I am curious what everyone's opinion is regarding the future of the AFC over the next 3 seasons? So many variables have come into play, especially lately, and I'm seeing the shakings of repeat of the past.
First, I want to point out a notable poster on here lashed out when I laughed at him suggesting Brady was too old to be effective for more than 2 more years. After seeing him so far this season, still believe that? Not everyone on here who has experience on the sidelines feels the need to brag about it. Being able to watch decline in play due to age or confidence is something I believe most veteran coaches, even down at the high school level, can do. Peyton is clearly injured, and I believe he'll come back for one final season, and he'll look much better than he ended.
Brady? 3 more years, minimum. Guy looks incredible. Now, he might retire simply to avoid more injuries, but I doubt it. Very competitive, and has such a fantastic regiment he's able to pretty much avoid major wear and tear on his arm. He's playing until 40 if he wants.
BUT. Once he's gone, we've had plenty of time to see Luck, see Tannehill, see Manziel...
Who rules the AFC? Luck is pretty much the front runner, but discounting any possible 1st/2nd year prospect that kicks ***... who are your other AFC quarterbacks? Are we seeing Rex Ryan continue his great defense but awful quarterbacks? Is Tannehill CONTINUING to get better? Is he even with Miami due to personnel changes in Miami after a 9-7 (god forbid) season in 2015?
Before Ross hiring Tannebaum? I'd say Tannehill stays in Miami for another 5 years. Now? I genuinely dont know what the hell we are doing. What do you think?
Page 1 of 2
-
-
i think in 2-3 years its Luck and everybody else a notch below, Roethlisberger will be up in age as well as Rivers, i think Manziel won´t make it in this league and he will be a non factor, as for tannehill he has a chance to become the 2nd best QB behind Luck imo
Bpk likes this. -
-
I'd rather play it this way. The qbs I don't see being better than tannehill as of now or in the not too distant future. Dalton, manziel, Hoyer, mariota, Winston, manual, geno, bortles, Alex smith, mettenberger, jake locker, mallet, Tom savage.
If cross off the older guys, IMO, it looks like this.
Luck >>>flacco>tannehill, dalton, Alex smith, maybe Derek Carr, >>>>other guys
My point being tannehill has room to move up, but it's important to remember how many other guys he's already above IMO.Unlucky 13, DeDolfan, Brasfin and 1 other person like this. -
-
DON'T YOU SAY THAT.
Sent from my Transformer TF101 using Tapatalk 4eltos_lightfoot, Brasfin and Ohio Fanatic like this. -
With alll the coaches that were fired at Denver I wonder why Manning would want to come back.Its basically a regime change and it will be a few years before they challenge.
DeDolfan likes this. -
Da 'Fins Season Ticket Holder Staff Member Club Member
As long as Brady is healthy - he may play several more years. The fact is, he's an incredible quarterback who has a near perfect throwing motion (not release wise but mechanically) that will help him continue on. That said, one never knows. MLB pitchers can go into their 40's (Nolan Ryan, who was a physical beast and pitched with his legs as the power - went well into his 40's but for the most part the arm starts to break down). His arm or one hit that hurts a shoulder - and he could be in trouble (I don't wish that, honestly, because it hurts the game to lose a player long term).
But as far as the AFC QB situation - after Brady and Manning: 1) Luck; 2) Flacco; 3) Big Ben; 4) Rivers; 5) RT / Alex Smith (tie; week to week they would go up or down).
Not sure RT is near the top 10 in the NFL still. Even without Brady and Manning he's still #5 at best in the AFC (with those two he's #7 or #8 in the AFC). But, in the NFC you still have Brees, Ryan, Wilson, Romo, etc.
Bottom line, Tannehill has potential still. But, he definitely has to get better and I think there is upside there. However, he has to become a cerebral QB (which he hasn't really shown himself to be, yet). Then, he needs great O-line blocking (clear area of need in free agency and the draft) and he needs another WR who can be physical and make plays (not a mid-level #2 guy; but a true #1 type who has physicality).
Along those lines, there is potential in Crabtree becoming a free agent but also, potential for Larry Fitzgerald - his cap # is in the $20 million plus range which means they are going to have to release him or renegotiate. He will have to decide if he wants to stay in AZ the rest of his career with questions about Palmer's healthy return and the rest of the QB situation. Or risk free agency. if so, lots of teams will vie for him but the Dolphins should give huge consideration. LF is the most professional WR in the league. -
It's our conference after Brady Retires. The Colts are our stiffest competition for the future imo, but that is only because of 1 man. Remember they just gave away a 1st for basically nothing in trich. Vontae was a great move for them, but with the success they are having this year that's another late draft pick for them. We are in an incredible position for the future I believe. If we fail this year, Failbin will be fired which is something we may need. If we don't fail were in the playoffs and I'm not complaining one bit. With the 14th pick this year, we have a chance to add some serious talent in round 1 and 2 just like we did last year. I fully believe with another solid draft from Hickey, we will be one of the best young teams in the conference "talent wise" with a chance to dominate it as long as Tannehill keeps progressing. The Ravens and the North have some very good young teams too, the problem with the Ravens I believe is an aging Ngata, Suggs, Dumervil, Steve Smith, and RB. They're a little older than us and gonna have to rebuild more I believe, the other teams in the north either have huge questions at QB or an aging one.
-
It's our conference after Brady Retires. The Colts are our stiffest competition for the future imo, but that is only because of 1 man. Remember they just gave away a 1st for basically nothing in trich. Vontae was a great move for them, but with the success they are having this year that's another late draft pick for them. We are in an incredible position for the future I believe. If we fail this year, Failbin will be fired which is something we may need. If we don't fail were in the playoffs and I'm not complaining one bit. With the 14th pick this year, we have a chance to add some serious talent in round 1 and 2 just like we did last year. I fully believe with another solid draft from Hickey, we will be one of the best young teams in the conference "talent wise" with a chance to dominate it as long as Tannehill keeps progressing. The Ravens and the North have some very good young teams too, the problem with the Ravens I believe is an aging Ngata, Suggs, Dumervil, Steve Smith, and RB. They're a little older than us and gonna have to rebuild more I believe, the other teams in the north either have huge questions at QB or an aging one. Our 14th pick is gonna come in clutch this year too imo, great position.
-
Between Brady throwing motion and Belicheat always having a an effective if unspectacular running game. I can see Brady easily playing into his 40's.
Manning on the other had never met a pass play or coverage he didn't like. It wasn't until the Donkey went to offset line and emphasis the running game did Manning look like the Manning of old. -
Brady said he wants to play until he's forty, IIRC, and with the way he's playing, he's going to get his wish. He's 37 right now, that means 3 more years.
I think by then, if no other Luck-type young QB's show up, Tannehill is going to be at least top 3 in the AFC. All of the good younger QB's seem to be in the NFC: Rodgers, Matt Ryan, Stafford, Wilson, Kaepernick, Foles, Bridgewater...
If you put Luck at the top, Tannehill's competition in the AFC in about 4 years is going to be: a 37-year-old Rivers, a 36-year-old Roethlisberger, Joe Flacco, Alex Smith, Andy Dalton, Derek Carr, Blake Bortles, Johnny Manziel, and a handful of young QB's.
With the way Tannehill has been improving every year, I think his chances of getting near the top of that list are pretty good. -
Your 2017 AFC Pro Bowl QBs... Andrew Luck, Ryan Tannehill, Jay Cutler. Say what?????
-
If the Patriots offense keeps featuring the two yard pass, then Brady can retire at age 65.
-
Lets be honest here.
When Brady retires Belichick will insert Jimmy Garoppolo as the starter, and continue the dynasty.
They won 11 games with Matt Cassell in 2008.
Matt Cassell! It took me about a minute of racking my brain to remember that name...thats how terrible he is.
I'm more concerned with Belichicks retirement. -
-
-
Brady giving press conference in sleeveless hoodie. Has on a straight face, but must be dying of laughter inside.
-
-
I don't want to take anything away from him. He has that killer instinct that just wins games in the clutch. They will likely lose that.
But with the week to week regular season, I don't see the Patriots taking too many steps backwards. It may be a heavier run team, but will likely still sit on top of the AFC East. -
-
-
In Tannehill I trust.
-
-
Don't forget Drew Brees.
Then there is Andrew Luck, Big Ben, Phillip Rivers, and Russell Wilson.
That next tier is Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco.
Tanny is probably in the tier below that, but is the most promising young QB in the AFC East. -
Imagine actually having a shot at the division in week 17. Imagine the pats at 9-6 and us at 9-6. We've never had that opportunity because Tom pulls magic wins out of his *** like nobody else has done before. Just one errant throw or fumble here and there and the patriots would be human and beatable. It'll come. Idc how good jimmy is, he. won't. be. tom. -
-
I was thinking about this the other day as well. I know it sounds ridiculous, but come 2018 the following will either be out of the league or ineffective, IMO:
P. Manning
Brees
Brady
The following QBs will be over 35 and on the decline especially with where their bodies are:
Roethlisberger
Rivers
That's 4 of the AFCs 6 best QBs.
Luck will be a thorn in our sides for the next decade+. That's a given. Flacco will always have the Ravens 'there'. But after that, it's the newcomers.
If Tannehill can just continue to develop or even level off at some point in 2016-2017, we're going to be a contender in the AFC.
(how sad is it that I'm discussing excitement for the 2018 season?) -
-
finfansince72 Season Ticket Holder Club Member
-
I see Peyton retiring this year or next, I see Brady having 5-7 years left, I see Big Ben with 4-7 years left, I see Flacco with 7-10 years left, I see Rivers with 3-6 years left.
RT17 hasn't even punched his ticket to enter with the likes of these names yet, he belongs with A.Smith/A.Dalton in terms of conversation, so I will let RT17 prove to me he is in the category with the passers above before I say he's gonna be one of the best in the AFC in the future. For all we know, he could have a terrible year next year and get benched (because RT17 isn't exactly PM18, TB12, BR7, JF5, PR17, where he's allowed to have a bad year and get away with it) -
I would love to see what Urban Meyer could do with the Dolphins.
-
If Brady plays into his 40's, look for hitting the quarterback in the pocket to become a penalty. People who move around, like Wilson and Luck, will be fair game, but hitting a pocket QB while he's in the pocket will become illegal.
-
-
Pretty sad we are hoping other quarterbacks retire for our average qb can climb up the totem pole. Meanwhile Luck isnt waiting, hes challenging them.
Page 1 of 2