I'm stunned to see Dirty Landry banned because he argues that Tannehill who has never been a top ten QB two games in a row isn't a top ten QB. We're going to be 6-10 or 7-9 this year. Why are we banning people that have a problem with that? Is this a Dolphins forum? Aren't the Dolphins going to lose more games then they won? Shouldn't we take issue with that? I'm not saying stop being a fan but the direction we're going is not an insert Tannehill and we're five games better one.
- Thread Status:
- Not open for further replies.
Page 1 of 4
-
-
-
I feel exactly that RT is below to avg qb and if others want to believe in stats that he is top 10 then that's on them, my opinion is if you care about stats then most qb to int ratio is something highly regarded right? so then Brett Favre shouldn't be elite!! I think his td to int ratio is something like 1-2 tds to 1 int which isn't really good when talking about elite or avg qb's, but I would take him over anyone but Rodgers, who by the way learned from him lol. so its basis of personal preference I take what I see on the field and I don't take stats compared from this guy to that guy as highly, for every qbs situations are different rt had multiple 200yard rusher last year. It will depend next year, what im going to love is this time next year when we go 7-9 again the discussion post I post that finally says everyone who says rt is a top 10 qb stand up, but by that time it will be something else the receivers cant catch or running wrong routes or it will be back on the o-line lol
But like I have said every time in a discussion about this, I do hope RT proves me wrong and leads us to the promise land I just don't see it.dolphin25 likes this. -
All he did was defend himself vs the Alt Tanny group from what I saw. Was he a dick to those guy's? No more than they were to him.
It is a disturbing trend of watching guy's who are extremists vs RT getting weeded out all the while extremists who are RT apologists are still doing what they do.
2 things however. I don't know what goes on in the PM's once a guy is asked to tone it down. If a mod sends you a message asking you to chill out and you reply with a "suck my d-ck" you aren't likely to be around. Is that happening? I dunno, I would like to think that this streak of Anti Tanny's being 86'd (Landry/Dan/CIF) is coinciding with other issues and not the debates between these two extreme groups which frankly has BOTH sides failing.
For the record, I'm not a proponent of banning anyone unless you have no choice. The site isn't nearly as big as it once was in terms of activity. A site of extremists is better than no site at all.dolphin25, Rock Sexton, Tin Indian and 1 other person like this. -
I imagine with Dirty it was more the constant starting of unnecessary threads to argue the same things, and the trolling nature of many of his posts.
As to finsfandan, I have no clue. I've had him blocked for years. LOLdanmarino, Irishman, ripper1961 and 4 others like this. -
dolphin25, Dolphin North, Rock Sexton and 2 others like this.
-
Pretty soon this site will be nothing but a dozen guys patting each other on the back after another 7-9 season..
dolphin25, hitman8, Rickysabeast and 8 others like this. -
dolphin25, Boik14, Rickysabeast and 3 others like this.
-
I agree with the dictated tone, but dirtylandry didn't do himself any favors by posting empty content and stances not supported by any factual information ON TOP of instigating posters he's had a recurrent history with. Those posters have since apologized on the mains here, and I, at least, saw some concerted efforts from those posters to not bring their own personal histories to their threads.
That being said, it should have never happened in the first place. For awhile though, it was getting downright childish in here.
People also need to stop accusing posters of being dirtylandry. It's kind of old and desperate. You can tell through reading these people's posts that they aren't the same person, it's a conspiracy theory I just can't get behind. I don't agree with hitman8, like.. ever, but he's at least got the wherewithal to articulate his gripes, as tired as his gripes get. Dirty, from what I could tell, wouldn't really fire back with anything of substance about 80% of the time. It won't build you any currency on a discussion board to.. refuse to have a substantive discussion.
That's just how I feel though.Irishman, ChrisKo, shamegame13 and 2 others like this. -
-
This is why I don't even post that much anymore.Why argue over the team I love with other fans.The arguments just go on and on because nobody will ever admitt they are wrong.I also noticed this site is getting less and less traffic every year.The mods should ask themselves why is this happening.And no its not trumps fault.
Irishman, dolphin25, shamegame13 and 3 others like this. -
It’s become a whole “if you think Tannehill is average that means your DirtyLandry and our focus is now to have you banned” and that is so transparent and easy to see as I have been baited on quite a few occasions. They do this to belittle the poster as we all know DirtyLandry wasn’t too great of a poster and it’s used as an insult. Personally, I find it funny and annoying at the same time because if I was to say that the 5 guys who think Tannehill is elite/top 10 were all the same person, I would get unfair penalties against me.
What’s funny is most people around planet earth would find Tannehill to be an average QB which would mean there is a lot of DirtyLandry.
Say what you want about DirtyLandry, I didn’t think he was a good poster but he sure left his mark around here.dolphin25, Rock Sexton, pumpdogs and 1 other person like this. -
-
its funny there are more people who think RT is avg or below avg than there are people who think he's top 10, its just asinine to tell someone there wrong. ya you'd get banned for attacking someone if you pointed out things about anyone else. I was called dirty Landry a few times, I know look at it as an achievement and am proud of it hahahahah -
But here’s the kicker, 1 poster who witch hunts, goes so crazy with it that you clearly know this guy has a few names himself on here. He gives himself up so easily because that’s all he does now is call people Dirty and just serious projections of what he is more than likely doing himself.
We have to stop replying to each other Balla, soon they will say me and you are the same person and come up with some crazy Shutter Island type theory for the “why and how” this is happening.Last edited: Dec 27, 2017dolphin25, Rickysabeast and bigballa2102 like this. -
Last edited by a moderator: Dec 28, 2017dolphin25 and shamegame13 like this.
-
Last edited by a moderator: Dec 28, 2017bigballa2102 likes this.
-
He is not top 10 until he is top 10.Will that ever happen?I hope so but now coming off this long layoff with knee.I have my doubts.
If he doesn't do it in 2018 it's time to move on.bigballa2102 likes this. -
Have a conversation with a non Phins fan outside the Miami region and ask a fan about Tannehill.... he wouldn’t even know what to tell you.... “uhhhhh he still plays?” would be the general tone you got back.bigballa2102 likes this. -
ya missing 2017 really hurt him because with the strength of schedule next year might be high if he doesn't succeed I don't know how you don't move on from him ya know?
I as well hope he strives and proves me wrong, and guess what if he does ill come back and apologize.shamegame13 likes this. -
shamegame13 likes this.
-
-
-
-
dolphin25 likes this.
-
I’ll take Goff, Wentz, or Jimmy G over Tannehill
Dolphin Dundee, muskrat21 and bigballa2102 like this. -
bigballa2102 likes this.
-
no one is basing anything on facts we are joking around about how ridiculous it is people saying every is dirty.
I agree derailing a post with non sense is bad, but whats also bad is everyone getting their panties in a bunch over something that means nothing and complaining and saying insults as everyone is dirty, is childish and just as bad as your so called "straw man" so if you going to look at one side look at the other.dolphin25 and shamegame13 like this. -
You guys (Balla, Pump) realize we look like one big DirtyLandry-ball out here, right? LMAO
Irishman and bigballa2102 like this. -
this is a qb driven league, I've said this 100 times the bad part about Miami is that they are creating an atmosphere where no one wants to come and play, that needs to change. i have some insight and wont share how i know but the whole deal with grimes and his wife, the whole rt thing is interesting she should have not put it on social media but the information was pretty profound.dolphin25 and shamegame13 like this. -
hahaha now that makes me laugh, man wish everyone could lighten up like this and stop taking stuff so serious we are out of the playoffs the season ends on sunday why not have fun i mean jesus can we pick up the RT sucks, no hes great threads again next year, and joke and then get serious about draft time lol.shamegame13 likes this. -
i hope i am wrong man how i hope -
canesz06 and bigballa2102 like this.
-
shamegame13 likes this.
Page 1 of 4
- Thread Status:
- Not open for further replies.