Rich Gannon was a fine mobile Qb back in the day, he knows what he is speaking about when it comes to White running between the tackles..sort of...

Encouraging about White's accuracy, but "praise agendas" are nothing new this time of year and Sparano has said as much when asked about where White would be moved if he doesn't emerge as one of the three best Qb's:

per rotoworld.

 

That's a pretty huge assumption. I have no idea where they are getting that from.

 

so your saying he didnt fail? he succeeded? i dont think so.

 

Well, despite the fact that I don't think he completely failed, no that wasn't what I meant. I meant that I don't know where they got that he won't be active in a similar role this year.

 

similar meaning him being listed as a QB. with henne, penny and thigpen....i dont see how he will be "active" at all. but thats just me i guess.

 

Does Patrick Turner have the work ethic of Jamarcis Russel?

 

For 50 plays?

I'd say he neither failed nor succeeded, to small a sample to say one way or another.

To illustrate, Pat Cobbs played 65 plays last year, White was just not out on the field very often.

 

Until the Steeler game.
I'll ask again if we need that game to get into the playoffs does Henne leave that football game. The answer is no. We gave white his shot.
Disaster...

 

Au contraire, at crunch time White was out there on the field instead of Henne in the Titans game on a must have 2pt conversion attempt.

Success, and that was with 52 plays.

 

Don't be surprised when White emerges from camp as the #2 QB.

 

I would be more than surprised. I would be beyond shocked. PW sucks. No other way to say it. If he improves to where he is #3 even, I'll be surprised. The guy is awful

 

Surprised?

I'll be horrified

 

Lol. Wow. This is the excitement last year's second rounder brings to fans.

 

This is the reality of what White has shown us so far. I don't care if he was taken #1 overall (well, really I would, but just as a metaphor), if he can't play at this level, which he has shown that he cannot, then he's a bust. His 55 or so plays were all nondescript and nothing that showed any potential ability in either the WCxQB or as a QB. I know that we have hopes that the light will come on at some point soon and he'll flash the ability he had in college, but it certainly hasn't happened so far. Not one flash worth. And additionally, even with slow-learners or slow-developers, you almost always see some kind of flash of their ability ??

As an aside, I was at Dan Marino's first TC practice back in the day. His first 7 on 7 pass play was a masterpiece. You could see that he was going to be special. He was not ready to start at QB at that point, but with those first plays, you could see that he had something that separated him from the other QBs in camp. Of course, it's unfair to compare White to Marino, and I don't mean it as a comparison other than pointing out that "flash" moment, when you saw something. Admittedly, I haven't seen White in person at TC or a game, just on film, but I have yet to see anything in the passing or run game that reminds me of his days at WVA... I'm not claiming to be any kind of expert or football guru, far from it. Just my personal opinion, based on what I see from this kid, but something is missing....I hope to God I'm wrong and he blows us all away this coming offseason and year...but tell me, has he really shown anything ??

 

Wouldn't surprise me, basically Henne and Pennington flip positions on the Qb depth Chart, White would be expected to play in the WC with the chance for Thiggy to bounce him if he doesn't perform at TC.

10 days until OTA's and I'm looking forward to see if Penny was blowing smoke or if Pat White really has improved, he also needs work on his footwork as a Running Back:

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stN4Ngb2SxA"]YouTube- Patrick White - Week 5 - 2009[/ame]

If folks will notice, when he drops back he sorta trips before he can reverse his momentum and run into the hole.

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MpSgh-jzhqc&feature=related"]YouTube- Pat White Miami Dolphins 33-Yard Run[/ame]

Arguably his best play from 09, but still one can tell that White's rb skills are touch crude as he doesn't run hard until he is in the open field, in the NFL holes close far to quickly for that to work consistently, he has to spend time with Rb Coach James Saxon imho.


[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhqHXMWd-0s&feature=PlayList&p=78AD4CB49EE45E13&playnext_from=PL&playnext=1&index=14"]YouTube- PFTV 4/29/09: Will Dolphins Fans Accept Pat White As A Quarterback Only?[/ame]

And, once again, "move Pat White to Wr" was predictable a yr ago.

 

I believe the Pats are due for job description changes this year:
1) Pat Turner: hybrid WR & TE RedZone threat, TE will be his ticket to stick in the up-cming season, shades of the Martin switch in GreenBay before he came to Miami
(2) Pat White: (a) Special/Teams ( returns, holder, punter, trick plays) could be used @ scat back (passing/running options) WR & Slot on the receiving corp,once again, opens options
(c) Unconventional Offense & 4th string emergency back up QB. versatility will be his ticket to stick, becoming a passing/running unconventional threat assure him of a roster spot. can always use an energy 4th string back-up QB, especially late in the season
they will have to find their way quickly, make their bones in 2010

 

Why would White as the #2 mean Henne and Penny would flip positions on the depth chart?. What you're saying is if White is #2, then Penny is the #1. That makes no sense at all.

 

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMAF_ktK2e8&feature=related"]YouTube- Pat White Drafted by the Miami Dolphins[/ame]


They show some highlights of White throwing the ball, he hits his man on the out route consistently the ball has good velocity and accuracy, yet against Pitt he looked like a noodle armed Qb on his one pass.

 

Chad Henne as the starter

Pat White as the WC Qb and the #2 Qb

Pennington as the #3 Qb if Henne goes down.

To start 2009 Pennington was the #1 Qb, White the #2 and Henne the #3, in 2010...they flip positions...see what I did there?

 

White is not a NFL conventional QB, he will have to find other options :yes:
our QB Stable:
the Iceman, Chad Pennington, the Thigpen, Pat White as an emergency option

 

Rotoworld is probably right here, the thing is bro they arent carrying 4 active Qb's on gameday, someone is going to be a healthy scratch, and most likely game in and game out, it will be White.....I dont see how he even makes the team....it is a waste of money at this point...unless he switches to WR, but even then I would much rather give Turner a crack, than White...

 

they will both get every chance to re-make themselves in a Dolphin uniform in 2010

 

C'mon now bro. White was the #2 in 2009 based on a technicality. He had to be listed there to play in the wildcat. When Pennington went down in San Diego, who came in? Henne.

I've got to believe that Tyler Thigpen will be on the QB depth chart somewhere, so that probably means it's going to come down to Pennington or White. Which one leaves and/or what does White's new position become? I can't see the front office giving up on White, I'll give you that, and I think he can have a specified set of packages to have success with (i.e. certain wildcat packages, the option role from the first New England game, trick plays), but I think my gripe with it will be if that's all that White proves to be successful with. You should get more from a 2nd round pick than just specified packages.

 

Iam tellin ya, Irish needs to have his *** kicked one time, lol...iam serious...at this point and time, I have no idea what we have as a General Manager...we want bigger olineman yet we sign Smiley to a 25 million dollar contract?...Wilford, Eric Green, Wilson...I really, really would like to know who made those decisions, because those are 4 players that I personally was not thrilled about when we signed them..

The only thing he's got going for him at this point is the fact that he may of hit the jackpot taking the combination of Jake and Henne over Just Matt ryan..

 

That was by design though RF4, they are using the #3 Qb rule to it's maximum effect by designating White the #2 Qb and using him during games.

Just what do you expect from a #2 Qb? They typically hold clipboards and wear their hats to the back and have great golf games, they don't run the Option or the WildCat or what have you.

White does have to show some things during this Preseason, like much less hesitation, more explosiveness and better passing accuracy, that could be as easily Rookieness showing through last yr, however he is no longer a Rookie, his game has to improve or Thiggy holding a clipboard and wearing a Dolphins hat and never playing will appear to be the better option compared to White producing next to nothing as the WC/#2 Qb.

 

I expect my #2 QB to come in and win games if my #1 goes down. Let's assume the worst; God forbid Henne breaks his leg againts the Bills week one. Do you really want to throw Pat White to the Vikings pass-rush week 2? Heck no. Do you want Chad Pennington in there? If healthy, yes, but that's iffy at this point. If that's the case, then Tyler Thigpen is your best chance to win the game. We can list Pat White at #2 to play the wildcat and specialty packages, but for all intents and purposes, Tyler Thigpen is your best bet to come in and win that game unless Chad Pennington's 100% healthy.

 

You could not be more wrong if you tried

 

I think we have to look at that from the 2008 perspective rather than 2010.

One thing we know about Parcells is that he builds from the line of scrimmage.

Coming off 1-15 and having one of the worst offensive line's in football, you don't always have the luxury of pursuing your prototypes.

Smiley is a bit small for us and had a long history of injury. But he was a highly experienced veteran who also happens to be one of the league's better pulling guards. I can't recall that class completely, but Smiley was one of if not the top offensive lineman available.

Remember, Miami was considering filling the open left tackle spot via the draft (Jake Long) and the smallish center (Satele) was entering his second year (third ever as a full-time center) following a rookie season in which he didn't even make the line calls. Not to mention the problems elsewhere on the line and the inherent lack of depth.

They really, really needed capable veteran stability at that position. So they made sure they got Smiley at midnight.

**Notice how we tend to do that at positions of extreme need (Dansby)**

Smiley was the first block in reconstruction the Miami offensive line. He played pretty well and provided excellent veteran leadership.

Two years later, the Dolphins have young veterans across the line and starting-caliber depth behind it. Now they have the luxury of pursing exactly what they want. In 2008, most of the interior line was small. Now you see tackle-size guys in there.

Think of it like the quarterback position on a rebuilding team, where they sign a veteran to hold the fort while they develop a hand-picked, prototype rookie.

From that perspective, the Dolphins got a good return on their investment in Smiley.

No front office is perfect. They all miss. They all make mistakes. But I feel like this one has gotten it right a lot more than its gotten it wrong.

 

he's sooo tiny,i just wanna put him in my pocket!

 

Such a development would mean things are either going really good or really bad for the Dolphins.

Right now he's #4 as a QB. He's got to prove he's better than Thigpen in some facet of the game. Right now I don't think he is.

 

Well, let's flip that question around:

Chad Henne stays perfectly healthy all season, do you really want a #2 Qb whose only contribution is charting plays and being a scratch handicap Golfer?

Or do you want a #2 Qb who can offer offensive production on a week to week basis?

Take your Vikings example, chances are excellent the "Williams Wall" will be down for repairs in Wk #2, do you think it would be helpful if we ran the WC or PatCat that week? Their running defense will clearly suffer that game, how would Thigpen take advantage of that situation?

Besides holding a clipboard and wearing a headset that is to say.

 

i have said this very same thing many times and people still don't seem to get it. white as a #2 would be a disaster and pennington is the #3 now for a reason. he is not here to go in and be the backup qb he is a teacher these days. besides his arm could be a ghost for all we know at this point.
thigpen is absolutely our best option as the backup QB.

 

I agree with this by all means. As I said, you can go ahead and list Pat White as the #2 QB to run the wildcat, trick plays, specialty packages, etc. and/or move/list him to/at another position where he's active on gamedays to do those things - my main gripe is that that's probably not the value you want out of your 2nd round pick, especially considering this front office has found a starting QB (Henne), a starting CB (Smith) and what looks to be a starting OLB (Misi) in that same round.

But, if Henne was hurt, I'm starting Thigpen 10 out of 10 times over Pat White.

 

um we do have running backs padre :wink2:

 

Depends on whether or not the Bill Polian theory that players make their greatest improvements from Yr 1 to Yr 2 applies to Pat White the all around player.

If it does then he could earn his worth.

And allow me to show what I think White the Rb problem is adjusting to the NFL:

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stN4Ngb2SxA"]YouTube- Patrick White - Week 5 - 2009[/ame]

I posted that earlier pointing out his footwork was sloppy.

Now check out his WVa plays:

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9cURDu0_ss"]YouTube- Pat White: Four Plays to Greatness[/ame]

Same sort of runs on the first two highlights, straight up the middle (the 4th play is a nice throw into a tight window)

The difference between the Jets and the College defenses?

Notice how quickly that hole closes, the Dolphins Oline parted the Jest Dline, the hole was huge, but that small hesitation on White's part due to sloppy footwork and the speed of the Jest D simply snapped that hole closed before he could reach his best gear.

Pat White has to show he can run much harder and with more certainty, the stuff he got away with at WVa just won't work in the NFL if he doesn't improve his game..and that is just running the ball.

Eegads, the guy throws two TD's and two Int's and now he is Dan Marino awaiting his chance to start?

Henne goes down and Pennington steps in 10 times out of 10.

 

All excellent points boss, and that is the name of the game in scouting personell, to be more right then wrong, however, its hard for me to quantify what kind of job he's doing when he has a football genious giving him advice ya know?...Just speculation on my part, but I have a hard time believing that Parcells iniatiated the scouting for the services of Green, Wilson,Smiley, and Wilford...Those choices scream Ireland to me, and, I'am still a little bitter about his lack of couth and judgement in the Dez situation, maybe the embarrassment he has caused our franchise will check him in the human relations dept.

All that being said, I have so much respect for Parcells, that if he has chosen this man to be the man, he must see tremendous potential..

Question for ya brother, do you know how Ireland and Parcells got to know each other? was Ireland in Dallas already when Parcells got there,I don't recall their history.