I want to start off this thread saying that I pray to God for a full recovery of Pat White.
I have been an opponent of the 2nd round pick on White since draft day. That is neither here nor there now. He is a Miami Dolphin and I will always hope he succeeds.
However, his injury is on the shoulders of our coaching staff. The fact of the matter is Pat was not ready to play in the NFL. When you put a 190 pound person into an NFL before he is mentally or physically ready and call plays that let him take shots it is not a good recipe.
Pat was not ready to throw the ball in an NFL game, the box was loaded with a tenacious run defense, and a horrific injury happened. Yes, it was a freak play and I by no means believe it was intentional. Regardless you were risking some type of injury to Pat in this situation.
This needs to be on the conscience of our coaching staff.
Page 1 of 2
-
Its on the shoulders of the GAME OF FOOTBALL nothing else. Please lets stop with the dramatics...its football, he was a football player.
He played the play hard, he was tripped by the defender, falling off balance, got tackled with a hit...him being off balance and unable to asorb the blow had more to do with that anything else.
Please lets use common sense and less emotion to define what happens on this field of play.dolphindebby, steveincolorado, finfansince72 and 15 others like this. -
our coaching staff told ike taylor to launch his head into White's? of course whenever you put a player outthere you are risking injury, but that kind of play is gonna result in an injury to a lot if not most players. White's mental preparation and size has nothing to do with it.
Darren Sproles weighs 181 pounds, hes just fine in the NFL. -
While I agree the coaching staff wanted to take a look at Pat White, I don't think his injury is their fault.
White isn't the only 190 lb player in the NFL, and there are plenty of WR and DBs that take much bigger hits than that on a play by play basis. White just was the victim of bad luck.
I do hope he is OK, I never like to see that happen.late again and JimToss like this. -
Teach the kid how to slide please.....wasn't he a baseball player?
I hope he's ok, and look forward to seeing him develop. That was a nasty hit laid on him by a historically dirty team, just ask Carson Palmer! -
Probably a fine, but bad luck for PW more than anything else.
Geez this team has ZERO quit, amazing...come on Miami.resnor likes this. -
-
Pat White had no business coming out to play QB, period. If Henne was injured they have a much more experienced player on the sideline.
The injury isn't on the coaching staff.....their mistake was blowing a chance to win this game.
I hope he has a full recover and the staff has the brains to start teaching him how to catch a pass. Otherwise it's one of the most wasted 2nd round picks I've ever seen. Eddie Moore type bad..... -
Ronnie Bass, resnor and jetssuck like this.
-
In the NFL, we call those WR's, or busted picks..... -
While I'm very sorry to see what happened to Pat White, it's just the game of football unfortunately.
He's an NFL player, enrolled in the NFL draft, and went through the training camps the same way as everyone else. Unfortunately, he just happens to not have that much mass on him, took a very unlucky hit.
I promise you that if you asked him if he wanted to be in the game with Henne having to come out, he'd say yes, and play. From everything I've read, and seen about this kid he's a fighter. And to suggest he wasn't mentally ready to put himself on the line for this team is kind of an insult.
I truly hope he has a speedy recovery, and if we learn nothing out of this, it's that the boy is tough as nails, and pretty darn fearless.eric likes this. -
-
The hit didn't seem to be malicious on Taylor's part. Looks like he was going shoulder to shoulder.
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdakK8ocyq0"]YouTube- Pat White Injured on Helmet to Helmet Hit By Ike Taylor. Steelers vs. Dolphins[/ame]
Hope White's OK.steveincolorado likes this. -
Silverphin, mullingan, eric and 1 other person like this.
-
This post is the biggest bit of irony I have read for some time. Just yesterday many of you stated that the Fins should bench Henne in the second half and turn White loose so we could intentionally lose and pick up a better draft spot, now you guys are saying the coaches should have known better than doing just that.
Shame on all of you; hopefully you are praying for Pat White. -
I have to disagree with you on this one. The game of football is an extremely violent contact sport. If he was not ready to play the game, he would not be here. We may agree or disagree about whether he should have been drafted in the second round or not but that does not matter. He could have been on any team, playing in any position and been injured. It was a clean play and a hard hit. I hope that Pat White recovers fully and comes back next year ready to play, but the fault for his injury falls on no one, sometimes stuff just happens.
-
Its the nature of the beast.
-
OK, we can blame the coaching staff for a lot of things but this is a bit of a reach IMO.
-
First off, my prayers go out to Pat White. Hope the hit looked worse than it actually was, and that he makes a complete and speedy recovery.
Secondly, IMO the hit was not dirty. Illegal? Well, from the "helmet to helmet" rule...yes? And, as such, I'm sure Taylor will be fined.
Lastly, how can anyone place blame on a player getting hurt? That just makes no sense to me whatsoever. Players play. And, as such they are susceptible to injury. It's just part of the game.
JMHO... -
I hope to God Pat White has a full and quick recovery...but the fact that there was no flag thrown for helmet to helmet contact is a load of crap...and the CBS announcer...the most ignorant sportscaster ever...said, "Pat White is a football player, helmet to helmet contact is just a simple part of the game." Are you kidding me!? :no:
-
-
White accepted the second string QB position and he also has to accept the risk that goes with that responsibility. I hope he is not injured seriously but there shouldn't be any blame on the coaches for a second round QB getting hurt coming in to relieve an injured starter.
-
it should be completely on the shoulders of Ike Taylor for an illegal hit by leading with his helmet... And why was there no flag! He'll certainly be fined
-
thats the same type of hit gibril wilson tries to put on everyone. the only difference is guys usually bounce off of wilson and keep on going for plenty more yards.
if they want to stop these types of injuries, they need to ban that style of tackling. unfortunately that same style of tackling usually makes some nice highlight hits that dont cause injury.NoCalFinFan likes this. -
http://www.palmbeachpost.com/sports/dolphins/pat-white-carted-off-field-after-a-head-160471.html
White is at a hospital having tests and should be OK, according to a source familiar with the situation. White might stay overnight for observation. -
The staff should have red-shirted White this season. He wasn't ready to play this season and the coaching staff should have recognized them. I think they felt pressured into using him or at the very least thought he was something that he has turned out not to be.
JimToss likes this. -
Absolutely disagree. Pat White declared for the draft, he decided to play this sport he gets everything that comes with it good and bad.
100% Pat White's decision to be a football player.
This is on nobody except him for making that choice to sign the contract.2socks likes this. -
Do you blame the Patriot staff for playing Welker?
Football players get hurt, we never want to see it, but it happens.Crappy Tipper likes this. -
-
First off I want to say that I hope Pat has a speedy recovery. It was a very scary hit and I'm glad to hear that he is doing alright. Regarding the coaching staff, I have been very disappointed in them this season. They did a good job last season and now it seems they have taken a couple steps back. We all knew it wasn't going to be easy this season with the NFL's hardest schedule. But seriously stop and think back to how many times this season you could do nothing but shake your head in disbelief. Granted, there are a few positions that need to be improved. Our team isn't complete yet. I just want the coaches to be evaluated just as hard as the players.
gunn34 likes this.
Page 1 of 2