Thoughts on the Dolphins Titans Game
49 replies
This was a devastating loss at the worst possible time for Miami, and it should essentially mean that our season is over. We're 8-8 going into a home game with the Pats that will decide whether this is a winning or a losing season, and somehow I'm more than content with that.
The 7-game winning streak was awesome and we were all drinking the kool-aid towards the end there, but the fact of the matter is that this team is just too stripped down on offense to do much with the football. Asking this team to play in the cold rain, playing from behind, against a bruising running game...the writing was on the wall very early that we wouldn't get back into this one.
However, I do want to talk a little bit about the game anyway, because it wasn't as one-sided as the score indicated. We had several long drives that we just couldn't finish, and our defense was not as big of a factor since we're built to play with the lead. Man, the game we could have seen if Miami took the lead early and Tannehill was forced to beat us...
The refs hurt us some today as well- the PI on Parker that wasn't called in the red zone, the fumble recovery that the Titans kept, the PI on Needham where he was getting tackled. It's easy to see those things in a loss but it's not an excuse- on this 7-game win streak, we've outplayed the refs and bad calls like that were easily forgotten.
It doesn't make it any easier today, but still, we had some moments to shine and they just didn't shake out.
So as we sit at .500 and hope for four other AFC teams to choke and let us in the playoffs, I think we'll see this team playing with a heck of a lot of pride against the Pats. To me, the season hinges on it- go 9-8 and call it business as usual, or go 8-9 and start asking some tough questions in that front office.
This offensive line, there's just no excuse for protection that horrible. There were a few plays today with a solid pocket and I'm hoping that we can eventually see that with some regularity from this starting five. But man, looking back and seeing that we're going to miss the playoffs by one win...and we had SO MANY close games where we couldn't finish out the go-ahead score...a loss to the Pats would put Grier back on the hot seat for me.
Anyway, I know we have another week left but it was a great season, my friends...lots of ups and downs with several records set along the way as well. Speaking of which- I didn't watch the last few minutes of the game; did Waddle break the rookie reception record?
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
Can't write up a summary of the game without mentioning Tua. If there's one primary reason we lost today it was him. Not good. We need a QB that can help us win in adverse conditions. Tua hasn't shown that this year. He did show it at least once last year (Arizona), but today was on him more than anything else, not the OL or refs etc. even though there is some stuff to complain about there too.
"cbrad wrote:
Can't write up a summary of the game without mentioning Tua. If there's one primary reason we lost today it was him. Not good. We need a QB that can help us win in adverse conditions. Tua hasn't shown that this year. He did show it at least once last year (Arizona), but today was on him more than anything else, not the OL or refs etc. even though there is some stuff to complain about there too.
Tua was inconsistent today and missed several open receivers, but in each and every instance he was also running for his life. I completely agree that Tua played poorly but everyone also needs to realize that Tua has no business rating in at "above average" with a historically awful offensive line. He has played exceptional with very little help, and I just can't bash the kid for fumbling in a monsoon or throwing a late pick (I had turned the game off by then, so I can't comment there).
Winning football games at any level comes down to winning in the trenches.
"KeyFin wrote:
Tua was inconsistent today and missed several open receivers, but in each and every instance he was also running for his life. I completely agree that Tua played poorly but everyone also needs to realize that Tua has no business rating in at "above average" with a historically awful offensive line. He has played exceptional with very little help, and I just can't bash the kid for fumbling in a monsoon or throwing a late pick (I had turned the game off by then, so I can't comment there).
No the OL was a lot better today than earlier in the season. This was mostly on Tua. He had far too many bad throws. And there are quite a few QBs that overcome bad OL. We need one of those. Tua has shown he can do that in certain games, so I don't for once think he can't, but today was not an OL issue it was primarily the QB.
I just dont see how Tua is going to drastically change into a franchise quarterback next year. You all are telling me this guy, basically has played the same since last season, this same guy is going to evolve into something we have yet seen from him, on year 3?
okay………. Ive recalled that happening once in the last 20 years and that was Drew Brees in year 4 with the Chargers
"Vertical Limit wrote:
I just dont see how Tua is going to drastically change into a franchise quarterback next year. You all are telling me this guy, basically has played the same since last season, this same guy is going to evolve into something we have yet seen from him, on year 3?
okay………. Ive recalled that happening once in the last 20 years and that was Drew Brees in year 4…
History shows some QBs can make that leap in year 3 or 4. So you can't give up too early. But you also shouldn't wait too long either. Oh, and there's no question Tua was better this year. He just played like crap today.
"cbrad wrote:
History shows some QBs can make that leap in year 3 or 4. So you can't give up too early. But you also shouldn't wait too long either.
History only has Drew Brees as that example. Name me other quarterbacks in the last 20 years that has taken that long to evolve?
"cbrad wrote:
No the OL was a lot better today than earlier in the season. This was mostly on Tua. He had far too many bad throws. And there are quite a few QBs that overcome bad OL. We need one of those. Tua has shown he can do that in certain games, so I don't for once think he can't, but today was not an OL issue it was primarily the QB.
They still weren't good.
Tua always had a hand in his face or was running for his life.
I disagree about it not being the offensive line.
Holland is a huge upgrade over McCain
I want to be alive, I am alive! Alive, I tell you! Mother, I love you, those are no longer just words. I want to hold you, I want to run in a stream, I want to taste ice cream but not just put it in my mouth and let it slide down my throat but really eat it. - Robot Morty
That was the Tua of old today, happy feet, nervous not in rhythm. He had one really good throw to Waddle, that doesn’t cut it though. I wanna see a good game against the Patriots.
The refs killed me today what a shit show.
Duke was good except that one drop. He was the only one who really shined on offense, that doesn’t cut it.
Strange play calling today too.
Can‘t win games when D is the one unit that came to play.
"Vertical Limit wrote:
History only has Drew Brees as that example. Name me other quarterbacks in the last 20 years that has taken that long to evolve?
Statistically most QBs improve from year 2 to year 3, and plateau at around 3-4. Some take even longer. Statistically the most impressive QB in history in terms of efficiency, Steve Young, took MANY years to show that.
Anyway, I'm not saying Tua will be elite, but he could become good enough. I wouldn't just give up after year 2. If he's like this after year 3 then yeah sure.
Sorry dude but there was nothing good about this game and this can't be a great season if we don't even make the playoffs. You can tell how far this franchise has fallen when you describe it that way after we only beat terrible teams. We didn't even dominate any team that had all their players.
The Dolphins are the softest team in the NFL. Tua hater starting 12/11/22.
Tua was bad today. With that being said, he didn't benefit from at least two (three?) drops and no fewer than two uncalled PIs. And for as much as I'm in his corner, being unable to play in inclement weather is a clear problem that he needs to overcome. I hope we keep him next season and put the pieces around him where he doesn't need to be a superstar to win most games.
Personally, folks who believe that a franchise QB can make a silk purse out of the sow's ear that is our offensive line are delusional. They also need to check their definition of "franchise QB". There are only about 12 of those for the entire 32 team league and consequently, they are in short supply. So, go ahead and give up on this quarterback and see if the next one will be better. Keep in mind, we've had 20+ starters since #13 retired, so if history is any indicator, the next guy who comes in won't be a hall of famer.
Criticizing what you have is one thing. Actually replacing it with something better? That's something else. So I suggest we actually fix the team before worrying about whether he's the liability. Otherwise, you can bet the next guy will be a liability too.
"cbrad wrote:
Statistically most QBs improve from year 2 to year 3, and plateau at around 3-4. Some take even longer. Statistically the most impressive QB in history in terms of efficiency, Steve Young, took MANY years to show that.
Anyway, I'm not saying Tua will be elite, but he could become good enough. I wouldn't just give up after year 2. If he's like this after year 3 then yeah sure.[/QUOT
My prediction Tua will either be traded or our backup next year.Watson will be the Qb.
I thought the offensive line didn't play bad at all. Tua wasn't good. The play calling was even worse. The officiating was even worse than that.
Tannehill was way too comfortable way too early in the game. He did just what he needed to do, hand the ball off and throw in a couple of play action passes. That's where he excels.
Where was Waddle all game? It's like they expected Tennessee to focus on him all game. Parker's body language is off putting on plays that he can't make. If the ball is placed perfectly he is going to catch it though. He gets no separation and is always challenged. He doesn't win off the ball alot.
They finally let Tua take a shot down field and he throws a perfect dime to Waddle. The next play call is a mind boggling feat of ineptitude, a reverse flea flicker pass that didn't work and eventually killed all momentum of that drive and ended the game essentially.
"Vertical Limit wrote:
History only has Drew Brees as that example. Name me other quarterbacks in the last 20 years that has taken that long to evolve?
Ryan Tannehill.
"Vertical Limit wrote:
History only has Drew Brees as that example. Name me other quarterbacks in the last 20 years that has taken that long to evolve?
Ryan tannehill if you say Tuas better at this point our lying. He has improved a lot since leaving Miami. And I wanted TUA
"texanphinatic wrote:
Ryan Tannehill.
What’s his record in Tenn without Henry?
🎃
"jdallen1222 wrote:
What’s his record in Tenn without Henry?
Better than without AJ Brown
Holland is a huge upgrade over McCain
I want to be alive, I am alive! Alive, I tell you! Mother, I love you, those are no longer just words. I want to hold you, I want to run in a stream, I want to taste ice cream but not just put it in my mouth and let it slide down my throat but really eat it. - Robot Morty
"jdallen1222 wrote:
What’s his record in Tenn without Henry?
Yeah, no one should be arguing that we would somehow be better with Tannehill this year. Even after today his overall rating is 86.3 when league average is 90.8, his rating with Henry is 90.2 (still a tad below average) and without Henry it's 82.0.
And if you're looking for a game that a QB "lost" this year, one of the best examples is Tannehill against Houston where he threw 4 INTs in crucial situations, and that's against a weak team. That's a much bigger "blame the QB" scenario than anything we saw today with Tua.
tua aint it and you can make whatever excuse you want, it won't make it true.
herbert had the 32nd ranked OL last year, and never looked this terrible.
"jdallen1222 wrote:
What’s his record in Tenn without Henry?
5-3. The real question you should be asking is what is the Titans record since Tannehill went to Tennessee versus the Dolphins record since trading Tannehill.
The Dolphins have been a subpar team since the early 2000’s. No one who is objective should dispute that. We have been hit garbage with a flash one season with Sparano and one season with Gase. Other than those two seasons, straight up garbage.
Everyone here got fed up with Tannehill…quarterback quarterback quarterback Tannehill sucks, he’s got to go. We’ll never win with him. Anyone with ANY objectivity should have felt as if they were smacked in the head with a shovel when Tannehill went to Tennessee, became the starter and took the Titans to the AFC Championship his first year there.
I know, I know, “That was Henry, not Tannehill.” Well then, explain to me why the Titans weren’t vying for the playoffs with Mariotta as the quarterback, huh?
The epiphany everyone should have had with Tannehill’s success in Tennessee is that we as a team SUCK. We’ve sucked for years and we’re going to continue to suck until the entire TEAM is rebuilt. Well that rebuild is the result of YEARS of neglect so it’s going to take a number of years to fix.
We were embarrassed today but defensively the team is good to go. Offensively? Ok, we drafted a quarterback with a subpar offensive line…a unit that the Dolphins have shown year after year the inability to produce a solid effective unit. We drafted a quarterback without a franchise running back, a back that averages 5+ yards per carry…a back that you can reliably hand the ball off to 20-25 times a game.
The Titans have just that! They have the offensive line…they have the franchise running back…all they needed was the right quarterback and they got it in Tannehill.
What has Miami done? Screw the offensive line. Need a quarterback…so he can run for his life. Screw a running back…running backs are irrelevant. Need a quarterback to put it all on his shoulders…again with no OL so he can run for his life.
Am I saying Tagovailoa is the answer? Nope. Am I saying Tagovailoa is the problem? Nope. What I’m saying is our entire offensive unit as a whole sucks, has sucked for years and will continue to suck until someone with half a functioning brain cells realizes that the offensive line is just as important as the quarterback…that the running back position is just as important as the quarterback. Our receiving corps needs shoring up but I emphasize those two areas as the most important, because until you have an offensive line that can hold the opposing defense at bay and open up running lanes…until you have a running back that can beat the crap out of opposing defenses running the ball, it doesn’t matter WHO you have at quarterback.
This entire organization needs revamping from the top down and get a GM in here that can assemble truly talented players and lure competent position coaches to help these players excel.
Until THIS happens, might as well change the team’s name to the Mediocre Dolphins because that’s all we’ll ever be

“The person you will spend the most time with in your life is yourself, so you better make sure you’re someone interesting”
"cbrad wrote:
Yeah, no one should be arguing that we would somehow be better with Tannehill this year. Even after today his overall rating is 86.3 when league average is 90.8, his rating with Henry is 90.2 (still a tad below average) and without Henry it's 82.0.
And if you're looking for a game that a QB "lost" this year, one of the best examples is Tannehill against Houston where he threw 4 INTs in crucial situations, and that's against a weak team. That's a much bigger "blame the QB" scenario than anything we saw today with Tua.
Please tell me I’m not reading this the way I am.
The Titans are going to the playoffs for the 3rd year in a row…AFC Championship and winning the AFC South 2 years in row and just secured the number 1 cede in the AFC (provided they don’t implode next week)…
And Tannehill STILL sucks? Is THAT what you’re saying?????

“The person you will spend the most time with in your life is yourself, so you better make sure you’re someone interesting”
I've been saying it for years. We are not going to win anything let alone any game of importance until we have a franchise quarterback on this roster. With that said, due to there being NO other options in the draft or free agency, I think the job is still Tua's going into next season. Keep upgrading the roster around him and hope for the best. Maybe we get lucky, I don't know. It's hard to look at this in any type of positive light. This is the second year in a row in week 17 that he has crapped the bed on us. I wont be fooled again. I like Tua, I'm still rooting for him, but this is an exact repeat of last season.
"The_Dark_Knight wrote:
Please tell me I’m not reading this the way I am.
The Titans are going to the playoffs for the 3rd year in a row…AFC Championship and winning the AFC South 2 years in row and just secured the number 1 cede in the AFC (provided they don’t implode next week)…
And Tannehill STILL sucks? Is THAT what you’re saying?????
This year yes. Not in 2019, he was elite then, and not in 2020 where he was way above average. But in 2021 he's a below average QB.