how much of one I'm not really sure. I've read interviews where they said they'll all disagree with one thing or another day in or day out, but when it comes to drafting a prospect if they're *all* not on the same page they'll either try to get there or they realize that it's time to move on from that particular player.
I don't have a link for it otherwise I'd link it. -
PS, I remember reading in a Dolphin digest (I think it was Ireland interview) were he said they (Sparano, Ireland and Parcells) don't always agree on picks.
I have to find the story, its somewhere in my house. -
If anybody thinks Bill Parcells is going to leave after going 7-9 you are dead wrong. He will not leave till he thinks the job is done and 7-9 is not getting the job done.
dolfan7171 and skippysphins like this. -
Hmm is their some sort of a rift I didnt hear about?
Parcells is in a great position and honestly I would hate to lose his input. I remember when we were exploring the 2nd round tender for Miles Austin and Ireland didnt want to do it(can u blame him THEN) I wonder if they agreed on that decision. -
From what I have read, Parcells loves the player rah-rah/locker-room/work out room little visits and motivational things with who is on the roster...and loves college evaluation and player evaluation stuff....but decisions are Irelands I would think for final say (that doesn't mean he sees things differently than Bill however) - Bill may only live for WAR ROOM draft day stuff.
And game day, player decisions are all Sparano.
Again, maybe I am in the minority, but Parcells loves what he loves, but I do not get the impression that he is interfering with Jeff or Tony to do what he hired them to do.:hi5:dolfan7171, Paul 13 and RunRickyRun like this. -
I dont know, I always got the impression that they three of them got along, and all had input on the player personnel decisions. Didn't we read that somewhere during the draft last year?
I don't think we'll see Parcells go anywhere this year. It's clear that his job isn't quite done yet. I think Sparano said it best today in saying we're mediocre, and that isnt accepted here. Sure, we've made alot of progress, but there is still quite a bit to be made as well. I think with Parcells' ego, he isnt going to want to leave, until he feels that the job is done. I dont think he thinks that yet. However, that is just my opinion?dolfan7171 likes this. -
-
What I am getting at is that there one be one less person in the player personnel decision process. There fore perhaps increasing the odds of getting the right players in here. My thinking is less people to bump heads on the process that will make this team better. I would also like to cut our losses this off season, and admit our mistakes and move forward.
-
-
-
I get zero sense from Tony or Jeff that Bill is interefering with what HE HIRED THEM TO DO! -
Of all three of those guys I dont see how losing a mind that has built championship football teams would "increase" the odds of us getting the right player. Parcells specialty is talent evaluation, Ill take my chances with him. -
I will say this, whomever has been the major deciding factor in personell the last 2 years should probably go ahead and move on.
They have it on.... Well.... Jake Long, Devon Bess, Henne and Hartline, Sean Smith (Maybe) and Vontae Davis...thats it.
Keep in mind, almost the entire team has been revamped with very few players left from behind...
Just my 2 cents worth.jetssuck likes this. -
These guys have screwed up almost as much as they've done well......if this off season isn't much better, I'm not gonna be a happy Dolfan.NoCalFinFan and Fin-Omenal like this. -
-
-
Very risky signing at the least.. -
I did read somewhere that Bill Parcells was the one who was totally high on Pat White and really wanted him, so that had to play a part in our worst draft pick this year.
Fin-Omenal likes this. -
-
You can't expect any organization to hit on every player, its not going to happen. But overall, I think this front office compares favorably to the rest of the NFL. -
See how illogical winning can make you? We sound like Patriot fans right now...
This very team was 1-15 just 2 seasons ago. We catch some breaks the very next year and go 11-5 and make the playoffs. Then the following year we have the hardest schedule in the NFL, lose our starting QB (and have to break in a brand new rookie QB), we lose our Pro Bowl Half Back and a very solid CB (leaving us with two rookie CBs) and we finish 7-9. Yes, missing the playoffs leaves a sour taste in my mouth, but people need to look at the big picture here, we are moving in the right direction. -
Don't forget about players they've brought in via FA or trade. Randy Starks, Lousaka Polite (both should have been Pro Bowlers IMO), Jake Grove, Chad Pennington, Anthony Fasano who I believe is better than we've seen from him this year. Even Dan Carpenter. They've made a few bad decisions but they've also brought in a ton of good, young talent over the past few years. -
-
Fin-Omenal likes this.
-
For instance, your list includes Safety and OL......do you realize we currently have the most expensive OL and the most expensive Safeties in the league? You really think we can afford to upgrade those spots or that it's ok that we have to already?
They haven't been bad at what they do...........but just like Sparano's game day coaching, there's plenty of room for improvement. And our future depends on it. -
Jeff Ireland tried to fight it and didn't want White.
But Ireland is not perfect.. The Patrick Turner selection was all on Ireland. He said on WQAM after the draft that Turner was his pick, that he was the one pushing for Turner.. and that he picked him because he liked the fact that Turner had a long torso, with shorter legs. This helps big receivers move well in tight spaces and cut better ( so he said) -
Bill Parcells hired Ireland and I highly doubt he hired anyone that he did not fully trust and respect. I doubt these guys argue about players. I mean no one knows but that just would not make sense to hire a guy thats not on the same page as you. Every coach is going to make bad draft picks and make bad signings. Its just apart of the NFL.
I really can't believe that ppl are actually bringing up that they want trifecta gone at all. You don't change an entire franchise in two seasons. You can quick fix it and win games but you can really tell that what our coaches and front office is doing is building a team that will win every year and for years to come.Paul 13 and Fin-Omenal like this. -
-
finfansince72 Season Ticket Holder Club Member
Seems strange to read a lot of the comments here. IF we hadn't had a horrendous rash of injuries we wouldn't have been 7-9. The front office hasn't been perfect, every front office wiffs on a few draft picks, regrets not signing soandso, etc. To act as though we need major changes in our personnel staff is amazingly kneejerk and shortsighted. We are building a strong team here that will contend next year. Giving a front office 3 years to get rid of the driftwood and get their guys here is standard operating procedure...at least for good franchises. If we want to be the Lions and Browns we can get rid of front office personnel every year or two. I don't see the problem with our front office. The suggestion that Parcells is hurting the team is laughable and silly, I mean its unbelievable to even be reading some of this stuff. I know this was a frustrating year but if we have a rash of injuries next year and a hard schedule we'll be a 7 or 8 win team again more than likely.
-
Time to go? Its taken two years just to reset the pins again.
Two years for us just to get Parcells cued up with his version of mediocrity.
You know, the place before we fell into the cesspool of 1-15, has been our home for the last twenty five years?
Make no mistake, the Tuna isn't here to get us mediocre, actually, I don't really believe we ever left, a fringe mediocre in 07, just woefully undercoached, and chronically ill prepared.
This is when all eyes should BE on Parcell's, not Sparano, not Ireland, but the guy with the blueprints, the guy who at least knows the formula for playoff teams.
The pins are finally set, or to be more accurate, he's already thrown, now we need to see him pick up the spare.Fin-Omenal likes this. -
Other than bring TS and JI here, what has Bill really done here?
-
I don't think anyone is saying that they want to see any of the FO gone or changed yet, but there is room for improvement.
The past 2 years, we've spent A LOT of money and draft picks on Defense and quite frankly, with the exception of 2007, the 2009 defense was the worst defense I've seen out of a Dolphins team since the early 90's. There is no denying that.
And regarding the QB position. This FO was very fortunate. Pennington fell into their laps because of Favre last year, and we were lucky that Henne lasted until #60 in the draft. Remember, we passed on Henne with our #2a pick and were lucky that he fell to us at #2b. Had they not been very lucky with Pennington and Henne we would've went into 2008 with Josh McCown starting QB. YES, JOSH MCCOWN! That was the original plan, which would have put us somewhere in the realm of 6 wins last year and 7 this year. Improvment? yes. But where else can you go from 1-15.jetssuck likes this. -
In just 2 off-seasons, from FA, Trades, and Drafts he turned this franchise into one with balance and depth to the point that in a season with MAJOR injuries we still hung in every game, didn't get blown out, or quit, or give up, we were out played and our depth as cohesive and close as it was, was not top notch based on the reality that they weren't expected starters, and it showed in the end. Again, only 2 seasons removed from 1-15 and we ended 7-9 and 11-5 (18-14 overall). Have they hit on every FA or Draft pick, heck no, they arent claiming they did. Have they hit more than missed, yes, and they would be the first to tell you it ;)....but they are following a plan and they have this offseason to improve on their #'s to set it up so our team during the upcoming season improves on its.
Disappointed for sure......but this just smells of WHAT HAVE YOU DONE FOR ME LATELY and lacks of all perspective on what really has occurred it.
BP, TS, and JI are not the problem....the problem is on the field, and they are entering their 3rd offseason...just their 3rd....lets see it as part of their plan. Cause the best thing we should admit.....is they have one, they are following it.
Thats what they HAVE done for us lately.:hi5: -
According to Ross yesterday, he expects Parcells
"Ross stopped now in a lobby as Dolphins fans walked by him into the winter. One wished him luck. He thanked the man. Ross was then asked whether Bill Parcells was returning as football czar.
"As far as I know,'' he said after the Dolphins' 30-24 loss to Pittsburgh. "Everything we've talked about is moving ahead, about the future."
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/sports/...-hyde-steelers-0104-20100103,0,2640763.column
Now, this is just me saying this and you may think I'm nuts. But watch for Raider rumors with Parcells. He is very good friends with AL Davis. (Not saying he would go)
Although Parcells is a true and blue east coast guy. -
After sleeping on it a day and reading from people with cooler heads, I agree with the majority.
We are only 2 seasons removed from 1-15, had a trecherous schedule and an incredible amount of really bad injuries.
I am very unhappy with a handful of picks, and off-season moves, HOWEVER, what they have done considering what they had to work with is actually very impressive.
It is mainly the really bad picks of the two Pat's this past year that spurned my earlier rant, when in all reality, the upside of the guys they have brought in, either via FA or the draft.BigDogsHunt likes this.
Page 1 of 3
- Thread Status:
- Not open for further replies.