I think one of our clear needs that we can all agree on is RDE. A true edge threat to compliment Wake and be a disruptive terror on the line...
However... when I look at the majority of the top 43 DE prospects, from the limited amount I've seen of them... it looks like almost all of them seemed to play at LDE in college, and or looks to be an LDE in the pros. Mingo, Werner, Margus Hunt, Sam Montgomery (played RDE opposite Mingo, but IMO looks more like a LDE than RDE in the NFL.), Alex Okafor, etc.
Besides Tank Carradine... who are the other pure RDE edge rushing prospects that can explosively get after the QB?
-
Dion Jordan and Ensah, which is why they will both be top 10, probably Top 5 picks.
-
If that's the case... it moves Tank higher on the priority list for me... -
Jordan will go #2 to Jacksonville IMO to play the wide 9.
-
I love Werner @ 12, Watson @ 22 and Hopkins @ 180. Go Noles.
-
Any thoughts regarding Trevardo Williams in the 3-5 region as a nickel rusher from the right end spot? Could also hopefully develop as a LB. Kind of like how the coaching staff seem to be approaching Kaddu, only in Williams' case he has the production and physical ability to suggest he might be a better bet. Of course I've never a actually seen the guy play so I thought I'd ask those in the know :)
FinNasty likes this. -
-
Carradine would be my pick at 12, that's what I hope we do ultimately. I think Werner would be good at RDE too; his strength is his get-off at the snap with that first step and also reading plays. Whether we pick Tank/Werner or not, I also like Corey Lemonier as a nickel-type guy. 2012 production at Auburn not quite where you want it, but the rest of his DLine was god-awful; his 2011 was a lot better due to him having solid players with him on that unit. He's got great explosion and is a physical freak. I'd take him in the 2nd.
Trevardo Williams interests me some, probably in the 4th. Undersized, but great production at UConn. There are 3 Huskies I would really like on the phins...in order: Sio Moore (2nd), Dwayne Gratz (3rd), and Williams.
Devin Taylor is an option for RDE as well. He played LDE at SoCar, but moved to the right at the shrine game(?) where he played really well - albeit against meh competition, imo. Huge, lanky frame with nice agility. Maybe 2b or 3rd? I'd be in favor of him if we don't take Tank. Cornelius Washington had a nice seniorbowl week too, coming off the right side.
I want to take two pass-rushers early in the draft. I like the depth this year and, simply, I want to attack the other teams' most important player. Tank/Werner/Taylor & Lemonier/Washington/Williams. Get a more 4-3 size guy and one of these faster nickel types. -
Actually Werner and and Carradine flipped lde and rde positions quite often in the 2012 season, and in 2011 he took maybe 20% of his snaps on the other side even lining up in the middle on occasion. -
-
No your memory serves you correctly. It is an aspect of Werner's game that has been pretty much completely overlooked and gives even less credence to his average measurables.
see 2011 highlights, the dude is making plays from wherever he lines up
[video=youtube;WtP-K5E3UAY]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WtP-K5E3UAY[/video]smahtaz likes this. -
Tank Carradine, Bjoern Werner, Dion Jordan, Alex Okafor, Devin Taylor, Cornelius Washington, Barkevious Mingo and Corey Lemonier can all probably play RDE.
Although I would note with Dion Jordan you might be better off playing him as a linebacker.
Some guys are not side-specific, some guys are. There isn't necessarily a rhyme or reason to it. Just like with offensive tackles and guards. Some guys one side is just as good as another. Some guys move to the other side and they're like lost puppies. The important thing to me is whether I've seen you demonstrate proficiency on the right side, even if you play left. Do I see the same player? Am I seeing the same results?
Bjoern Werner played left side a lot in college but also played on the right side and was a more efficient pass rusher from that right side. This leads me to believe he could easily switch.
Devin Taylor's physical skill set and playing style translates better to the right side than the left side. His production started to fall when Jadaveon Clowney arrived and Clowney is pretty exclusively a right side pass rusher. Prior to that I think Taylor played right side more often than you see now (which is practically never). He showed up at the Shrine Game and played right side again and had one of the most dominant individual All Star game performances I've seen since Brandon Marshall (Hula Bowl), Marques Colston (Shrine Game) and Phil Rivers (Senior Bowl).
Cornelius Washington is begging to be used wide and allowed to convert speed to power against offensive tackles all day long. The best side for him to do that is going to be the right side and that's where he had a very big impact on the Senior Bowl. So again this is an example of a guy that I've seen not only play on the right side, play play particularly well there.
Alex Okafor is first and foremost an accomplished, savvy, extremely effective pass rusher. Those you usually put on the right side.
Barkevious Mingo played left while Sam Montgomery played right. I cannot say whether Mingo will be one of those guys that just can't "get it" on the right side as opposed to left. I don't know that. It's yet to be discovered.Bpk, smahtaz, Alex13 and 1 other person like this. -
Awesome info CK! This is a position I am really starting to dive into as I cram for next week lol.
What are your thoughts on Damontre Moore from TA&M? He's looked pretty impressive from the little bit I've seen? -
I dislike him a lot. I disliked him a lot when everyone were singing his praises and Todd McShay was saying he could go #2 or maybe even #1 overall. He's got really good ability to move in space. He's explosive in his direction changes and acceleration from a standup position, he's athletic (despite poor workout showings), and he makes most of his plays using those qualities along with his motor.
But when push comes to shove he just doesn't beat offensive tackles and blockers, even lesser blockers like tight ends and backs. I've seen a 185 lbs wide receiver tie him up in blocking once. He's physically weak in the upper body. I've been saying that a while, before he only did a meager 12 bench reps at the Combine.
I would definitely consider the guy as a 3-4 Outside Linebacker and actually a pretty good one. There are off field issues to weed through, including reports of laziness and bad work ethic which had to be worsened when he only did 12 bench reps. But as a motor guy, a guy that can run around and make plays a number of different ways, I think you'd potentially take him in the 2nd round as long as certain other guys are off the board. One of those is Zeke Ansah. I'm not a huge fan of Ansah but he's a lot like Moore only he has a little bit better excuse for his lack of true pass rush success, and he's bigger, stronger and more athletic. -
Lavar Edwards has played both sides, but he's been effective as RDE.
-
-
I think it is a bit more than a right/left side issue. Not only do they need a right defensive end, they need one in the physical profile typical left defensive end. It's not impossible but it narrows down the field to a significant degree.
-
They aren't going to run a defense with two ends split at wide techniques in the base package. It's possible that some of the specific elements of the defense has them relax the size element, but I'd be pretty shocked if they spent significant resources on a draft pick under 270lbs. and can't punch above his weight class in terms of strength and run defense. -
This is the guy I want.
Ben Volin @BenVolinPBP3m
RT @JasonLaCanfora Auburn DE Cory Lemonier having a private visit and workout with the Fins, starting with dinner with team officials toniteBpk likes this. -
I think the most likely is a short-term veteran Nickel sub, develop what they have, and kick the can down the road
edit- lol soon as I post this invid posts the Lemonier thing. -
-
What we're missing, like Disgustipate mentioned, is an extra rush end when we're in nickel. Outside of that we'd either need to do one of two things, draft a jumbo end with rare Watt or Campbell type talent or a hybrid linebacker with significant pass rush ability. -
Also, I think the "nickle rusher" can't just be a guy that can only play against the pass. With as much as you need to play nickle, they have to be able to set the edge as well.
So, I think that role is much bigger than you seem to believe (or at least bigger than I'm interpreting your post to indicate). And that role warrants a pretty significant investment IMO. -
Seattle's d-line is similar to ours as well (schematically), no?
-
I think the Dolphins defensive fronts are a little screwy because of Cameron Wake being a left-side only guy. This defense you'd expect to use a lot of "Under" fronts with Odrick lined up on the strong side covered by blockers and Misi aligned over the tight end on the line of scrimmage, but that would generally involve them being on the defensive left side. Because of Wake you get a lot more situations where Odrick is lined up wider than he probably should be because he's on the weak side.
It's a little bit inefficient, but it was hardly a big problem last year.
-
You might see more and more teams willing to spend more on Nickel substitutes(Seahawks arguably did with Bruce Irvin last year but not sure that applies as Chris Clemons might have been on his way out in general), but I'm not sure you break the bank. -
Devin Taylor is very interesting as well imo.Bpk likes this. -
Not to mention we have guys who can set the edge in base defense, so stopping the run isn't really an issue for us to where we need to prioritize an end who can start from day one and do it all; IMO that's overkill at the moment, which is why Washington could be a great late 2nd or 3rd round pick b/c he has a ton of upside and we can take the time to groom him as Wake's heir. What could also improve our pass rush in base defense vs pass happy teams w/o having to sacrifice much vs the run if we add another defensive tackle capable of applying pressure who can sub in for Soliai. Of course we could still grab a pass rusher to supplement the edge.