Who is to blame if you cant score from 5 yards away with 8 downs?
198 replies
I think if you click on the Club Level link on the main page, it tells you. You send a check (might be another payment option) to someone, and they give you access to Club.
$24 per year. Not bad. You have to have paypal. I will set it up later.
"resnor wrote:
Dude, you say that other teams have olines that are bad, and compared us to Atlanta.
I pointed out how a team with a bad OL can do things to overcome it with great play calling and getting rid of the ball faster.
Had nothing to do with a Dolphin comparison as much as a general statement....not shocked that didn't get comprehended though.
"The reason so many people misunderstand so many issues is not that these issues are so complex, but that the people do not want a factual or analytical explanation that leaves them emotionally unsatisfied"
Tannehill usually gets rid of the ball quickly. The problem is that when teams rush 4, there are 7 guys in coverage. I know you think Tannehill throws short too much, but it's hard to throw deeper with all the coverage.
"resnor wrote:
Tannehill usually gets rid of the ball quickly. The problem is that when teams rush 4, there are 7 guys in coverage. I know you think Tannehill throws short too much, but it's hard to throw deeper with all the coverage.
Id respond but I'd get accused of comparing something or someone with something that was never said.
"The reason so many people misunderstand so many issues is not that these issues are so complex, but that the people do not want a factual or analytical explanation that leaves them emotionally unsatisfied"
"resnor wrote:
Tannehill doesn't often have "bad games." I think his lowest rating last season was a 70. He'll have a poor half, or some poor throws. It's a problem when your QB is being asked to throw 30+ times, with an oline that couldn't block a D III defensive line, and zero hope of a run game to keep the defense honest. Like I said, Tannehill has to play at a HoF level every game just to give the Dolphins a chance.
It's disgusting to expect that of any QB, and ridiculous to hold it against any QB who can't maintain that level of play every, single game.
This exactly!
No QB in the league would be able to play consistently good with this haphazard o-line. It is so infuriating to know that we have good WR's, good RB's, and a good QB, but we can't do anything because there is NEVER any blocking.
Now, saying that I also think the coaches, at least Philbin, needs to go. He's lost this team.
Tanne's faults are being exacerbated by the bad Oline play, pocket awareness, accuracy, ability to think under duress, he's a decent QB as long as the rest of the team performs well, he's an upper tier 3 QB and I'm not sure that will change.

"resnor wrote:
There hasn't been a whole lot of "good arguments" from those on the side against Tannehill. There has been a whole lot of attributing things erroneously to Tannehill, and letting the entire rest of the team off the hook.
There has been several great arguments against Tannehill, but they're met mostly with blind optimism and flaming. So the nay-sayers mostly remain quiet.
But honestly, I agree with almost everyone here- it's impossible not to blame Philbin, Coyle and Lazor for the vast majority of the problems. The defense did step up some in the second half, surprisingly with Grimes off the field, which tells me that a youth movement would not be a bad thing at this point. Get the folks on the field who want to play and let them make some plays.
On offense, the problems are literally everywhere. And as much as we all love Landry, putting the ball in his hands every single down is a recipe for disaster. We can't beat anyone on screen passes and that's what this offense has become. When your top passes of the day all came from pass interference (and two of the three were clearly uncatchable), that's a big problem.
The line also did better in the 2nd half though, and those of you blindly saying Tannehill is the guy are lying to yourself. He missed on throws over and over and over again this week, despite us dominating field position in the 2nd half and controlling the tempo. Honestly folks, we left 28+ points on the field in the 2nd half alone all from Tannehill's misses, and at some point you have to start admitting that he's getting a lot more chances than you're letting on. To defend Tannehill, teams have to cut off the short routes and it's game over. We have deep threats 1:1 all day long because of it, and the only way teams will play us differently is if Tannehill starts connecting. We have 50+ games to tell us that it won't happen though, which means he's out there getting slaughtered for nothing. I think everyone here likes Tannehill and wants to see him succeed, but it is literally impossible at this point in this offense.
Make no mistake though, Lazor didn't overthrow a dozen receivers today on easy TD's. We were BLESSED with three flags that made things seems a little better than it really was, but those passes were sailing and not going to be caught. Pressure or no pressure, that's 100% on your quarterback's shoulders for (1) not being able to make the proper reads quick enough (2) for being inaccurate and (3) for not having the trust of the coaching staff to make something happen. And for the record, I'm not talking about the plays where defenders rushed in untouched....Tannehill had over 25 throws today with a clean pocket. Unfortunately though, several of them were screens to Landry, dump-off passes or deep incomplete...which is exactly what our opponents game-plan for. Plain and simple, he's just not accurate enough.
But let's give him the benefit of the doubt. You play head coach- how do you win with Tannehill? He's a 36% career passer on anything over 20 yards, and the defense is playing a short zone each week smothering up all the short stuff. They're also blitzing on every down because Miami can't go deep, and those blitzes make it a lot harder for us to run the football through the gaps as well. So with Tannehill on the field, we can't run, we can't throw short and we can't throw deep.
And don't give us, "Well it's because of the coach and the line." That's a big part of the problem, sure. But it is what it is and we still need to compete for 12 games despite those issues. So you tell me- how exactly do we win with Ryan Tannehill with this team and this offense? Because if you don't have a legitimate answer, then Tannehill can't be the guy.
Or let me ask it a different way. Pull Tannehill off the field and insert Dan Marino in his 5th year as a pro. Against that defense today, does Marino throw 2 TD's and 2 picks? We can't say because they'd play Marino completely different. They wouldn't blitz as much because Dan is the Man reading the field and finding the open target quickly, and he has a knack for making adjustments and exploiting the deep throws when teams cheat up on him.
Tannehill simply isn't the guy folks. He's tough. He's a competitor. He's resilient and a dozen other things. But he's not accurate on intermediate throws and we're far too one-dimensional with him on the field. Insert an accurate passer though, and everything changes because the defense is kept honest. I can't understand how others can't see that other than they just don't want to see it.
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
The answer is, you fix the biggest problems, and get them to be average, at least. If then Tannehill still is struggling, you replace him, too.
"KeyFin wrote:
There has been several great arguments against Tannehill, but they're met mostly with blind optimism and flaming. So the nay-sayers mostly remain quiet.
But honestly, I agree with almost everyone here- it's impossible not to blame Philbin, Coyle and Lazor for the vast majority of the problems. The defense did step up some in the second half, surprisingly with Grimes off the field, which tells me that a youth movement would not be a bad thing at this point. Get the folks on the field who want to play and let them make some plays.
On offense, the problems are literally everywhere. And as much as we all love Landry, putting the ball in his hands every single down is a recipe for disaster. We can't beat anyone on screen passes and that's what this offense has become. When your top passes of the day all came from pass interference (and two of the three were clearly uncatchable), that's a big problem.
The line also did better in the 2nd half though, and those of you blindly saying Tannehill is the guy are lying to yourself. He missed on throws over and over and over again this week, despite us dominating field position in the 2nd half and controlling the tempo. Honestly folks, we left 28+ points on the field in the 2nd half alone all from Tannehill's misses, and at some point you have to start admitting that he's getting a lot more chances than you're letting on. To defend Tannehill, teams have to cut off the short routes and it's game over. We have deep threats 1:1 all day long because of it, and the only way teams will play us differently is if Tannehill starts connecting. We have 50+ games to tell us that it won't happen though, which means he's out there getting slaughtered for nothing. I think everyone here likes Tannehill and wants to see him succeed, but it is literally impossible at this point in this offense.
Make no mistake though, Lazor didn't overthrow a dozen receivers today on easy TD's. We were BLESSED with three flags that made things seems a little better than it really was, but those passes were sailing and not going to be caught. Pressure or no pressure, that's 100% on your quarterback's shoulders for (1) not being able to make the proper reads quick enough (2) for being inaccurate and (3) for not having the trust of the coaching staff to make something happen. And for the record, I'm not talking about the plays where defenders rushed in untouched....Tannehill had over 25 throws today with a clean pocket. Unfortunately though, several of them were screens to Landry, dump-off passes or deep incomplete...which is exactly what our opponents game-plan for. Plain and simple, he's just not accurate enough.
But let's give him the benefit of the doubt. You play head coach- how do you win with Tannehill? He's a 36% career passer on anything over 20 yards, and the defense is playing a short zone each week smothering up all the short stuff. They're also blitzing on every down because Miami can't go deep, and those blitzes make it a lot harder for us to run the football through the gaps as well. So with Tannehill on the field, we can't run, we can't throw short and we can't throw deep.
And don't give us, "Well it's because of the coach and the line." That's a big part of the problem, sure. But it is what it is and we still need to compete for 12 games despite those issues. So you tell me- how exactly do we win with Ryan Tannehill with this team and this offense? Because if you don't have a legitimate answer, then Tannehill can't be the guy.
25 clean pockets??? more like 4.
The line is legendarily bad. Not a single QB in the NFL would succeed with this nightmare set up.
But those of you who have made up your minds will ignore this.
So what's the point?
"jcs92593 wrote:
25 clean pockets??? more like 4.
The line is legendarily bad. Not a single QB in the NFL would succeed with this nightmare set up.
But those of you who have made up your minds will ignore this.
So what's the point?
Thanks for proving my point....the only possible way you can defend Tannehill is to point fingers at others. Because there's not a single positive thing you can say about how he COULD HAVE led us to victory today. But you insert a solid QB on those four plays you mentioned and it's 4 TD passes with the wide open man down the sidelines.
But watch the film again and start counting. He threw 44 passes and a heck of a lot more than 4 were clean pockets. The 2nd half protection was decent, yet his production actually dropped.
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
"KeyFin wrote:
There has been several great arguments against Tannehill, but they're met mostly with blind optimism and flaming. So the nay-sayers mostly remain quiet.
But honestly, I agree with almost everyone here- it's impossible not to blame Philbin, Coyle and Lazor for the vast majority of the problems. The defense did step up some in the second half, surprisingly with Grimes off the field, which tells me that a youth movement would not be a bad thing at this point. Get the folks on the field who want to play and let them make some plays.
On offense, the problems are literally everywhere. And as much as we all love Landry, putting the ball in his hands every single down is a recipe for disaster. We can't beat anyone on screen passes and that's what this offense has become. When your top passes of the day all came from pass interference (and two of the three were clearly uncatchable), that's a big problem.
The line also did better in the 2nd half though, and those of you blindly saying Tannehill is the guy are lying to yourself. He missed on throws over and over and over again this week, despite us dominating field position in the 2nd half and controlling the tempo. Honestly folks, we left 28+ points on the field in the 2nd half alone all from Tannehill's misses, and at some point you have to start admitting that he's getting a lot more chances than you're letting on. To defend Tannehill, teams have to cut off the short routes and it's game over. We have deep threats 1:1 all day long because of it, and the only way teams will play us differently is if Tannehill starts connecting. We have 50+ games to tell us that it won't happen though, which means he's out there getting slaughtered for nothing. I think everyone here likes Tannehill and wants to see him succeed, but it is literally impossible at this point in this offense.
Make no mistake though, Lazor didn't overthrow a dozen receivers today on easy TD's. We were BLESSED with three flags that made things seems a little better than it really was, but those passes were sailing and not going to be caught. Pressure or no pressure, that's 100% on your quarterback's shoulders for (1) not being able to make the proper reads quick enough (2) for being inaccurate and (3) for not having the trust of the coaching staff to make something happen. And for the record, I'm not talking about the plays where defenders rushed in untouched....Tannehill had over 25 throws today with a clean pocket. Unfortunately though, several of them were screens to Landry, dump-off passes or deep incomplete...which is exactly what our opponents game-plan for. Plain and simple, he's just not accurate enough.
But let's give him the benefit of the doubt. You play head coach- how do you win with Tannehill? He's a 36% career passer on anything over 20 yards, and the defense is playing a short zone each week smothering up all the short stuff. They're also blitzing on every down because Miami can't go deep, and those blitzes make it a lot harder for us to run the football through the gaps as well. So with Tannehill on the field, we can't run, we can't throw short and we can't throw deep.
And don't give us, "Well it's because of the coach and the line." That's a big part of the problem, sure. But it is what it is and we still need to compete for 12 games despite those issues. So you tell me- how exactly do we win with Ryan Tannehill with this team and this offense? Because if you don't have a legitimate answer, then Tannehill can't be the guy.
Last year Tom Brady was a 28% passer on anything over 20 yards. And since 2009 Brady has been at 37%.
If you really want to get down to it you could look at "air yards". Meaning how many yards did the QB actually throw the ball without adding the YAC.
64% of RT's yards last season came from the ball being in the air.
To compare:
Brady: 49%
Rodgers: 50%
Manning: 63%
Luck: 59%
"danmarino wrote:
Last year Tom Brady was a 28% passer on anything over 20 yards. And since 2009 Brady has been at 37%.
If you really want to get down to it you could look at "air yards". Meaning how many yards did the QB actually throw the ball without adding the YAC.
64% of RT's yards last season came from the ball being in the air.
To compare:
Brady: 49%
Rodgers: 50%
Manning: 63%
Luck: 59%
And you think Tannehill's receivers getting less yards after the catch mean that he's more accurate than the others? Come on guys, a blind man could see through that warped logic.
Tannehill's "longest" TD pass of the year in 2014 was 50 yards...which ranks 42nd among active passers right behind Mohamed Sanu....a WR who threw 3 total passes in Cinci last season. Yes, a wide receiver did in three attempts what Tannehill managed to do only once the entire season. Every other starting NFL quarterback (and 9 backups) did better, but somehow none of this is on Tannehill? Ever? Come on guys.
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
Yep...the oline would cause even Aaron Rodgers to continually throw passes that give his wr no chance to make a play:shifty:. On 4th down no less. Common sense should tell you tannehill and the offensive line are a problem along with the playcalling. It'd not one or the other. Tannehill is PART of the problem. It's nobody's fault but his own when he misses an open receiver. Assuming he had a reasonable amount to time to throw, which isn't always the case but I don't hold those plays against him. Some of you clowns don't hold ANYTHING against him. It's all someone else's fault. 4 yrs of this excuse making ****.
"KeyFin wrote:
Thanks for proving my point....the only possible way you can defend Tannehill is to point fingers at others. Because there's not a single positive thing you can say about how he COULD HAVE led us to victory today. But you insert a solid QB on those four plays you mentioned and it's 4 TD passes with the wide open man down the sidelines.
But watch the film again and start counting. He threw 44 passes and a heck of a lot more than 4 were clean pockets. The 2nd half protection was decent, yet his production actually dropped.
I will try one time. If you don't get this, I can't help you.
44 passes is IDIOTIC play calling. 6 runs. Now tell me, is that a balanced offense??? No. So the defense KNOWS you are going to pass, running isn't even an option. So they can blitz corners every play with no fear. Now, couple this with a line that can't block anybody, and tell me how a QB is going to be able to take his drop, go through his reads and find the open WR and deliver the ball. With less than 2-3 seconds??? Can't be done.
I'm not saying he is elite, but he is damn good. The line is abhorrent. I just want them to be average and we are fine. They are well below that. He ran for his life all game. The TD to Stoneburner was a great pass, off his back foot, he couldn't step into the throw since there was a defender already at his legs. And the pass when he stepped out of the sack and hit Landry was great too. Both plays saw a defender in the backfield in less than 2 seconds. And yes. I timed the plays.
But keep blaming the QB it's easier!
"KeyFin wrote:
Thanks for proving my point....the only possible way you can defend Tannehill is to point fingers at others. Because there's not a single positive thing you can say about how he COULD HAVE led us to victory today. But you insert a solid QB on those four plays you mentioned and it's 4 TD passes with the wide open man down the sidelines.
But watch the film again and start counting. He threw 44 passes and a heck of a lot more than 4 were clean pockets. The 2nd half protection was decent, yet his production actually dropped.
Maybe you should watch how Andrew Luck played vs the Jets two weeks ago. Or do you think Luck is a bad QB also?
"KeyFin wrote:
And you think Tannehill's receivers getting less yards after the catch mean that he's more accurate than the others? Come on guys, a blind man could see through that warped logic.
I'm saying that you think RT is horrible at long throws and that's the cause for the offensive woes. I'm showing you that this is not the case.
"danmarino wrote:
Last year Tom Brady was a 28% passer on anything over 20 yards. And since 2009 Brady has been at 37%.
If you really want to get down to it you could look at "air yards". Meaning how many yards did the QB actually throw the ball without adding the YAC.
64% of RT's yards last season came from the ball being in the air.
To compare:
Brady: 49%
Rodgers: 50%
Manning: 63%
Luck: 59%
Do you have a link for your 64% air yards on Tannehill and others?
"BigNastyDB13 wrote:
Yep...the oline would cause even Aaron Rodgers to continually throw passes that give his wr no chance to make a play:shifty:. On 4th down no less. Common sense should tell you tannehill and the offensive line are a problem along with the playcalling. It'd not one or the other. Tannehill is PART of the problem. It's nobody's fault but his own when he misses an open receiver. Assuming he had a reasonable amount to time to throw, which isn't always the case but I don't hold those plays against him. Some of you clowns don't hold ANYTHING against him. It's all someone else's fault. 4 yrs of this excuse making ****.
The reason RT misses so many long throws is because he's not allotted the amount of time needed to allow his WR to get to the spot on the field he's throwing to.
Basic Football 101.
"jcs92593 wrote:
I will try one time. If you don't get this, I can't help you.
44 passes is IDIOTIC play calling. 6 runs. Now tell me, is that a balanced offense??? No. So the defense KNOWS you are going to pass, running isn't even an option. So they can blitz corners every play with no fear. Now, couple this with a line that can't block anybody, and tell me how a QB is going to be able to take his drop, go through his reads and find the open WR and deliver the ball. With less than 2-3 seconds??? Can't be done.
I'm not saying he is elite, but he is damn good. The line is abhorrent. I just want them to be average and we are fine. They are well below that. He ran for his life all game. The TD to Stoneburner was a great pass, off his back foot, he couldn't step into the throw since there was a defender already at his legs. And the pass when he stepped out of the sack and hit Landry was great too. Both plays saw a defender in the backfield in less than 2 seconds. And yes. I timed the plays.
But keep blaming the QB it's easier!
Okay, so you named his two BEST passes of the entire day. Two down, forty-two to go. That's not an argument, my friend. And I'm saying that because I'm not the enemy here....I love Tannehill and the Fins as much as anyone. But you can't take the good, ignore the bad and blame everything else on the line and the coach. We've done that for five seasons now and eventually, the quarterback has to be accountable.
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
Watching the Colts. Their line is a lot better than ours. Hasselbeck has had a clean pocket most of the game. And they are opening holes for Gore.
"yoge wrote:
Who is at fault here?
Philbin is. He refuses to employ a FB and refuses to run a power game. The O line is expensive and still sucks. Everything starts with Queasy.
.
"AdamC13 wrote:
Do you have a link for your 64% air yards on Tannehill and others?
http://www.sportingcharts.com/nfl/stats/quarterback-air-yards/2015/
"KeyFin wrote:
Okay, so you named his two BEST passes of the entire day. Two down, forty-two to go. That's not an argument, my friend. And I'm saying that because I'm not the enemy here....I love Tannehill and the Fins as much as anyone. But you can't take the good, ignore the bad and blame everything else on the line and the coach. We've done that for five seasons now and eventually, the quarterback has to be accountable.
I'm not saying the QB is blame free, maybe 10-15% is on him. The rest is on the line and play calling. Get them average, he will shine. He has showed it plenty of games that when the line blocks, he can make plays.
But blaming him for today just shows an agenda against him. He had no time all game.
"danmarino wrote:
The reason RT misses so many long throws is because he's not allotted the amount of time needed to allow his WR to get to the spot on the field he's throwing to.
Basic Football 101.
Naaa. He throws uncatchable balls out of bounds all the time. Always has regardless of his time.
.