Volek and Pennington are the only ones that look good to me.

 

I'll take Penny, thank you.

 

Quite a while back CK said that Collins might be our QB next year. He was right about Daunte so maybe it will happen.

 

in the case of Collins, he knew his job; help Campbell become accustomed to Al Saunder's offense. His success as a starter is suprising (considering he hasn't taken a snap in 10 years), but he knows he doesn't have to win the game, and all he has to do is manage the game. He also knows he's not gonna be the long term starter so he's not worried about losing his job.

Hill would probably be the same way. Knows he's gonna be a back up so he's not worried about doing too much.

 

This thread jinxed him.

 

No, he just showed the type of player he is.

 

Give the reigns to BECK, sign a trustworthy clipboard holder and veteran backup only. Draft another QB in day two later rounds only cause of Becks age and young 3rd string QBs are quite valuable as trade bait sometimes or they emerge as starters down the line.

 

doesn't help that Moss stopped running

 

Please no Pennington.

 

Say what you want about the guy, but he finds a way to get things done. He may not have a very strong arm and he does have an injury history, but he's an intelligent QB that can give you a chance to win. We could do much worse, Todd Collins for example.

 

Well, Penny, Collins, etc....sign whoever you want but they are holding a clip board and only playing mop up and worst case injury time only to hold down the fort.....Beck is our near term future.

 

Agreed. I think whatever vet Miami brings in at QB should be brought in as a backup only.

 

Spinkle in some additional OL help and me likey likey

 

As long as it's not the Todd Collins I just watched.Kinda' looked like Jay Keebler to me.Always thought Volek had some potential.

 

We definitely don't "need" Todd Collins. All of those QB's are EXTREMELY AVERAGE AT BEST, honestly. I don't see the point in signing or trading for an old QB on a team that is being rebuilt. Of course we need a veteran QB, but not at the expense of a draft choice that Collins would cost. In that sense, I'd take Pennington if/when released, but he still sucks, IMO.

Todd Collins is officially the most overrated player in football. Yeah, I saw it coming.

 

this probably has merit. Sparano being a oline guru will fully understand that for a qb to succeed, he needs time, something John did not get

 

Yeah. I don't see the point in starting an old QB on a team that will win 7-8 games tops, probably about 4-5.

Veteran backup? Sure. But please........nothing more, nothing less.

 

Please Bill, don't touch any of them.

 

he is only younger than him by one year. personally im done with the 37 year old qbs. Id much rather get josh mccown.

 

I don't think we need Todd Collins, unless you mean we need a veteran backup. From the throws he made, it seemed like he thought Santana Moss was a 6'3 WR instead of a 5'10 guy.

 

I didnt think he had that bad of a game. His recievers dropped alot of passes, and the pick six was because his reciever gave up on the play.

 

Billy Volek would be quality competition for Beck maybe win the job outright.

 

Josh McCown is probably one of the most pathetic QB's in the NFL.

There's a reason why he's referred to mostly as "McClown"

I wouldn't even bring that guy in to compete for the 3rd string job.

 

The only person that least I would get is Pennington but he can't throw a deep much which will take Ginn's ability to go deep. Irony the only team I have seen him throw deep against is us.

Beck>?>rookie

Lemon will most likely get paid higher somewhere else to be a backup.

 

My 6 year old son can throw the ball with more zip than Collins.