Do we want to win?
8 replies
Win or no to get the 1st pick
I’m torn. I never want to see them lose. But is really the difference between 1 and 3 a big difference? It hard to even type this we’ve fallen so far.
Lots of people will tell you what they think about you and what you shouldn't and should do. Not everyone's thoughts are worth consideration. Don't take criticism from anyone who you wouldn't also go to for advice.
The first pick, hopefully to trade down for a haul, is unquestionably my first choice. That was the case coming into the season. Why root for a few wins that would drop their position and make the future potentially worse?
Coaching is more important than talent. The more wine Hafley can coax out of this group the higher I will be on him. We had a good chance of winning the last 2 games with better kicking.
So yeah I'm on board with us going on a win streak.
I feel like picks 3-5 are the sweet spot to get max value for trading down. For one it puts more teams in range and while still costly not as costly as #1. Only bright side to having the #1 pick for me is the National Media having to talk about the Dolphins all off season.
And draft position be damned, I hate losing. I hate losing more than I love winning at anything.
This is a strange year since there's three solid QB prospects and none of them might go #1 overall since all three have had somewhat disappointing seasons. Because of that, maybe one or more returns for another year of college- who knows?
Some could argue that the top four or five players in this draft aren't QBs. So let's say we pick #1 overall. Do you take Smith, the can't miss receiver at that spot? I don't know. Or the CB out of Notre Dame? These aren't typically positions that go first, so it's a strange draft and in some ways, I don't think #1 carries it's normal value like when you have a "can't miss" QB sitting there.
If Miami wins a few more games, then we pick maybe top-5. If Miami loses out, maybe we pick top-2. I don't see that as much of a difference in this draft, but it would make a huge difference for our current roster to end the year with 3 or 4 wins. If we win out, maybe we fall outside of the top-10 completely...but if we win out then I think we already have our QB for next season anyway. So even in that highly unlikely scenario, we're not missing out on much but we have a huge boost in confidence on our roster.
The only way I could see wanting to lose out is if you're 100% all in on the WR Smith. Great player and I'm not opposed to it. If you're 100% all-in on Manning or Mestermaker (or Mensah from Miami), then okay....you can get your QB at #1. This year is strange though because you can probably get that same QB at #3. I really believe that the top 2 or 3 picks will not be a QB.
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
My worry is that the management will see Willis as THE qb to to take us forward, when clearly, in my opinion, he isn't. He's a very serviceable player and as a back up or as a number 1 until the draft pick gets up to speed, if we pick one of the top qb's, I'd be very happy with that, but he isn't going to be the franchise qb or get us to a Superbowl any time soon.
________________________________________________________________________________________________
Every week I hope for a win and will enjoy it if we do...but I'm also not that bothered if we lose and so move towards a higher pick. The performances and progression are the main things for me, and on that basis I've been fairly happy this season. We've not really been blown out by anybody, even good teams we were heavy underdogs against, bar maybe the 49ers. We've played tough just about every week, and you can see that Hafley is getting a tune out of our undertalented squad, and that's a win in my books.
I'd much rather we were in our position of low expectations and promising performances than the like of the Chargers and Colts with high expectations for the season and demoralising performances.
Phin McCool#6↑My worry is that the management will see Willis as THE qb to to take us forward, when clearly, in my opinion, he isn't. He's a very…
My worry is that the management will see Willis as THE qb to to take us forward, when clearly, in my opinion, he isn't. He's a very serviceable player and as a back up or as a number 1 until the draft pick gets up to speed, if we pick one of the top qb's, I'd be very happy with that, but he isn't going to be the franchise qb or get us to a Superbowl any time soon.
I like Willis because he can move the chains with his legs, which completely transforms this offense and keeps drives alive. Much of our success this season has been on his back and I appreciate him for it. I don't like Willis because he's not processing the field fast enough, he's not throwing accurate passes consistently, and he sometimes takes unnecessary chances.
In my book he's still a rookie since he hasn't started a full season yet, so the negatives don't weigh on me like they would a true 3rd or 4th year QB (like a Tua or a RT). He can certainly still grow past some of the mistakes and raise his overall ceiling, which could be absolutely huge. But at the same time, I don't necessarily think he should be the locked-in starter until we find that next guy.
I'm not against Willis and I hope he sticks around. I've loved the leadership he's shown to this team despite the struggles we've had. If we're picking top-3 though and we don't take the top WR or top CB, we must draft a QB.
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
I dont want to lose but i think itll happen organically whether i want it or not. I felt that way before the season started. Theyre playing hard but theres a clear shortage of talent.